Journalist Evan Ratliff responds to Alex Kantrowitz discussing Zoom's CEO proposing digital twins to attend meetings on his behalf.
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Voice AI Has Passed the Uncanny Valley and Evades Detection
“We're pretty close to someone not being able to detect it at all, and you could say, well, there's an uncanny valley, But I think even now we're up the like back slope of the uncanny valley when it comes to the voice stuff. Like many people will go through a f…”
Insight
Interviewees Are More Candid With AI Agents Than Human Reporters
“When it comes to people asking questions or conversing with ChatGPT, there's a quality of, you don't necessarily feel like there's someone there, and you might be a little more intimate than you would have otherwise. And that can be very valuable in an intervi…”
Opinion
Ratliff: Voice Cloning Is the Greatest Scamming Technology Ever Invented
“This is the greatest scamming technology that has ever been invented.”
Assertion Supported
Commercial Voice AI Therapists Lack Meaningful Scientific Research Backing
“The thing I can say for sure is they're being introduced without any scientific research showing, I mean, I found one study on voice therapy, one controlled study that had been done, And there are voice therapists on the market right now.”
Insight
Ratliff's AI Bot Disarmed Suspicion by Accusing Humans of Being AI
“It just puts someone off guards, you know, saying, If it asks like, hey, am I talking to an AI? I do it with the scammer sometimes. Hey, is this an AI? And they'll be like, no, this is a real person. But I think it kind of turns your brain around to where, whe…”
Insight
Extended LLM Interactions Expose Generic Predictive Training Over Sentience
“The more that you talk to it, the more generic it feels to you. The more you can actually feel The training data, the sort of, like, distilling down the training data and the predictive aspect. Like, oh, it's trying to predict what a human would say in this gi…”