Jan 2, 2019 · 35m · a16z
a16z Podcast | Enough with the Old Stuff -- Time for New Questions in Mobile
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of the a16z Podcast, analyst Benedict Evans and host Michael Copeland discuss the evolving mobile landscape, moving past legacy market share debates to examine Android hardware commoditization, shifting user interaction models, platform control struggles, and global scale.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. How this is scored →
The host as informed peer 2.9 Guest teaching 5.0 Guest disagreement 2.0 The host pushing back 2.3
speaking balance: gold is the host, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 16:25 Rejecting Wearable Hegemony Premise
Evans directly challenges Copeland's assertion that wearables are a chink in Apple and Android's dominance, redirecting the thesis to interaction complexity instead.
Hardest push from the host ▶ 16:25 Testing Wearable Threat ThesisCopeland explicitly challenges Evans on whether wearables disrupt the established operating system duopoly.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 7:24 Google Anti-Fragmentation ContractsEvans corrects Copeland's premise about OEMs forking Android by explaining Google's strict anti-fragmentation contracts that block manufacturers from mixing closed and open devices.
The host holds their own ▶ 11:59 Referencing Post-Netscape FrameworkCopeland demonstrates deep familiarity with Evans' written analysis by invoking his post-Netscape and post-PageRank concept to direct the conversation.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The host as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The host pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Changing Android Hardware Landscape and Chinese OEMs | 2 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Michael Copeland prompts Benedict Evans on whether Samsung's declining high-end sales suggest Android is a bad business to enter. Evans explains that Android is a viable commodity box-shifting business if manufacturers utilize the Shenzhen hardware ecosystem rather than building massive internal scale. | |
| Open Android, Google Services, and Alternative Ecosystems | 2 | 5 | 1 | 3 | Copeland asks if traditional hardware makers like HTC or LG might be forced into forking Android. Evans corrects this assumption by explaining Google's strict contractual anti-fragmentation clauses, which prevent OEMs from selling Google-serviced phones if they sell any unapproved open Android devices. | |
| Evolving Mobile Interaction Models: Web vs. Apps and Unbundling | 4 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Copeland cites Evans' thesis on living in a post-Netscape world to frame the discussion around web versus app paradigms. Evans walks through Google's internal tension between open web indexing and native OS API controls, as well as the cycle of unbundling and rebundling through notifications. | |
| Evaluating Wearables and the Trajectory of the Apple Watch | 3 | 5 | 4 | 3 | Copeland asks if wearables represent a chink in the hegemony of Apple and Google. Evans rejects the framing, arguing wearables simply add another layer of complexity while reinforcing native app models over web models. | |
| Strategic Challenges for Facebook and Amazon on Mobile Platforms | 3 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Copeland asks how Facebook and Amazon can move deeper into mobile given past hardware failures. Evans outlines the strategic necessity for platforms to sit at the primary aggregation layer rather than remaining isolated as single app icons. | |
| Chronic Uncertainty in Android's Future vs. iOS Stability | 3 | 6 | 4 | 2 | Copeland asks whether Apple and Google's dominance is less than guaranteed given ongoing shift dynamics. Evans dismisses comparisons between mobile platforms and historic Windows versus Mac dynamics, explaining why third-party mobile operating systems like Tizen or Firefox OS are fundamentally doomed. | |
| Unprecedented Global Scale and the Emergence of Local Ecosystems | 3 | 5 | 2 | 2 | Copeland prompts Evans to explain scale as the primary engine driving industry change. Evans demonstrates how four billion connected smartphones lead to localized ecosystems that operate independently of Silicon Valley market dynamics. |
Statements from this episode (21)
Evans: Apple sells top 10% of global phone volume, Android 50%
“Apple is selling the top 10% of all the phones on Earth, And that's growing steadily, and Android takes the next 50% of all the phones sold on Earth, and that's growing slightly faster.”
Evans: Apple drove 80% of U.S. Black Friday e-commerce spending
“They had 80% of all the e-commerce revenue on the Black Friday spending festival in the U.S., and About half of global web browsing, depending on which numbers you believe, and it could be a third, could be two thirds, depending.”
Evans: Samsung Captured Half of Android Volume and Almost All Profits
“There's been a question for two or three years as to what was going to happen with Samsung, which had taken half of the Android market by volume and almost all the profits.”
Evans: Android Hardware Manufacturing Is a Bad Business Without Commodity Scale
“Well, Android business of itself is a bad business unless you embrace being a commodity box shifter.”
Evans: Xiaomi Is Expanding to Middle-Income Markets, Not Developed Nations
“Xiaomi is starting to think, but it's starting to go international, but only to middle income markets, only to India and Brazil and places like that, not to develop markets. Much harder for them to come to the USA.”
Evans: Xiaomi is first Android OEM to build differentiated software
“Xiaomi is the first Android manufacturer that has kind of successfully built a differentiated software experience on top of Android.”
Evans: Google contracts block OEMs from selling both Google and forked Android
“Well, the problem for them is that Google's contract says you're not allowed to sell a forked and uncompatible and open version of Android. And, or if you do, you can't sell a single phone that has Google services on it.”
Evans: Google Maps and Play Store are Google's only crucial Android services
“Very briefly, it seems like the Maps and the App Store are crucial. None of the other services matter very much.”
Evans: Android destroyed vast wealth for mobile hardware manufacturers
“Google were actually afraid of Microsoft rather than afraid of Apple, and so they created this mobile phone platform that's been Enormously successful for Google, vast destroyer of wealth for the entire manufacturing industry”
Evans: Chrome-based phones could reduce Android to a legacy runtime
“It is entirely possible, for example, that we could be sitting here using Chrome-based phones In which Android is a sort of legacy runtime.”
Evans: Mobile websites, apps, and notifications cycle endlessly into one another
“Every, every website attempts to expand until you can turn, get people to install an app. And then every app attempts to expand until you can send notifications. And then every notification expands until it becomes an app.”
Evans: Wearables reinforce an app model over a web model
“What they also, I think, of course, do is reinforce an app model as opposed to a web model, incidentally.”
Evans: Facebook is just one of many social networks on mobile
“This is why Facebook has gone from being the only social network on desktop to being only one of many social networks on mobile”
Evans: Apple Pay neutralizes Amazon's primary mobile checkout advantage
“One of the key reasons to buy something on Amazon particularly on mobile as it's already set up with your account, so you don't need to enter a credit card in. Well, if you've got Apple Pay, then you don't need that, that, all of that aggregation goes away.”
Evans: Apple is less of a competitor to Facebook and Amazon than Google
“Apple is less of a competitor to both Facebook and Amazon than Google is.”
Evans: Facebook Home and Amazon Fire Phone were clear platform failures
“We had Facebook Home, which failed, obviously, and that was kind of an attempt for them to move up the stack, or rather move down the stack. And we've had the Kindle Fire Phone, which has also been a failure for a bunch of reasons.”
Evans: Android's evolution matters more to mobile's future than iOS
“And so another way of saying this is kind of, you know, the question of what Android is kind of matters to the future of mobile. The question of what iOS is doesn't matter in quite the same way.”
Evans: Comparing iOS and Android to Mac vs Windows is useless
“And I'm kind of, again, I'm sort of exasperated by people who think that looking at Windows versus Mac tells you something about this, because both the iPhone business is in a fundamentally different position in the industry to where the Mac Corp position was,…”
Evans: Global smartphone adoption will reach 4 billion devices
“And we'll go to four billion. There's about three and a half to four billion people on Earth today who have a mobile phone. There's a lot more SIM cards, but there's three and a half to four billion people on Earth today who have a mobile phone. And that will …”
Evans: 4 to 4.5 billion adults globally will be online
“What's actually happening is that there are five billion adults on Earth, and four to four and a half billion of them will be online, and basically the only people who are not online are the people who are not economically active or who are basically being sho…”