Dignan: Government lacks feedback loops because failure does not risk defunding
Aaron Dignan · Aaron Dignan: Change The Way You Work · Feb 7, 2023 · at 13:23
Aaron Dignan, founder of The Ready, explains to Shane Parrish why government institutions stagnate compared to market-driven corporations.
0:00 / 0:39exact quote · 39.2s
720p mp4 · rendered on demand · StarZero watermark
“The difference, though, is that there are very few feedback loops for the government. So one of the early kind of theories that I pull from a lot of sociocracy and the guy that kind of created the modern version of it talked about feedback constantly as like the lifeblood of everything. And so not just feedback at a person to person level, but system to system and marketplace to marketplace. And so with government, the feedback loops tend to be really, really poor because it has to be there. It's going to be there forever. To your point, there's a time horizon to it. But also, it doesn't really get, like, defunded next year if it doesn't do a good job. But a public company does.”
quote is from the automated transcript, cleaned for reading: filler sounds and stutters are removed, nothing is rephrased. names can be misheard (the analysis reads context, assessments check outside sources). how →
More from Aaron Dignan
Dignan: Command-and-control management no longer applies to the most interesting work
“Most of those contexts are well figured out and are not the center of the universe anymore. That's not where most of the interesting work is happening.”
Dignan: Leaders falsely assume the only alternative to chaos is bureaucracy
“Essentially, we lose our way because we believe in a false choice. So most people believe that the pattern of organizational evolution is from chaos to bureaucracy.”
Dignan: Corporations squash startup innovation by imposing their operating systems
“And then to finish the doom loop that we're talking about, you bring in those acquired companies with all that creativity and judgment, and you squash it by conforming them to your operating system. And then you start over. And that's essentially how the econo…”
Dignan: Organizations do not have values, only operating beliefs
“Because it's the reality is that human beings have values and can hold values, but organizations don't really, they have ways of operating and beliefs about how the world and reality works.”
Dignan: Leadership requires trading short-term performance for capability growth
“And now the idea is I want you to ensure continually growing capability, which is a totally different animal. And so continuing growing capability means I need a system that is learning all the time while it's executing. And that means I'm going to have to mak…”
Dignan: Consensus decision-making slows execution and creates average ideas
“The consensus view is great because it feels like family vibes. Everybody weighs in, everybody shapes it, everybody touches it, but it's slow. And worst of all, it makes the idea average. So, you know, a camel is a horse designed by committee. I don't know if …”