why aren't all 2,678 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 42 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Insight
Garber: Acquirers stall low-runway startups to buy them at 10% of value
“And the M&A, the real smart M&A people are saying, okay, yeah, let's kick some tires and we'll go for a test drive and we'll look over everything under the hood. And then they realize, okay, you're basically running out of money. I'm just gonna, again, same th…”
Insight
Garber: LPs Require 1x DPI Before Backing Subsequent Venture Funds
“You have to produce basically a one X DPI in whatever fund you're in that they've invested in to get them to invest in the next fund. It doesn't matter how well it's shaping up versus the vintage. It doesn't matter if it's top core, top top decile. It doesn't …”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Posner: AI will crush the traditional law firm partner-to-associate leverage pyramid
“So we think that right now the law firm model says you have one partner, you have five associates. And we think that pyramid or that leverage model may get squeezed a little bit and you may see roles and responsibilities changing.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Jeffrey: AI will not reduce code volume, just make code disposable
“There isn't going to be less code. The code just becomes less valuable throw away.”
Insight
Jeffrey: Slow Companies Will Be Outcompeted Even If Rivals Are Wrong
“And so like the risk to all these companies that are slow, Is that they're going to be outcompeted even if their competition is wrong, right?”
Opinion
Jeffrey: San Francisco Tech Often Struggles Exporting Products Globally
“And my experience is that San Francisco is sometimes bad at bringing the products to the rest of the world, not fully baked for what works in San Francisco.”
Insight
Jeffrey: Entry valuation does not matter for seminal power-law companies
“There's only so many large enough seminal companies in an era that you're either in them or you're not. And if you're in them, then the valuation doesn't matter.”
Opinion
Jeffrey: Startup transformation windows have compressed to three months
“You're seeing, you know, companies have to go through this walk through the desert and everything they need to do, which they used to have like six months to a year to do. They probably have three months.”
Opinion
Jeffrey: AI Terminal Prompts Cannot Replace Last-Mile Product Development
“I don't subscribe to the view that we're all going to sit at like a blinking terminal line with that blinking empty cursor and you'll be able to type anything in and it'll just happen, right? I think that that's I think that is an oversimplification of how har…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Cordoba: Every startup founder pivots their initial idea
“Because at the end of the day, we're going to end up pivoting. Find me one startup founder who hasn't pivoted. It just isn't real.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Cordoba: Most startup failures stem from founder breakups
“Well, and most, because I worked after I graduated, I worked for Berkeley Skydeck, and most of the, like, startups that fail, fail due to, like, founder breakups.”
Insight
Cordoba: Universities, not accelerators, are the primary centers for startup collisions
“I found that those four things tend to live in or around a university, or they live in or around some sort of central community that touches all of them. So accelerators serve this purpose on a micro scale, but really university is the biggest portion of this.”
Insight
Cordoba: AI lacks novelty; breakthrough ideas require human creative collisions
“They're not known for novelty. It is human creativity that does that, and you have to collide with the right people in order for those awesome ideas to emerge.”
Insight
Cordoba: Harvard-MIT lagged Silicon Valley due to concentrated, non-diverse networks
“Even if you look at part of my research in undergrad, so I looked at, okay, even on the East Coast, there's plenty of innovation, but the Harvard-MIT geographical region hasn't yielded the same outcomes as, say, the Stanford-Berkeley, Silicon Valley region, ri…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Cordoba: Future innovation will come from non-coastal, blue-collar industries
“I think that the future of innovation is going to come from the
Less flashy industries than what we've seen historically.
I believe it's going to come from the regions and areas that, as I, listen, I born and raised California, love the West Coast.
I do believ…”
Insight
Robinson: Debit fraud risk is simple velocity-based, not sophisticated AI
“And if you look and study risk in our business, it's not traditional sophisticated AI type fraud. It's simple velocity based fraud. Additionally, a lot of the banks, a lot of the issuers of the cards have tools you can use. So you combine what the network prov…”
What-if
Robinson: E-commerce would not exist without Visa and Mastercard brands
“And so the Visa brand and MasterCard brands are much more than just a payment rail. They're this consumer warm blanket that created e-commerce. Without those brands, you'd never enter your dark card and have Amazon ship your product.”
Opinion
Robinson: Visa and Mastercard offer brand value stablecoins cannot easily disrupt
“It may be lower costs, but I would argue Visa and MasterCard can make the cost practically zero if they wanted to, but their brands offer much more value than just pushing money to someone.”
Opinion
Robinson: Most financial innovation originates in the US, not abroad
“Speaking as an arrogant American, most, most financial innovation comes to the United States. Maybe you could argue about infrastructure, which may come from over in Europe or India, but if you look at financial innovation, it's come here, right?”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Robinson: Everyday payroll fintech products have crushed US payday lending
“Payroll is now every day, okay? Which has crushed payday lending in this country, right?”
Opinion
Robinson: AI will not replace human relationships in enterprise sales
“You have to have value, and AI can communicate the value, right? But in the end, they want to do business with the person, and so I don't think that'll be replaced.”
Insight
Gandhi: Media Does Not Just Influence Decisions; It Is Human Cognition
“So so media is not something that influences our decisions. Media is us and hence extremely crucial that we look at it with the same level of integrity and Seriousness that we look at our brains with.”
Opinion
Memon: Zuckerberg and Musk Have Privatized Society's Information Pathways
“Suddenly the information pathways are not public. The information pathways become private. So Zuckerberg, Elon, they start owning our information pathways. Now the conversation is not public anymore.”
Insight
Gandhi: Credentialed Institutions Can Make Simulated Futures Come True
“So if you make, if you imagine, if you simulate a future, and if you have the right amount of credentials, You can make that future come true by the very virtue of giving a neutral, a seemingly neutral advice, a seemingly neutral prophecy.”
Insight
Memon: Political Corruption Is a Systems Problem, Not Individual Moral Failure
“The system either picks for the most corruptible or corrupts. What we need to look at is, why is it that the positions of power make people behave this way or select for a certain kind of person? It is not the individual. The individual is a symptom of a much …”
Assertion Supported
Gandhi: History's Greatest Philosophers Were Heirs to Extreme Wealth
“More often than not, it has been observed from Buddha to Mahavi to Wittgenstein. They were all princes. You know, Wittgenstein was the son of the richest steel Baron of Europe. Some of the greatest philosophers of the last 2003 thousand years came from extreme…”
Insight
Gandhi: Human Values Are Inherited From the Future, Not the Past
“Values are things that you inherit from the future that we seek to build together.”
Insight
Memon: Modern Value Capture Happens at the IP Level, Not Fungible Services
“If you look at the value capture, most amount of value capture happens on the IP level. We need to export IP, not export services. Services are fungible, services are automatable in the modern world.”
Opinion
Chen: Fears of an AI 'SaaS-pocalypse' wiping out enterprise incumbents are overblown
“Now I think it's overblown, right? A lot of companies especially enterprise, have a lot of integrations. They build a lot of operational processes around some of these systems. This isn't a flip the switch and these companies disappear overnight. These compani…”
Insight
Modi: Skilled designers iterate faster and better than prompting AI
“There's still a huge delta between like, you know, a smart designer who knows what they're doing, making an improvement in a quick turn in about, you know, 30 minutes and exploring a few different options that accounts for the technical requirements of the pro…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Modi: Machines will never have the full context that humans possess
“The machine does not, and never will have full context that a person does.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Modi: No single AI foundation model will dominate the market
“Our belief is that there will not be a, my belief is that there won't be one model to rule them all. It's just impossible.”
Assertion Partly supported
Uber and Meta Cap Employee AI Coding Spending at 1500 Monthly
“Uber famously just put a 1500 dollar per employee cap on vibe coding per month. Meta's been reported to do the same.”
Assertion Supported
Modi: Investment banks are maintaining flat headcount while adopting AI
“So you're seeing the banks actually not do massive headcount reductions. They're actually staying flat adopting AI.”
Insight
Rakhmetzhanov: Industrial buyers are growing tired of pure SaaS models
“Nowadays there are tons of different AI tools, applications, platforms, but everyone is getting tired of certain
software as a service model.
you know, everyone demands results, you know, like end to end results basically.”
Insight
Shutting down a failing startup is a mature decision, says Marquez
“I've met a lot of founders who hang on, you know, thinking that you know, it's quitting is bad, and my opinion, I don't know that I agree with that. I think at some point it's very mature to say, hey, I'm wrong, this isn't working and then having a, an honest …”
Opinion
Founders working 80-hour weeks inevitably sacrifice their parenting, says Marquez
“If you have kids at home who are at a stage where they need your love and attention, yet you're gonna go do 80 hours a week. I'm sorry, I'm not gonna sugarcoat it. Guess what? Something's gonna give. You know, my personal preference is that the, that it's not …”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
AI agents will not replace humans anytime soon, predicts Marquez
“I do not think AI agents are going to replace people anytime soon.”
Opinion
Marquez: Fears of SaaS Armageddon and AI Replacing Engineers Were Overblown
“The SAS Armageddon was overblown or that AI was immediately going to replace any engineers. It's me. It's just a tool in the hands of the, of someone who knows how to wield it.”
Opinion
Chadha: Female actors lack power, driving her shift to producing
“When you exist in this kind of a industry for a long time, you realize, ah, actors, especially female actors, have, ah they don't have the kind of power that I really wanted. And to have more creative agency over my, ah, destiny as an artist, I wanted to becom…”
Insight
Chadha: There Is Really No Such Thing as a Woman's Issue
“So, yeah, I think Women's Day exists to bring to make noise about women's issues. Yeah. But there really is nothing called a woman's issue.”
Opinion
Chadha: Stop listening to uneducated podcasters and YouTubers on social issues
“I would like to call a spade a spade and say, if the celeb has a decent IQ, please listen to them. Unfortunately, due to social media, anybody can become a star. So you have podcasters and YouTubers who may not have read a single book in their life.”
Opinion
Chadha: Film industry considers actors over the hill by age 35
“Because I understood very early on, ah, that the premium is on youth. And then the youth fades, which it does for everyone. And then the same people are like, 30 and 35 only just, and considered over the hill.”
Assertion Contradicted
Chadha: Mumbai's Dharavi slum exports up to $700 million globally
“It exports between six hundred million to seven hundred million dollars worth of goods everywhere to the world.”
Opinion
Chadha: Indian farmers protest because of low prices, not food scarcity
“The reason the farmers keep protesting is because, I mean, does India have a food scarcity problem? I don't think so. You constantly see visuals of, ah, you know, farmers, ah, destroying their own crop. Matlab, biste ton piyaaz kisi na highway pe pheg diya, gu…”
Assertion Supported
Chadha: China's TikTok algorithm pushes robotics and science, unlike the West
“In China, TikTok pushes out content about robotics, about aeronautics, about science.”
Opinion
Chadha: Billionaires should build self-sustaining villages instead of buying carbon credits
“Like, if a billionaire truly wants legacy, don't, you know, collect climate credits. Make a village where everyone can be fed, where there's enough place to grow your own crops, and to irrigate the land. Be in this thing with nature, and that is actually true …”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Emil claims contextual engineering limits AI hallucinations to simply repeating itself
“That's what brings in all of the cultural tailoring, and all of the interpretation and empathy, and eliminates the preponderance of anything that could happen of a hallucination. The worst things that happen to us, she might repeat herself. A couple of times.”