why aren't all 77 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Opinion
Schimpf: Defense Department needs Project Warp Speed for autonomous weapons
“I think there's, I think you have to do both, right? So you've got to say, like, look, like, yeah, we need a warp speed for autonomous systems or weapons. Like, we need that, right? Like, that's a no brainer that we need to have. And in doing that, you can tea…”
Disclosure
Schimpf: Anduril skips proprietary AI model research to leverage commercial models
“We don't do AI model research. We don't need to. We just take the best things that are there.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Defense tech will not produce hundreds of major startup success stories
“I think the hard reality with this is it's just like venture. It's just like any sort of industry where there isn't going to be 500 success stories. That is unlikely to be the case, right?”
Assertion Supported
Anduril fielded its first weapon system in under two years
“It was just like under two years from when we started from Never having done a weapons program to having a fielded weapon capability”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Schimpf: Standard drone communication links fail under electronic jamming in Ukraine
“Nearly every drone company that's been deployed into there has had the same reaction. Very little works on that communication link. You gotta actually very quickly innovate on it and solve these problems.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Schimpf: US manufacturing rebuild will start in defense and aerospace
“I don't think it's gonna start with, you know, making low cost iPhones, but I think starting in defense production, starting in aerospace, Areas where there's like a national interest in keeping this on the U.S., and then looking at mass-producibility there.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Schimpf: U.S. government lacks data on deep defense supply chain dependencies
“Number one, I think you need data, right? Like there's very little data on like what two, three levels down into the supply chain is actually on that bill of materials and what are the, you know, kind of critical components.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Schimpf: Recruiting hardware and manufacturing talent to California is extremely difficult
“Particularly as you get to more hardware skill sets, manufacturing skill sets, getting them to come to California is a huge problem.”
Insight
Schimpf: Perfect global battlefield intelligence creates overwhelming information overload
“Now I say I had a perfect AI system that could tell me where every ship, aircraft, and soldier was in the world. What are you gonna do with that? Now I know everything. That is overwhelming.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Schimpf: AI's primary defense role is managing massive sensor scale
“So when I think about, like, where AI is going to drive The most value for warfare. It is dealing with the scale problem, which is really like the amount of information that is the number of sensors, like the sheer volume of systems that are going to be fielde…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Schimpf: Manually piloted military drones cannot scale due to jamming limits
“It's all like manually piloted, but that doesn't really scale. And there presents a lot of limitations on communication, jamming, all these things.”
Assertion Supported
Schimpf: US defense posture requires human accountability in warfare
“And so the US posture on this is very much, we want to have humans accountable for what happens in war.”
Opinion
Schimpf: Ukraine invasion was biggest global wake-up call on bad actors
“Turns out invading Ukraine was probably the single biggest shift I've seen in terms of people recognizing that, look, like, there are still bad actors in the world.”
Assertion Partly supported
Schimpf: Commercial vehicle development takes 2-3 years while military timelines skyrocket
“There's this awesome chart, which shows how long it takes to get commercial aircraft or autos from kickoff to fielding. And it's been flat to slightly better for all of those things, on the order of two to three years. The military aircraft side just went lite…”
Assertion Supported
Schimpf: New defense missiles take 12 years from concept to deployment
“New missile takes about 12 years to go from concept through to fielding, like, 12 years.”
What-if
Schimpf: Anduril depended on a strict 2-to-3-year window for success
“I don't think we could have done it five years or later would be too late. Five years earlier probably would have been too early. I think we were in this like two to three year window where we could ride all those waves correctly.”
Insight
Schimpf: Urgent conflict and top-down leadership drive change in DoD
“There's two things that drives change in any organization, and especially in the DoD. It is an urgent conflict, and it is top-down leadership, and those are the two things that get changed to happen.”
Opinion
Schimpf: Defense Innovation Succeeds Only When DoD Bets Big on Startups
“I think if we are in a position where we're working on top tier defense programs at scale, I'll feel like we've started to move the needle. And we are actually making a dent in, you know, both how the department buys, but also the types of technology it's buyi…”
Disclosure
Anduril is working with the Air Force on the Loyal Wingman project
“Today, we're at a place where, you know, we're fortunate to be able to, you know, disclose we're working with the Air Force on the Loyal Wingman project, which is incredibly big change from where we were when we even started with this.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Lower costs allow the Air Force to fund multiple autonomous aircraft vendors
“Unlike, you know, something like an F-thirty-five, where it's only feasible to afford one provider of this you can start to look at for this, for weapon systems, for a variety of these things, Carrying multiple people to be able to really incentivize the indus…”
Opinion
The DoD Replicator program is achieving unprecedented procurement speed
“They are moving at a wildly faster pace than they have before. They're using the power of, you know, senior leadership to mobilize and force change into the department that otherwise would kind of move and incrementally adopt these new things over a very slow …”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
The U.S. military under-invested in air defense for 30 years
“And the U.S. Has under-invested in air, air defense capabilities for the last 20 or 30 years, right? We've had full air superiority. We didn't need to invest. It wasn't a critical problem set we had.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
The U.S. defense industrial base faces a critical generational retirement gap
“The traditional industrial base in the U.S. For defense is often at the point of retirement. You have people who are largely you know, built this up during the Cold War, they're retiring, their kids don't want to run these facilities, and it's become a critica…”
Insight
Defense startups fail by solving non-urgent problems for the DoD
“I think the single most important thing is if you're solving a critical warfighter need on a problem that, you know, urgently needs to be solved, you can be successful. I think the trap for most people is they're solving a problem that would be great to solve,…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Schimpf: DoD spends far less on software than commercial tech firms
“When you look at, like, how these things play out in terms of, like, what do modern technology companies spend? Take a Tesla, take any of these companies that are building, you know, kind of modern hardware, software enabled systems. You know, what's the perce…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Anduril liquid-cooled desktop GPUs for early solar-powered desert Sentry towers
“We were literally taking desktop GPUs GPUs and liquid cooling them to get these things to work in a hot desert under solar power.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Anduril built Sentry prototype in three months and scaled in 2.5 years
“We were able to go and get a prototype up in about three months and then move into like a pilot in about six months and then a full scale in about two and a half years.”
Assertion Partly supported
Schimpf: Columbia-class nuclear submarine expected to operate through 2085
“The Columbia class nuclear submarine is going into service in 2035 and its expected lifetime is through 2085.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Anduril has hundreds of AI-powered systems deployed in the field
“We've got hundreds of systems deployed in the field today using a variety of AI technologies in, in often very straightforward ways to, you know, simplify the lives of operators as much as possible.”