Hal Elrod Rewrote 'The Miracle Morning' Based on Negative Amazon Reviews
Charlie Hoehn · Charlie Hoehn: Write Something People Want to Read · Dec 10, 2024 · at 9:08
Charlie Hoehn describes how author Hal Elrod treated his book like software, modifying the text after negative reader feedback.
0:00 / 0:37exact quote · 37.9s
720p mp4 · rendered on demand · StarZero watermark
“Hal Elrod, who's based here in Austin, he did that with The Miracle Morning. And so in the first year, he promoted that book, sold like, 13,000 copies or something like that which is quite good for its first year. With every negative review that he got, he went back into the manuscript and made revisions so that that feedback couldn't be given again. So that review couldn't be given again. And he just kept doing that until the negative reviews stopped. And to date, it's sold millions of copies. I think in, he said in year six, it sold its millionth copy.”
quote is from the automated transcript, cleaned for reading: filler sounds and stutters are removed, nothing is rephrased. names can be misheard (the analysis reads context, assessments check outside sources). how →
More from Charlie Hoehn
Hoehn: Traditional publishing prevents authors from iterating on their books
“One of the reasons that I am reluctant to advocate for the traditional publishing process is, Like, your book is set in stone there. You might, if you're lucky, get a ten-year update, you know, the ten-year anniversary, but you're not going to touch that book …”
Authors Should Reject Traditional Publishing Deals Under $100,000
“If you can get a publisher to give you a 100,000 dollar advance or more, you should probably do it. I mean, if you have millions of followers, a hundred thousand's not enough, but, like, you get the general concept. You want them to have enough skin in the gam…”
Why Over 95% of Authors Should Avoid Traditional Publishing Deals
“For 95 plus percent of authors I talk to, I tell them, it doesn't really make sense for you to do that.”
James Clear Lost Roughly 3x Per Copy Traditionally Publishing 'Atomic Habits'
“I remember talking to James Clear and we were talking about how much he would have made had he gone the self-publishing route with Atomic Habits, and I did the math, and it was like, ah, it's about three X more per copy.”
Hoehn: Inexperienced first-time authors face higher risks self-publishing
“If it's your first go-round as an author and you don't know what you're doing, the likelihood that you'll step on a landmine that hurts your book during the self-publishing process is even higher than if you're working with a traditional publisher.”
Hoehn: Cheap Generalist Designers Always Produce Unremarkable Book Covers
“A lot of self-published authors are like, I'll go to Upwork, or I'll hit up my designer friend who puts together PowerPoints, and I'll pay them 500 bucks. And it always results in something unremarkable. You have to pay an artist, a book-covered designer speci…”