StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Dec 8, 2021 · 17m · green-blueprint

Florida is the latest battleground over fossil-fuel phaseouts

Emily Pontecorvo · 10m spoken Stephen Lacey · 4m spoken Josie Tomkow · 25s spoken Florida Lawmaker · 18s spoken
0:00 / 0:00

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

In this episode of The Carbon Copy, host Stephen Lacey and reporter Emily Pontecorvo investigate how Florida utilities and state lawmakers enacted sweeping preemption laws to extinguish municipal clean energy goals, reflecting a nationwide conflict over fossil fuel phaseouts.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. How this is scored →

The hosts as informed peer 6.0 Guest teaching 2.3 Guest disagreement 0.0 The hosts pushing back 0.0
05100:0010:002:59–7:40 · The hosts as informed peer 6/10 The Rise of Local Building Gas Bans Nationwide Host Stephen Lacey frames the segment with strong domain context regarding building electrification, Ithaca's climate plan, and Florida utility lobbying. Guest Emily Pontecorvo collaborates smoothly by tracing the legislative trajectory in Florida.7:41–11:16 · The hosts as informed peer 6/10 The National Pattern of Gas Industry Preemption Lacey highlights watchdog data connecting campaign donations from utilities to state lawmakers. Pontecorvo provides investigative detail on internal Clearwater Gas emails showing direct coordination on preemption bills.11:16–15:38 · The hosts as informed peer 6/10 Vague Legislation Threatens Clean Energy Programs Lacey probes the existential threat facing electric and gas utilities and TECO's asset exposure at the Big Bend coal-to-gas plant. Pontecorvo breaks down the vague legal language that could imperil rooftop solar and clean energy programs.15:42–16:42 · The hosts as informed peer 6/10 Watered-Down Local Action and State-Level Stalemate Lacey synthesizes the outcome as a major victory for the fossil fuel industry, citing recent rollbacks in Tampa and Miami. Pontecorvo agrees, noting that Republican-controlled legislatures have effectively tied local governments' hands.2:59–7:40 · Guest teaching 2/10 The Rise of Local Building Gas Bans Nationwide Host Stephen Lacey frames the segment with strong domain context regarding building electrification, Ithaca's climate plan, and Florida utility lobbying. Guest Emily Pontecorvo collaborates smoothly by tracing the legislative trajectory in Florida.7:41–11:16 · Guest teaching 3/10 The National Pattern of Gas Industry Preemption Lacey highlights watchdog data connecting campaign donations from utilities to state lawmakers. Pontecorvo provides investigative detail on internal Clearwater Gas emails showing direct coordination on preemption bills.11:16–15:38 · Guest teaching 3/10 Vague Legislation Threatens Clean Energy Programs Lacey probes the existential threat facing electric and gas utilities and TECO's asset exposure at the Big Bend coal-to-gas plant. Pontecorvo breaks down the vague legal language that could imperil rooftop solar and clean energy programs.15:42–16:42 · Guest teaching 1/10 Watered-Down Local Action and State-Level Stalemate Lacey synthesizes the outcome as a major victory for the fossil fuel industry, citing recent rollbacks in Tampa and Miami. Pontecorvo agrees, noting that Republican-controlled legislatures have effectively tied local governments' hands.2:59–7:40 · Guest disagreement 0/10 The Rise of Local Building Gas Bans Nationwide Host Stephen Lacey frames the segment with strong domain context regarding building electrification, Ithaca's climate plan, and Florida utility lobbying. Guest Emily Pontecorvo collaborates smoothly by tracing the legislative trajectory in Florida.7:41–11:16 · Guest disagreement 0/10 The National Pattern of Gas Industry Preemption Lacey highlights watchdog data connecting campaign donations from utilities to state lawmakers. Pontecorvo provides investigative detail on internal Clearwater Gas emails showing direct coordination on preemption bills.11:16–15:38 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Vague Legislation Threatens Clean Energy Programs Lacey probes the existential threat facing electric and gas utilities and TECO's asset exposure at the Big Bend coal-to-gas plant. Pontecorvo breaks down the vague legal language that could imperil rooftop solar and clean energy programs.15:42–16:42 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Watered-Down Local Action and State-Level Stalemate Lacey synthesizes the outcome as a major victory for the fossil fuel industry, citing recent rollbacks in Tampa and Miami. Pontecorvo agrees, noting that Republican-controlled legislatures have effectively tied local governments' hands.2:59–7:40 · The hosts pushing back 0/10 The Rise of Local Building Gas Bans Nationwide Host Stephen Lacey frames the segment with strong domain context regarding building electrification, Ithaca's climate plan, and Florida utility lobbying. Guest Emily Pontecorvo collaborates smoothly by tracing the legislative trajectory in Florida.7:41–11:16 · The hosts pushing back 0/10 The National Pattern of Gas Industry Preemption Lacey highlights watchdog data connecting campaign donations from utilities to state lawmakers. Pontecorvo provides investigative detail on internal Clearwater Gas emails showing direct coordination on preemption bills.11:16–15:38 · The hosts pushing back 0/10 Vague Legislation Threatens Clean Energy Programs Lacey probes the existential threat facing electric and gas utilities and TECO's asset exposure at the Big Bend coal-to-gas plant. Pontecorvo breaks down the vague legal language that could imperil rooftop solar and clean energy programs.15:42–16:42 · The hosts pushing back 0/10 Watered-Down Local Action and State-Level Stalemate Lacey synthesizes the outcome as a major victory for the fossil fuel industry, citing recent rollbacks in Tampa and Miami. Pontecorvo agrees, noting that Republican-controlled legislatures have effectively tied local governments' hands.

speaking balance: gold is the hosts, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%0:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%3:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%3:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%6:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%6:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%9:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%9:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%12:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%12:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%15:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%15:00 · the hosts 0% · guest 100%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 13:56 Pontecorvo dismantles gas industry green transition claims

Pontecorvo sharply critiques utility claims that renewable natural gas or hydrogen can substitute for fossil gas without major infrastructure replacement.

 Hardest push from the hosts ▶ 15:42 Lacey evaluates state preemption as a definitive industry victory

Lacey directly asserts that the gas industry has secured a solid victory over municipal climate initiatives across Florida.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 9:15 Pontecorvo exposes Clearwater Gas internal correspondence

Pontecorvo educates listeners on public records revealing gas utility managers offering campaign donations in exchange for passing preemption laws.

 The host holds their own ▶ 3:16 Lacey articulates the physics and math behind gas bans

Lacey demonstrates domain command by connecting municipal gas bans in Ithaca and Berkeley to the fundamental physics of decarbonizing new infrastructure.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicThe hosts as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementThe hosts pushing backWhy
The Rise of Local Building Gas Bans Nationwide 6200 Host Stephen Lacey frames the segment with strong domain context regarding building electrification, Ithaca's climate plan, and Florida utility lobbying. Guest Emily Pontecorvo collaborates smoothly by tracing the legislative trajectory in Florida.
The National Pattern of Gas Industry Preemption 6300 Lacey highlights watchdog data connecting campaign donations from utilities to state lawmakers. Pontecorvo provides investigative detail on internal Clearwater Gas emails showing direct coordination on preemption bills.
Vague Legislation Threatens Clean Energy Programs 6300 Lacey probes the existential threat facing electric and gas utilities and TECO's asset exposure at the Big Bend coal-to-gas plant. Pontecorvo breaks down the vague legal language that could imperil rooftop solar and clean energy programs.
Watered-Down Local Action and State-Level Stalemate 6100 Lacey synthesizes the outcome as a major victory for the fossil fuel industry, citing recent rollbacks in Tampa and Miami. Pontecorvo agrees, noting that Republican-controlled legislatures have effectively tied local governments' hands.

Statements from this episode (10)

Assertion Supported
Nearly 200 US cities have pledged 100% clean electricity
“Nearly 200 cities across America have vowed to get a hundred percent of their electricity from zero carbon resources”
Stephen Lacey Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 0:25
Assertion Supported
Roughly 50 California cities have enacted gas hookup bans
“I think now something like 50 cities in California have passed similar laws”
Emily Pontecorvo Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 4:08
Assertion Supported
Tampa Electric used lobbying funds to fight local gas bans
“Again, it was non-binding, but it scared the local investor-owned utility Tampa Electric, also known as TECO. So TECO did what a lot of other gas utilities are doing. It used its lobbying power and money to launch a more aggressive counter-strike.”
Stephen Lacey Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 4:32
Assertion Supported
DeSantis signed laws preempting local bans on gas stations and energy
“The bills passed, and in June, Governor Ron DeSantis signed them into law. One would preempt any bans on gasoline refueling stations, and another would prevent all local governments across Florida from restricting any source of energy from utilities.”
Stephen Lacey Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 7:12
Assertion Supported
At least 20 US states have introduced gas preemption bills
“So what we're seeing is now in at least 20 states a count is at, including Florida, we've seen bills that preempt local governments from taking different kinds of climate action.”
Emily Pontecorvo Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 7:54
Assertion Supported
Tampa Electric funneled $15,000 to Senator Travis Hudson before legislative session
“What we found in Florida was there was a money trail between the Tampa Electric Company and Travis Hudson, so Tico, Tampa Electric Company, funneled about 15,000 dollars to him, like, right before this legislative session, and kind of as he was working on thes…”
Emily Pontecorvo Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 9:15
Assertion Supported
Tampa Electric registered six lobbyists to push Florida energy preemption bills
“Tico also had six registered lobbyists on the bills”
Emily Pontecorvo Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 9:34
Assertion Supported
Clearwater Gas manager offered campaign donation to senator for passing bill
“Their public affairs manager at Clearwater Gas said she would donate to her senator's reelection campaign if he gets it through.”
Emily Pontecorvo Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 10:16
Assertion Supported
Tampa Electric is converting its Big Bend coal plant to fossil gas
“Well, so recently, TECO has been investing in new natural gas power plants. So they have a major coal plant called Big Bend in Florida and Tampa, and they're in the process of converting part of that plant to run on natural gas.”
Emily Pontecorvo Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 12:56
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Research shows renewable natural gas supply cannot replace current fossil demand
“There's research showing that there may not be enough renewable natural gas to serve the, serve people at the level that natural gas does today.”
Emily Pontecorvo Dec 8, 2021 ▶ 14:34
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 100 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more