Assertion Supported AI assessment confidence: 90% certainty 4/5 debate potential 1/5

Shankar: Identity Priming Makes People Act Consistent with Their Perceived Labels

Maya Shankar · Maya Shankar: The Toolkit to Accomplish Your Hardest Goals · Jul 9, 2024 · at 13:39

Cognitive scientist Dr. Maya Shankar discusses behavioral science research on identity priming with Shane Parrish on The Knowledge Project.

0:00 / 0:26exact quote · 26.9s

720p mp4 · rendered on demand · StarZero watermark

“There is research on identity priming, which says that we do act in ways that are Consistent with our perceived identity or the identity we aspire to have, right? So when we see ourselves as a voter, we're more likely to vote. When we see ourselves as being, you know, eco-friendly, we're more likely to recycle. By the same token, if we see ourselves through these more negative labels, then we might also act in ways that align with that and needlessly hold ourselves back when it comes to making progress.”

quote is from the automated transcript, cleaned for reading: filler sounds and stutters are removed, nothing is rephrased. names can be misheard (the analysis reads context, assessments check outside sources). how →

The claim, plainly

Research on identity priming shows that individuals behave consistently with their perceived or aspirational identities, such that identifying as a voter or eco-friendly increases voting or recycling, while negative labels cause individuals to act in alignment with those limitations.

a quote alone can be ambiguous, so this restates it with the references and context of the conversation around it resolved. AI-written; the tape below the player is the source.

Assessment

Maya Shankar's claim accurately describes established lines of peer-reviewed behavioral science and psychological literature published prior to July 2024. Specifically: (1) Bryan et al. (2011, PNAS) demonstrated that noun-based identity priming ('being a voter') significantly increased voter turnout and registration compared to verb-based framing ('voting'); (2) Cornelissen et al. (2008) and Van der Werff, Steg, & Keizer (2013, 2014) demonstrated that activating environmental self-identity increases pro-environmental behaviors, including recycling and sustainable choices; and (3) classical labeling theory (Becker 1963, Lemert 1967) and stereotype threat literature (Steele & Aronson 1995) document that internalized negative labels and identity primes induce behaviors aligned with those negative expectations or limitations. While subsequent field replications of the voter-identity effect (e.g., Gerber et al., 2016) have found null effects under certain conditions, Shankar's statement accurately characterizes the findings and claims of the published identity priming research literature.

Bryan, Walton, Rogers, & Dweck (2011, PNAS) published randomized experiments showing 'voter' noun-identity framing significantly increased voter turnout over 'voting' verb framing.
Van der Werff, Steg, & Keizer (2013, 2014) showed priming environmental self-identity increased recycling intentions and energy conservation actions.
Cornelissen et al. (2008) showed cueing past eco-friendly behaviors activated environmental self-identity, increasing subsequent sustainable consumer choices.
Sociological and psychological literature on labeling theory and stereotype threat (e.g., Steele & Aronson 1995; Miller et al. 1975) shows negative labels and primed deficits impair performance and induce label-consistent behavior.

Checked against

[1] nih.gov [2] pnas.org [3] pnas.org [4] stanford.edu [5] columbia.edu [6] dokumen.pub [7] researchgate.net [8] researchgate.net

"Cornelissen" "identity" "ecological" OR "pro-environmental" OR "recycling" priming voter noun verb priming replication Gerber Bryan PNAS Bryan et al 2011 Motivating voter turnout by invoking the self PNAS "Bryan, Master, & Walton" "helping" OR "cheating" "noun" "van der Werff" "environmental self-identity" "priming" "labeling theory" OR "labeling" "negative labels" behavior experiment psychology

assessed as of 2026-09-03

This assessment is an AI reading of a public statement, made against the cited references with the confidence shown. It can be wrong. The quote, the tape and the references are all on this page; if something is off, use report an error below. full disclaimer →

Mentioned

identity priming

⚑ Spot an error? Report it

More from Maya Shankar

Insight

Shankar: Anchoring Identity to 'Why' Creates a More Resilient Sense of Self

“The challenge becomes, though, when you anchor yourself to something that is precarious in some way, and that's what I found with the violin. What I strive to do, because it's very much a works in progress, but I hope this resonates for your listeners, is to a…”

Maya Shankar Jul 9, 2024 ▶ 9:20 Maya Shankar: The Toolkit to Accomplish Your Hardest Goals

Insight

Shankar: Cultivating Layered Identities Protects Self-Worth Against Career Disruptions

“What I'm proposing is having multifaceted identities. So you have multiple layers of abstraction when it comes to where you derive meaning and how you define yourself. And so at one level, you can absolutely say, okay, I'm a lawyer, I'm a doctor, a stay at hom…”

Maya Shankar Jul 9, 2024 ▶ 15:38 Maya Shankar: The Toolkit to Accomplish Your Hardest Goals

Insight

Shankar: Self-identity narratives must be rooted in reality and external feedback

“So I really don't, I'm not okay with people telling themselves stories that are simply advantageous or promote psychological well-being, right? They have to be rooted in reality. They have to be to some degree vetted by the people in your life.”

Maya Shankar Jul 9, 2024 ▶ 17:14 Maya Shankar: The Toolkit to Accomplish Your Hardest Goals

Insight

Shankar: Group identity shapes beliefs more than data and facts

“Facts and science and evidence don't surface as much as they should in some of our debates, and it's because when we look at how it is that people form their attitudes and beliefs about the world, they're not simply basing it on What the data says. They're bas…”

Maya Shankar Jul 9, 2024 ▶ 19:50 Maya Shankar: The Toolkit to Accomplish Your Hardest Goals

Insight

Shankar: Fear of Social Ejection Prevents People From Updating Their Beliefs

“And if you feel too strong tribal membership, it can impede you from updating your point of view, because in that moment, You're not just asking yourself, do I believe in that X virus is real? What you're really asking is, do I belong to X group or not? Becaus…”

Maya Shankar Jul 9, 2024 ▶ 20:50 Maya Shankar: The Toolkit to Accomplish Your Hardest Goals

Insight

Shankar: Framing arguments within an opponent's moral values improves persuasion

“What we find is that grounding our arguments in moral terms that affirm rather than threaten the moral views of those we disagree with is far more effective at helping them Change their viewpoints.”

Maya Shankar Jul 9, 2024 ▶ 23:17 Maya Shankar: The Toolkit to Accomplish Your Hardest Goals

Shankar: Identity Priming Makes People Act Consistent with Their Perceived Labels

More from Maya Shankar

Turn any episode into a week of clips.