why aren't all 11 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Disclosure
Minted avoids diversity quotas in favor of a meritocratic hiring process
“We're not a company that says we must have this level of diversity at all levels. We are a company that says we must have a bias free and meritocratic process to evaluating sourcing talent and evaluating it.”
Insight
Injecting capital too early into paid marketing creates unsustainable growth
“So my conclusion really right now is that there's this organic pace of growth that makes sense. And that sometimes if you try to inject capital too early to try to accelerate that pace through marketing, you end up with a marketing mix, which is so heavily wei…”
Insight
Naficy advises investing in consumer brands over online retailers
“And so if you're a brand, I would invest in a brand now. I'm not sure I would invest in any type of online retailer, but I would invest in brands because I think there's a cooperative relationship that can be formed with Amazon.”
Disclosure
Minted keeps paid customer acquisition under 30% of its total mix
“So I think a healthy ratio for us, we have a very high bar, I would say, would be under 30% paid as a percentage of our acquisition mix.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Minted received zero orders for its first month after launch
“There was not a single order for probably three weeks, four weeks after the site was live”
What-if
Delaying early VC funding preserved Naficy's equity in Minted
“I mean, I've retained a much larger ownership stake in the company, which is what I wanted to do. Then I think I would have had I taken money early, bigger money earlier.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Minted artists radically transform their skills within 18 months of peer feedback
“They transform within 18 months of continuous feedback and critique from their peers, and they become unrecognizable from where they started.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Minted was constantly near failure and out of cash for five years
“Every year for the first four or five years when Minted was constantly almost going out of business. Because we were almost all, almost always out of cash. It was brutal the first couple of years of building this business.”
Assertion Supported
Naficy sold Eve.com for $100M cash right before the 2000 crash
“We ended up selling the business within one year of launching the business in April, 2000, right before the market imploded. And we sold it for about a hundred million dollars in cash after operating it for one year.”
Assertion Supported
Eve.com reached $10M in sales in its first year
“We reached ten million dollars of sales in our first year in 1999.”
Assertion Supported
Naficy raised $26M in Eve.com's first year
“Eve, I started with a co-founder and I raised twenty six million dollars in the first year.”