Jun 8, 2023 · 1h 3m · capital-allocators
Jim Falbe – Modern Value Investing at Saguaro (Capital Allocators, EP.320)
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
Jim Falbe, founder of Saguaro Capital Management, shares his journey from humanitarian work to institutional investing, explaining how his firm fuses classic Graham-and-Dodd value investing with cutting-edge artificial intelligence, concentrated portfolio construction, and systematic options overlays.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Ted holds 10.9% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Ted as informed peer 3.0 Guest teaching 2.8 Guest disagreement 0.1 Ted pushing back 0.5
speaking balance: gold is Ted, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 56:10 Dismissing market efficiency concerns on watchlist names
When Ted asks if a stock not being cheap means the market already discovered the thesis, Jim bluntly dismisses the premise, stating he doesn't care because they only need one or two dislocations a year.
Hardest push from Ted ▶ 46:15 Ted drilling into options gap riskTed directly challenges Jim's systematic option-writing strategy by raising gap risk on sudden negative thesis breaks or pre-sold buyout spikes.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 22:15 NLP n-grams identifying qualitative business moatsJim educates Ted on modern NLP techniques, explaining how multi-word n-grams detect structural monopolies and qualitative moats in SEC filings that quantitative screeners miss.
Ted holds their own ▶ 46:15 Ted articulating options gap risk and asymmetric payoffsTed displays sharp technical understanding of derivative execution risk, detailing how option commitments can lock managers into unfavorable fills during thesis disruptions.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Ted as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Ted pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guest Overview and Capital Allocators University Announcement | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Ted introduces the sponsored insight episode and CAU announcement before asking an open-ended opening question about Jim's background. Jim shares a personal anecdote about his mother teaching him covered calls. | |
| Humanitarian Work in Jordan and Understanding Influence | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Ted inquires about Jim's career path following college. Jim shares insights from running a training center in Jordan and explains the Middle Eastern concept of 'wasta' (influence and networking). | |
| Self-Education in Value Investing and Crisis Management | 3 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Ted observes Jim's inverted career arc of giving back before making money. Jim explains reading Graham and Buffett, testing his temperament during the GFC, and deciding to pursue professional investing. | |
| Graduate Studies at Notre Dame and Transition to Vulcan | 3 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Ted asks how Jim gained confidence to manage outside capital. Jim details his MBA at Notre Dame, working under Scott Malpass evaluating MENA managers, and getting connected to Vulcan Value Partners. | |
| Scaling Operations and Managing Capacity at Vulcan Value Partners | 3 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Ted asks about Jim's learning curve and tenure at Vulcan. Jim outlines the firm's rapid scaling from $1B to $20B and CT Fitzpatrick's decision to hard-close capacity at $10B to protect infrastructure. | |
| Cultural Alignment and Early Research Automation Initiatives | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Jim describes how he initially automated Brazilian equity analysis using Capital IQ plugins, which subsequently expanded into pitching an early IBM Watson AI research project at Vulcan. | |
| Machine Learning and Natural Language Processing in Idea Generation | 3 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Ted asks how AI integration expanded research capabilities. Jim details feature engineering with 300 variables and using NLP n-grams to detect moats, illustrating with a case study on Masonite. | |
| The Genesis of Saguaro and the WCM Connection | 3 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Ted asks about the impetus for leaving Vulcan. Jim explains why Vulcan chose focus over an affiliated manager platform, and shares how listening to Ted's podcast reconnected him to WCM and his late mother's former colleagues. | |
| Foundational Values and Organizational Principles at Saguaro | 3 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Ted asks about foundational firm values and definition of quality. Jim details Saguaro's cultural pillars and Pat Dorsey's framework of evaluating whether reinvestment and growth occur inside the defensive moat. | |
| Valuation Ranges, Holding Periods, and the Apple Lesson | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Ted asks about valuation rubrics and entry points. Jim explains using valuation ranges rather than point estimates, citing the mistake of selling Apple after a double instead of riding a 12x compounder. | |
| Research Decision-Making, Blind Voting, and Portfolio Sizing | 3 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Ted asks about research decision-making and portfolio construction. Jim outlines their blind voting process, strict concentration in 7 to 14 names, and deliberate avoidance of commodities and heavy leverage. | |
| Systematic Options Strategies and Downside Risk Management | 5 | 3 | 0 | 3 | Ted probes the mechanics of writing options around valuation ranges and explicitly presses on gap risk and thesis breaks. Jim explains their use of short-dated options and view that event risk aligns with direct ownership. | |
| Data Infrastructure and AI-Driven Competitive Monitoring | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Ted asks about other technological applications. Jim details structuring proprietary internal research data and training models to monitor weaker industry peers to detect early signs of disruption. | |
| Boutique Business Architecture, Fee Alignment, and Advisory Board | 4 | 2 | 0 | 2 | Ted questions how Saguaro justifies launching in a crowded asset management landscape. Jim outlines their performance-fee-centric model, scalable management fee reductions, and advisory board. | |
| Investment Case Study: Games Workshop and Niche Moats | 4 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Ted asks for a specific case study, and Jim presents Games Workshop (Warhammer 40k), explaining its hobbyist moat. Ted asks whether the lack of discount implies the market already knows the thesis, to which Jim dismisses market timing pressure. |
Statements from this episode (33)
Saguaro Capital Management writes covered calls as part of its strategy
“So definitely my first window, and it's funny that we actually write cover calls now.”
Falbe: Middle Eastern 'wasta' proves networking rivals performance in US careers
“And being in the Middle East, they have this term in Arabic called wasta. And the direct translation is influence, but what it really means is Who you know is everything. They get their job based on their uncle or their sister or their father gets them a posit…”
Falbe: Emotional temperament outweighs intellectual capability for investment success
“As a faithful disciple of Warren and Charlie realized the emotional makeup may be a more important part.”
Notre Dame endowment moved early into private equity and emerging markets
“They were very early in the 19 nineties into private equity. They were also early into the aughts in emerging markets. And when I was there right after 2010, they were looking to pivot into the frontier markets.”
Vulcan Value Partners scaled from $1B to $20B during Falbe's tenure
“When I signed on to Vulcan, it was a one billion dollar boutique. They were large enough that I was very confident they'd be able to pay the bills. There'd be some stability, but also small enough to still be able to really perform. And that was important to m…”
Falbe: Asset managers must build infrastructure prepared for best-case scenarios
“One of the things I really respect about CT that he did right was he always built a firm and prepared for the best case scenario. So I think a lot of people, they're like, I'll prepare for worst case scenario. You need to be prepared if something bad happens. …”
Vulcan Value Partners capped inflows while raising $100M weekly at $10B AUM
“We hit ten billion. We had a retreat and CT said, you know what? We are not taking any more money. And it took us, I think, to like, 12 or 13 before it actually stopped. We were bringing in a hundred million dollars a week in AUM because the performance was ju…”
Vulcan Value Partners built an eight-person AI team to drive value
“Ended up with us doing kind of a full AI effort at Vulcan, where we, you know, had eight people at the peak, and we're spending a lot of money, but just added a ton of value.”
Masonite and competitor Jeld-Wen control 80% of their door market
“What happened is his biggest competitor, Jeldwin, three days later, followed suit, raised their prices. Between the two of them, they own 80% of the market.”
Saguaro Capital was founded by five former Vulcan Value Partners professionals
“So five previous people at Vulcan who are all co-founders of this thing, principles, that really believed that we think we can do something that's going to add value for that next generation of value investors.”
WCM's Paul Black serves on the board of Saguaro Capital Management
“Paul's actually on our board now because of that.”
Saguaro maintains a strict one-in, one-out 100-company investment universe
“We have a list of a hundred companies. For something to get on that list, something else has to come off. So we're constantly searching for these super high quality businesses.”
Falbe: Even elite companies face a 50% drawdown once a decade
“We know from experience and also from academic research that even the best companies out there They tend to experience a 50% drawdown from peak to trough at least once every decade”
Falbe: Visa, MasterCard, MarketAxess, and Tradeweb have 30-year protected growth moats
“So you think of like Visa or a MasterCard or Market access or trade web or something. These companies are, it's gonna be 30 years where they're gonna continue growing, and that growth, it's all inside the moat.”
Saguaro evaluates businesses using valuation ranges rather than point estimates
“One of the things that makes us different from other people I know in the industry is we think in terms of ranges of values around businesses versus point estimates of value.”
Vulcan sold Apple at a split-adjusted $33, missing a massive run
“When I first started at Vulcan, we owned Apple, and at the time, I mean, it was just unbelievably cheap. It was like, and the iPhone that they'd released that year was not as popular as the Samsung Galaxy, which is hard to believe today, but everybody was kind…”
Saguaro holds elite compounders through fair value estimates unless better opportunities arise
“What we've tried to do is say, hey, if we've got one of these really rare, truly great businesses, it's okay if it kind of gets to our midpoint of value, our fair value estimate. Unless we have some other opportunity that's just so much more compelling, let's …”
Falbe targets under 20% turnover and 5-year holding periods at Saguaro
“I am guessing we're going to have less than 20% turnover. So I don't know exactly, but I'm very hopeful it's longer than five years.”
Saguaro limits portfolios to 5-20 names, currently holding 12 across strategies
“Our technical limits are five to 20 names. Realistically, each one of our portfolios will probably be more seven to 14. Today, we've got 12 in all three of our portfolios.”
Saguaro caps position sizes at 5% for ideas tracked under 12 months
“If an idea is new to us, i.e. We haven't followed it longer than 12 months, we're going to limit our position size to five percent.”
Falbe: Equity portfolios capture most diversification benefits in just 8-10 names
“I think you get most of them in eight or 10 names”
Saguaro aims to fully cover its management fees via options writing
“We're very hopeful in the long run to be able to look back and say, hey, we're more than covering our management fee with this options writing. Obviously not going to promise that and we'll see what happens, but that's helpful on entering positions.”
Saguaro traded Meta from $90 puts to $200 calls in four months
“We were writing put options on Meta slash Facebook in November, and then the 90 dollars or something, and then we turned around and we were writing call options once it got past 200 in March. And so we were able to kind of see the full investment cycle on the …”
Only 5% of acquisition takeout offers exceed Saguaro's internal valuation ranges
“We kind of went back and historically looked at things. I think it was five percent of the time acquisition takeout offers were above the high end of our range.”
Saguaro transcribes all meetings to make research machine-readable for AI
“So we capture all of our internally generated data. So we record and transcribe our research meetings. We try to record and transcribe as many calls as we can. Every research report that we're doing, we're trying to do the next step of making those reports mac…”
Falbe: No AI system will find another Amazon because duplicates don't exist
“No machine is going to find another Amazon out there because it doesn't exist.”
Falbe: Automated monitoring of weaker peers provides an early disruption warning
“However, disruption tends to occur in the weaker businesses first. So if we have the machine watching for changes in these weaker businesses, it gives us a leg up to hopefully avoid disruption before it would impact one of our companies sooner.”
Saguaro plans to cut management fees over time as assets scale
“And so we have a different structure. We want to be performance fee based. We want to make sure that we're capacity constrained and Over time, as we grow, we actually want to drive our management fee down.”
Saguaro has sourced 20 companies onto its elite watchlist using AI models
“And on the AI side, at this point, we've got about 20 names that we've actually gotten onto the SCM 100 list, taking them through our process.”
Falbe: Games Workshop generates 90%+ gross margins on manufacturing plastic models
“First thing you notice is, wow, they are 90% plus gross margins on producing plastic.”
Falbe: A 100-stock watchlist requires only 1-2 deeply discounted names annually
“If we have a full list of a hundred names, we only need one or two to have that type of a discount each year for us to have a really successful investment philosophy and process.”
Falbe: Using Sharpe ratios to compare private and public equity is crazy
“People want to compare private equity performance to public equity performance, and some people out there who I don't think understand the math actually use sharp ratios to compare them. That's just crazy to me. I'm like, for crying out loud, if I could value …”