StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Sep 6, 2024 · 18m · big-technology

Russia Funds Tenet Media YouTubers

Alex Kantrowitz · 8m spoken Ranjan Roy · 8m spoken
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

Hosts Alex Kantrowitz and Ranjan Roy dissect the Department of Justice's indictment exposing covert Russian funding of Tenet Media, examining the operational mechanics, financial absurdities, and broader implications for digital information warfare and creator accountability.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Alex holds 52.1% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Alex as informed peer 5.6 Guest teaching 2.4 Guest disagreement 2.2 Alex pushing back 2.2
05100:0010:000:00–2:26 · Alex as informed peer 0/10 DOJ Indictment of Tenet Media's Russian Funding This is an introductory host monologue breaking down the DOJ indictment of Tenet Media and setting the stage for the discussion. Under the scoring rules for solo monologues, all scores are set to zero.2:27–6:22 · Alex as informed peer 7/10 Absurd Economics and the Fake Funder Hoax Kantrowitz displays reporting expertise by comparing standard YouTube CPM economics ($12 per 10k views) against the inflated payouts ($100k per video) and details the fabricated Eduard Gregorian persona from the indictment. Roy collaboratively adds context regarding influencer disclosure regulations.6:22–9:08 · Alex as informed peer 8/10 The 'Victim Complex' and Direct RT Editorial Control Kantrowitz cites specific details from the indictment showing direct editorial intervention, including RT staff uploading directly and pushing the Tucker Carlson grocery store video. Roy agrees and expands on the indictment of media culture.9:09–12:36 · Alex as informed peer 6/10 Debate on Influencer Reputational Fallout The host and guest enter a direct debate over whether the influencers will suffer reputational damage. Kantrowitz pushes back firmly arguing they will be viewed as clowns, while Roy forcefully disagrees by arguing the audience views them merely as entertainers within a grift economy.12:37–16:21 · Alex as informed peer 7/10 Broader Covert Networks and Click Farms Kantrowitz references the DOJ indictment's note about multiple covert RT distribution networks to frame the broader threat. Roy educates the host with an anecdote about physical click farms observed in Taiwan.0:00–2:26 · Guest teaching 0/10 DOJ Indictment of Tenet Media's Russian Funding This is an introductory host monologue breaking down the DOJ indictment of Tenet Media and setting the stage for the discussion. Under the scoring rules for solo monologues, all scores are set to zero.2:27–6:22 · Guest teaching 2/10 Absurd Economics and the Fake Funder Hoax Kantrowitz displays reporting expertise by comparing standard YouTube CPM economics ($12 per 10k views) against the inflated payouts ($100k per video) and details the fabricated Eduard Gregorian persona from the indictment. Roy collaboratively adds context regarding influencer disclosure regulations.6:22–9:08 · Guest teaching 2/10 The 'Victim Complex' and Direct RT Editorial Control Kantrowitz cites specific details from the indictment showing direct editorial intervention, including RT staff uploading directly and pushing the Tucker Carlson grocery store video. Roy agrees and expands on the indictment of media culture.9:09–12:36 · Guest teaching 4/10 Debate on Influencer Reputational Fallout The host and guest enter a direct debate over whether the influencers will suffer reputational damage. Kantrowitz pushes back firmly arguing they will be viewed as clowns, while Roy forcefully disagrees by arguing the audience views them merely as entertainers within a grift economy.12:37–16:21 · Guest teaching 4/10 Broader Covert Networks and Click Farms Kantrowitz references the DOJ indictment's note about multiple covert RT distribution networks to frame the broader threat. Roy educates the host with an anecdote about physical click farms observed in Taiwan.0:00–2:26 · Guest disagreement 0/10 DOJ Indictment of Tenet Media's Russian Funding This is an introductory host monologue breaking down the DOJ indictment of Tenet Media and setting the stage for the discussion. Under the scoring rules for solo monologues, all scores are set to zero.2:27–6:22 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Absurd Economics and the Fake Funder Hoax Kantrowitz displays reporting expertise by comparing standard YouTube CPM economics ($12 per 10k views) against the inflated payouts ($100k per video) and details the fabricated Eduard Gregorian persona from the indictment. Roy collaboratively adds context regarding influencer disclosure regulations.6:22–9:08 · Guest disagreement 1/10 The 'Victim Complex' and Direct RT Editorial Control Kantrowitz cites specific details from the indictment showing direct editorial intervention, including RT staff uploading directly and pushing the Tucker Carlson grocery store video. Roy agrees and expands on the indictment of media culture.9:09–12:36 · Guest disagreement 7/10 Debate on Influencer Reputational Fallout The host and guest enter a direct debate over whether the influencers will suffer reputational damage. Kantrowitz pushes back firmly arguing they will be viewed as clowns, while Roy forcefully disagrees by arguing the audience views them merely as entertainers within a grift economy.12:37–16:21 · Guest disagreement 2/10 Broader Covert Networks and Click Farms Kantrowitz references the DOJ indictment's note about multiple covert RT distribution networks to frame the broader threat. Roy educates the host with an anecdote about physical click farms observed in Taiwan.0:00–2:26 · Alex pushing back 0/10 DOJ Indictment of Tenet Media's Russian Funding This is an introductory host monologue breaking down the DOJ indictment of Tenet Media and setting the stage for the discussion. Under the scoring rules for solo monologues, all scores are set to zero.2:27–6:22 · Alex pushing back 1/10 Absurd Economics and the Fake Funder Hoax Kantrowitz displays reporting expertise by comparing standard YouTube CPM economics ($12 per 10k views) against the inflated payouts ($100k per video) and details the fabricated Eduard Gregorian persona from the indictment. Roy collaboratively adds context regarding influencer disclosure regulations.6:22–9:08 · Alex pushing back 1/10 The 'Victim Complex' and Direct RT Editorial Control Kantrowitz cites specific details from the indictment showing direct editorial intervention, including RT staff uploading directly and pushing the Tucker Carlson grocery store video. Roy agrees and expands on the indictment of media culture.9:09–12:36 · Alex pushing back 7/10 Debate on Influencer Reputational Fallout The host and guest enter a direct debate over whether the influencers will suffer reputational damage. Kantrowitz pushes back firmly arguing they will be viewed as clowns, while Roy forcefully disagrees by arguing the audience views them merely as entertainers within a grift economy.12:37–16:21 · Alex pushing back 2/10 Broader Covert Networks and Click Farms Kantrowitz references the DOJ indictment's note about multiple covert RT distribution networks to frame the broader threat. Roy educates the host with an anecdote about physical click farms observed in Taiwan.

speaking balance: gold is Alex, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Alex 82% · guest 18%0:00 · Alex 82% · guest 18%3:00 · Alex 73.5% · guest 26.5%3:00 · Alex 73.5% · guest 26.5%6:00 · Alex 49.4% · guest 50.6%6:00 · Alex 49.4% · guest 50.6%9:00 · Alex 36.5% · guest 63.5%9:00 · Alex 36.5% · guest 63.5%12:00 · Alex 49.6% · guest 50.4%12:00 · Alex 49.6% · guest 50.4%15:00 · Alex 19.2% · guest 80.8%15:00 · Alex 19.2% · guest 80.8%18:00 · Alex 100% · guest 0%18:00 · Alex 100% · guest 0%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 11:17 Roy directly rejects host's reputational fallout argument

Roy unequivocally states 'I disagree. I completely disagree,' arguing that audiences expect influencers to grift and will not hold Russian funding against them.

 Hardest push from Alex ▶ 10:19 Kantrowitz pushes back on influencer immunity

Kantrowitz counters Roy's claim that commentators will escape unscathed, insisting that taking foreign money and claiming victimhood destroys credibility.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 14:40 Roy explains real-world click farm mechanics

Roy educates the audience and host by detailing first-hand observations of a driver managing a multi-phone automated engagement setup in Taiwan.

 Alex holds their own ▶ 7:52 Kantrowitz demonstrates command of indictment details

Kantrowitz exhibits deep reporting knowledge by listing specific operational examples from the DOJ filing, including RT staff uploading directly and pushing the Moscow terror attack narrative.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicAlex as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementAlex pushing backWhy
DOJ Indictment of Tenet Media's Russian Funding 0000 This is an introductory host monologue breaking down the DOJ indictment of Tenet Media and setting the stage for the discussion. Under the scoring rules for solo monologues, all scores are set to zero.
Absurd Economics and the Fake Funder Hoax 7211 Kantrowitz displays reporting expertise by comparing standard YouTube CPM economics ($12 per 10k views) against the inflated payouts ($100k per video) and details the fabricated Eduard Gregorian persona from the indictment. Roy collaboratively adds context regarding influencer disclosure regulations.
The 'Victim Complex' and Direct RT Editorial Control 8211 Kantrowitz cites specific details from the indictment showing direct editorial intervention, including RT staff uploading directly and pushing the Tucker Carlson grocery store video. Roy agrees and expands on the indictment of media culture.
Debate on Influencer Reputational Fallout 6477 The host and guest enter a direct debate over whether the influencers will suffer reputational damage. Kantrowitz pushes back firmly arguing they will be viewed as clowns, while Roy forcefully disagrees by arguing the audience views them merely as entertainers within a grift economy.
Broader Covert Networks and Click Farms 7422 Kantrowitz references the DOJ indictment's note about multiple covert RT distribution networks to frame the broader threat. Roy educates the host with an anecdote about physical click farms observed in Taiwan.

Statements from this episode (11)

Assertion Supported
Kantrowitz: DOJ Indicted Tenet Media Funders Over Covert Russian Money
“What did the DOJ indict the founders or the funders of this channel for, not the YouTubers, but the people putting the money in, that the money was coming from Russia and that Basically, the Russians had had RT, this Russian state-funded network, banned in a b…”
Alex Kantrowitz Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 0:43
Assertion Supported
Tenet Media Paid YouTubers $100K Per Video for Just 7K Views
“Let's see, like maybe 12 dollars you know, for every like 10,000 views, and these YouTubers were getting a 100,000 dollars per video, and some of the videos on the tenant media channel were getting like 7000 views.”
Alex Kantrowitz Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 4:13
Opinion
Roy: Tim Pool Willfully Ignored Suspicious Tenet Media Payments
“Tim Pool knew something was up and to not question that I think is what is raising the ire of everyone around.”
Ranjan Roy Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 6:55
Assertion Supported
Russian Funders Pressured Tenet Media to Blame Ukraine for Moscow Attack
“There's also the Russians pushed them to create a video tying the terror attack in Moscow to Ukraine, even though, like, ISIS was claiming responsibility at that time.”
Alex Kantrowitz Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 8:22
Assertion Supported
DOJ Claims RT Employees Directly Published Videos to Tenet Media Channel
“There was also a example where RT employees actually got access to publish videos directly to the channel, according to the indictment.”
Alex Kantrowitz Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 8:38
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Roy: Tenet Media Scandal Won't Damage Conservative Influencers' Reputations
“But I think that's kind of the sad part, that I don't think this is going to actually affect the reputation of most of these people.”
Ranjan Roy Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 10:12
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Kantrowitz: Influencers Implicated in DOJ Indictment Will Be Seen as Clowns
“There's gonna be core groups of fans that are going to be like, alright, I'm still with you, but I think otherwise, like, there, there's a chance that, like, they will be looked at as clowns from now on.”
Alex Kantrowitz Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 11:04
Insight
Roy: Audiences View Influencers Like Tim Pool as Entertainers, Not Journalists
“And I think a Tim pool or a lot of these people, yes, you could somewhat, a small group of people might consider them serious commentators or even quote unquote journalists. But I think most people are just like, they are entertaining and they kind of validate…”
Ranjan Roy Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 12:03
Assertion Supported
Kantrowitz: DOJ Indictment Implies RT Manages Multiple Covert US Channels
“So the DOJ in its indictment Said the RT employee running this project actually manages, and I'm quoting from the indictment, multiple RT covert distribution channels in the United States.”
Alex Kantrowitz Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 13:00
Insight
Platforms Can't Detect Covert Influencer Ops Run on Private Messaging Apps
“It's impossible for platforms to pick this up because everything is done behind the scenes, the recruiting, the payments, the editorial direction, usually in discords or in text messages or on WhatsApp signal. And it's very, very difficult to pick up.”
Alex Kantrowitz Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 13:41
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Roy: Russia Is Almost Certainly Funding Far-Left US Influencers Too
“Well, no, but I am positive that there's also very left wing influencers who are also receiving whether directly or indirectly money from Russia.”
Ranjan Roy Sep 6, 2024 ▶ 16:33
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 300 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more