why aren't all 11 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Supported
Hirasaki: Immuno-Oncology Acquisitions Occurred Before Human Clinical Data
“Now, there are some areas of clear exception. So, so very competitive hot areas like oncology, immuno-oncology over the last few years. You've seen this shift in acquisitions earlier on. In, in phase one, and actually even earlier just because it was so compet…”
Assertion Supported
Hirasaki: Spark acquisition vaulted Roche forward in gene therapy platform technology
“And then with the Spark acquisition same thing BMS, I'm sorry Roche was a laggard in the space, and now suddenly leaped ahead with not only a marketed gene therapy, but this AAV platform that it could use for delivering other gene therapies.”
Insight
Hirasaki: Pharma Companies Wait for Phase 2a Data Before Doubling Down
“So, so, you know, it's typical to You know, see pharma companies wait for proof of concept, you know, phase IIa data that shows safety and some efficacy before doubling down.”
Insight
Hirasaki: Top Corporate Buyers Fly In Executive Committees for Priority Biotech Deals
“I can tell you that big companies that really want an asset, that really want to show commitment to that program, will fly, you know, a big portion of their executive committee out in final negotiations to say, hey we're committed.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Biotech Boards Increasingly Retain U.S. Rights and Out-License Ex-U.S. Rights
“What we've seen really over the last 10 years is a lot of boards want the companies to be able to be standalone. And so, what you see are, in this fairly typical and actually Spark is a good example, where the company will keep commercial rights for the U.S. A…”
Insight
Pharma Demands Manufacturing Control Unless Assets Require Specialized Know-How
“If the asset is very critical to the business the pharma company will In all likelihood, want to control the manufacturing and distribution unless it is a very niche specialized product like gene therapies and AAVs, which require specialized know-how.”
Assertion Partly supported
Hirasaki: Major biopharma companies faced critical patent cliffs in 2018
“Roche lost exclusivity on Zolaire and Rituxin. Pfizer lost exclusivity on Lyrica. And GSK lost exclusivity on Advair.”
Assertion Supported
Hirasaki: Top 10 biopharma companies held $150B cash entering 2018
“And then on the topic of cash you know, the top 10 biopharma companies came into 2018 with about a hundred fifty billion dollars of cash on the balance sheet.”
Assertion Supported
Hirasaki: NASDAQ Biotechnology Index dropped 7% in 2018
“Between January and December of 2018 the NASDAQ biotechnology index went down seven percent.”
Assertion Supported
Hirasaki: AveXis acquisition gave Novartis an AAV9 platform for gene delivery
“So the lead asset AXVS- one-on-one it, you know, certainly is going to be probably best in class for SMA, but it also gave Novartis an AAV nine vector platform that it could use to deliver other gene therapies.”
Assertion Supported
Hirasaki: Roche Allows Acquired Companies Like Spark to Operate Semi-Autonomously
“Some big pharma companies will just tend to fully integrate the company whereas others will like Roche and Spark will allow the acquired companies to operate semi-autonomously.”