why aren't all 21 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
What-if
Krieger: Instagram could have reached sale with 4 to 6 people using AI
“I think we could have gotten there with like four to six, you know?”
What-if
Krieger: AI would have allowed Instagram to scale with just 4-6 employees.
“I think we could have gotten there with like four to six, you know?”
Assertion Supported
Meta will use AI chatbot conversations to target Instagram and Facebook ads
“Meta has basically announced that, yeah, we're going to take everything you say to an AI chat bot and we are going to Basically have it affect the kind of ads that you see on Instagram and Facebook. Of course there are some exceptions if you are talking about …”
Assertion Supported
Kantrowitz: Meta Agrees to $18B Settlement Over Youth Addiction Claims
“Meta agrees to pay eighteen billion to settle U.S. Lawsuits over children's social media addiction, and it's going to pay it over the next decade, and strictly limit how teenagers use Facebook and Instagram under an agreement with nearly all U.S. States to res…”
Opinion
Albergati: AI Companions Won't Generate Meaningful Revenue Compared to Meta's Core
“There are other companies doing that by the way, and they can make some money off of it. Like it's nothing. It's a drop in the bucket. I think compared to what Facebook is an Instagram, like their core businesses and whatever WhatsApp, you know, fits into that…”
What-if
Krieger: Instagram's original Android app could be built in a week with AI
“Android we built. In about a month for Instagram, we could have done it probably in a week with the models”
Insight
Krieger: Massive Platforms Can Only Introduce One New Behavior Per Generation
“Once you get a service as widespread as Instagram or as widespread as Facebook or WhatsApp, it's hard to introduce a new behavior there. You know, we did it with stories. I think they've since done it with reels but it's almost like one, you get one per genera…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Kantrowitz: Instagram will outlast the flagship Facebook app
“Certainly it's more culturally relevant than the blue app and it will outlast Facebook despite, despite Mark Zuckerberg's emotional attachment to the latter.”
Opinion
Roy: Internal emails prove Meta acquired companies to kill competition
“There's no doubt in my mind, and I think the emails all show that very clearly, the goal was to remove competition from the market. Like, that was the goal.”
Assertion Supported
Kantrowitz: Zuckerberg Testified Only 17% of Facebook Time Goes to Friends' Posts
“Only 17% of Facebook and seven percent of Instagram time are spent with friends posts.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Kantrowitz: No single platform will win the post-Twitter social media fragmentation
“With something like a blue sky, you have now have blue sky, you have threads, you have Instagram, you have Twitter, and instead of like one winning out, which there won't be an absolute winner, you're just going to have diluted experiences everywhere”
Opinion
Birkenbuehl: Instagram's child safety protections are fake
“So all these things that Instagram saying we have child, we have protections in place to present. It's not real. And they know it's not real.”
Opinion
A one-person, billion-dollar company is feasible
“I think so. I think that, you know, the, you know, I've seen a bunch of examples where small companies like Instagram comes to mind, you know, that, that started really small and by the time they got acquired, they were still very small. WhatsApp is a similar …”
Opinion
Haidt: Instagram will not enforce underage bans because kids would switch to TikTok
“They won't do anything about it because if they do keep kids off below 13, then the kids will just go to TikTok. So, you know, I understand why Instagram doesn't do much about underage use but it's a trap.”
What-if
Krieger: Instagram's month-long Android build would take one week with AI
“In about a month for Instagram, we could have done it probably in a week with the models”
Insight
Krieger: Creative tools historically fail to become enduring social networks
“You would see an emergence of a creative tool and whether they were able to sort of transcend that to being a network that you come back to was often not the case.”
Disclosure
Krieger: Anthropic tracks daily visitors for utility rather than time spent
“We don't really look at engagement, at least not in the typical, like at Instagram, we spend a lot of time looking at things like time spent. Right. We do look at things like daily visitors as a proxy for a utility.”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Boureau: Meta suspended ThrivePal's Instagram account shortly after launch
“I just started like two weeks ago our Facebook page on Thrive Battle, not Instagram because Meta suspended my Instagram page, so for now it's like, Tiny.”
Assertion Supported
Krieger: Instagram had 13 employees at sale and 16 at close
“We're 13 at sale and 16 at close.”
Assertion Supported
OpenAI and Anthropic consumer product leaders hail from Instagram and Facebook
“Head of product at Anthropic, Instagram founder, head of product at OpenAI, former head of product at Instagram, person who's running what all consumer applications at OpenAI is also someone who's come from Facebook.”
Assertion Supported
Kantrowitz: Former Instagram Executives Now Lead Product at OpenAI and Anthropic
“At Anthropic, it is Mike Krieger. The co-founder of Instagram. Yep. At OpenAI, it's Kevin Wheel, the former head of product, At Instagram.”