why aren't all 391 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 6 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Insight
Rampell: Digitizing Records Failed to Drive Real Efficiency Gains
“Nothing has actually gotten that much more efficient, because the filing cabinets were read by humans, the digital records are read by humans, right?”
Insight
Rampell: AI forces enterprise software to abandon per-seat business models
“And the reason why this is so important to understand is because the whole business model of software has to change. It has to change.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Rampell: Workday could triple revenue by automating active HR tasks
“Workday could probably triple their revenue if they start doing this because they're already the system of record.”
Insight
Rampell: AI startups acquire customers by applying to Craigslist job postings
“We're seeing a lot of companies doing this, they peruse Craigslist, they look for a job listing, and they're like, hey, Plazalane Optometry, I want to apply for the job. And, you know, the optometry's like, Okay, that sounds great. Tell me about your qualifica…”
Opinion
Rampell: Google acts as a tax on GDP via per-click ads
“Like Google, they kind of are a tax on GDP. Consumer spending is a huge part of GDP. They get a percentage of all that spend because they're charging per click. That tax might just shift elsewhere.”
Opinion
Rampell: Last-click attribution is the internet's most corrosive business model
“And like the most the most kind of pervasively corrosive business model, I think on the internet is this like last click attribution.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Rampell: Google is losing non-monetizable informational search queries to AI
“They are starting to lose some of the free, but not any of them immune, right? They're losing some of these informational queries, like who won the Oscar in 1977, like that's not a monetizable query.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Rampell: Costco's membership-based retail business model is immune to AI
“It is a very, very unique business model that is somewhat of a, it will stand the test of time and I think it's AI proof.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Rampell: AI agents are taking over 65 years of human white-collar tasks
“Now you have software agents that are effectively doing what for 65 years have been human work.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Rampell: Salesforce risks losing revenue or 10x-ing depending on AI transition
“So that's why, you know, Salesforce, it's a two hundred billion dollar plus public company. If they don't do this right, they could lose all of their revenue or most of it. If they do it really well, they can 10 X the revenue.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Alex Rampell: AI Software Prices Will Inexorably Fall Below Human Labor Costs
“I can't see a scenario where prices are more expensive than humans, or where prices don't just keep going down.”
Insight
In insurance and lending, acquiring fewer, profitable customers beats raw volume
“It really is a unique industry where more customers is actually worse than less but more profitable customers because each incremental customer is like a coin flip of profit or loss.”
Insight
Rampell: Sub-Brands Beat Monolithic Branding in Financial Services
“So in many cases, it actually helps to have sub brands and divide this up, which is, is somewhat anathema to a lot of companies that want to say, how do we get as much efficiency and synergy as possible? We're going to have one overarching brand.”
Insight
Rampell: Slow corporate decision-making guarantees adverse selection in venture deals
“If you take nine weeks to make a decision and like, you know, we'll decide within a day or Sequoia or Benchmark or some other great venture capital firm, we'll decide within a day, like you're not going to get good deals if you take nine weeks.”
Assertion Supported
Rampell: Affirm gets paid by merchants to acquire customers, unlike traditional lenders
“Contrast that with the other company that I co-founded a firm where we get paid to acquire customers in contrast to every other lending company where they have to pay a lot of money to acquire customers.”
Insight
Rampell: Pure white-label channel strategies cannot build massive tech businesses
“You're never going to build a massive business if you go channel, kind of white label channel, because nobody knows who you are.”
Insight
Rampell: Startups must achieve distribution before incumbents achieve innovation
“It's the battle between startup and incumbent is whether the startup gets the distribution before the incumbent gets the innovation.”
Insight
Rampell: Startups must achieve distribution before incumbents achieve innovation
“Battle between startup and incumbent comes down to whether the startup gets the distribution before the incumbent gets the innovation.”
Insight
Rampell: Credit card network moats are reinforced by high consumer rewards
“Well, the interesting thing there is that it's kind of a double moat that protects them, because not only do they have a network effect, but they also have this bizarre incentive where if a 2.5% fee is being charged to the merchant, well, the consumer is being…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Rampell: Capping Australian interchange fees transferred wealth to merchants, not consumers
“And actually, you know, in Australia, where interchange went down dramatically, it's like 50 basis points. Rewards went away. You didn't get your miles anymore. And then it was a giant transfer of wealth from the banks to the merchants, but none of that went b…”
Prediction Held up
Rampell: Repatriated corporate cash will fund buybacks, not innovation
“Exactly. It's probably going to go to buybacks M&A and dividends. And a lot of that is just kind of like reshuffling as opposed to actually building anything new.”
Opinion
Rampell: EU regulatory hostility toward US tech giants is driven by jealousy
“I think the EU is very jealous that Google's not a European company. I think they're jealous that Apple's not a European, like, Google is bad in Europe. In my personal opinion, I don't think they're nearly the monopolist that Microsoft was like in the late nin…”
Insight
Rampell: Incumbents usually win by innovating before startups achieve distribution
“The battle between every startup and incumbent is whether the startup gets the distribution before the incumbent gets the innovation. And normally the incumbent wins.”
Opinion
Alex Rampell: Apple's strict data privacy policy hindered its advertising efforts
“Apple is notoriously anti-data. That's the funny thing about Apple versus Google is that Apple says we don't collect any data. We don't use any data. We'll never store any data. This was part of the reason why their advertising efforts have not been successful…”
Opinion
Alex Rampell: Amazon should root for Apple Pay to fail
“They probably don't need Apple Pay as much, but they should be internally rooting for it to fail. Because if it fails, it actually helps Amazon sell more things at a higher markup vis-a-vis the competition.”
Assertion Supported
Alex Rampell: Microsoft never restricted Windows software like Apple restricts iOS
“Microsoft, in my opinion, never really They never did the same amount of control. Like, they never said, hey, this software product cannot be downloaded onto your Windows PC.”
Opinion
Alex Rampell: Cashless payment systems impose a regressive tax on the unbanked
“The problem is that cashless payments end up being a very, very regressive tax for a lot of people.”
Disclosure
Rampell: TrialPay spun off a high-beta product into a separate startup
“Thing number one is actually we split the company in two. We had a different product within the company that we just thought was very, very high beta. And there was a lot of controversy around this. I think most people thought that we were idiots for doing thi…”
Insight
Second-place players in data network markets drop to zero value
“And in fact, the value of the number two person goes to zero. Because they actually have a demonstrably poor product, which is why there aren't really any competitors to eBay.”
Insight
Pure algorithm companies struggle to build value without proprietary data
“If you are an algorithm company, It's very, very hard to build any kind of value because somebody else comes up with a marginally better algorithm. So you need to pair the algorithm with the data.”
Insight
Premium pricing over competitors proves a true data network effect
“If you can really show that you're charging 20, 30, 40% more than the competition, that's a, and they're actually willing to pay for it, and they're switching from a lower priced product, either they're totally irrational, they say, hey, I want to lose more mo…”
Assertion Partly supported
Rampell: Capping Australian interchange fees eliminated rewards cards and increased fees
“Like, so, Australia has interchange at 49 and a half basis points by law, and now, I mean, and this is not me supporting Visa. It's more of, It's very peculiar that you have an industry where when prices go down, consumers can be worse off. In Australia, now t…”
Insight
Rampell: Startups win if they get distribution before incumbents get innovation
“The battle between the incumbent and the startup comes down to whether the incumbent gets innovation before the startup gets distribution, and it's very, very hard.”
Opinion
Rampell: Extremely bearish on startups building new payment systems
“I'm incredibly bearish on any startup that says we're going to build a new payment system.”
Prediction Open · timeframe Nov 2020
Rampell: US will eventually cap credit card interchange fees
“I think it's going to happen in the U.S. Eventually.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Fintech startups will unbundle specific services rather than replace mega-banks directly
“You're probably not going to see somebody who's going to take over and take on Chase directly. It's more of, you'll see minor things like Lending Club that attack little bits and pieces of its business.”
Insight
Consumers seeking debt settlement are surprisingly reliable credit risks
“It turns out the people that raise their hands that say, I want to get out of debt, and I want to do the right thing, I want to be honest, they're actually very, very reliable people. The signal there is actually quite good, because what you want to find is yo…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Software analyzing direct bank data will outperform traditional FICO credit scores
“But the main thing that's going to change this is the software to identify, okay, we think that you are a positive quality payer. We see what's going on in your bank account. We see things that are just much, much better than what FICA can provide to us.”
Disclosure
Most US states prohibit rewarding consumers financially for switching insurance providers
“There's actually a law in most states, I know this because we tried getting into the insurance lead generation space at TrialPay, where you cannot reward people for switching their insurance.”
Assertion Supported
Alex Rampell claims he coined the term "online to offline"
“I was the one that coined this term”
Prediction Held up
Rampell: Consumers will increasingly buy and sell homes directly with companies
“In the future, or even increasingly the present, you're gonna buy your house from, or sell your house to a company.”
Insight
Rampell: Real estate buyer agents are incentivized to maximize purchase prices
“The buy side agent should be in charge of getting you, the buyer, a lower price. But the way that it works right now is the more money that you, the buyer, pay, the more money your agent gets compensated.”
Assertion Supported
Rampell: Most Washington state real estate agents sell zero homes annually
“So this is the most frequently occurring number in a big, big list is zero. So if you find like a random real estate agent in Washington state, the highest chance number of transactions that they've made last year is zero.”
Assertion Partly supported
Rampell: US real estate commissions are 6% versus 1.5% in Sweden
“So turns out in Sweden homeowners are paying one and a half percent if they want to sell their house. Even Canada, our northern neighbor has figured this out. They're only paying three percent and that keeps dropping. And the United States seems to be very stu…”
Insight
Fast-Growing Companies Make the Worst Channel Partners
“The people that were the least likely to be a channel partner were people that were growing quickly, which kind of makes sense because if you're growing a hundred percent year over year, why would you bother kind of like making a little bit of incremental reve…”
Insight
Alex Rampell: Data Cannot Change Minds Without Time
“You cannot change people's minds with data. It just doesn't work. You can change people's minds with data and time.”
What-if
TrialPay Should Have Built Core Payment Infrastructure Before Promotional Features
“If we had to do it over again, the way to have potentially built trial pay would have been to say, let's build Stripe first, and then after that gets critical mass, after we have distribution for this thing that is In many respects, a commodity. I mean, I don'…”
Opinion
Rampell: Gold as money is more absurd than Bitcoin
“And again, if you think that Bitcoin is silly, I would turn your attention to gold being a little bit more silly.”