StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Jun 30, 2017 · 22m · 20vc

20VC: Why You Do Not Want Diversity Of Thought, Why You Have To Build A Sports Team and Not A Family & Why Extreme Cultures Are Easier For People To Understand with Ari Mir, Founder @ Clutter

Ari Mir · 15m spoken Harry Stebbings · 6m spoken
0:00 / 0:00

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

In this episode of The 20 Minute VC, host Harry Stebbings interviews Clutter co-founder and CEO Ari Mir about constructing high-performance sports team cultures, maintaining unit economics discipline in on-demand logistics, and scaling a tech-enabled self-storage platform globally.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Harry holds 29.5% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Harry as informed peer 3.6 Guest teaching 3.6 Guest disagreement 2.8 Harry pushing back 3.0
05100:0010:0020:002:03–4:18 · Harry as informed peer 1/10 Ari Mir's Background and the Origin Story of Clutter Harry introduces Ari Mir and prompts him to share his background and the founding story of Clutter. Ari explains his previous startup successes and failures before detailing how applying an on-demand business model to traditional self-storage yielded Clutter's core value proposition.4:18–10:45 · Harry as informed peer 3/10 Building High-Performance Cultures: Sports Team vs. Family Model Harry actively probes Ari's management philosophy, asking if his sports team model creates an unhealthy culture of fear and pushing for specific timelines on performance termination. Ari defends his high-performance culture by distinguishing rational from irrational fear and outlining Clutter's rigorous six-month audit process.10:46–15:03 · Harry as informed peer 7/10 Implementing Extreme Cultures and Rethinking Cognitive Diversity Harry demonstrates notable industry knowledge by citing Lux Capital's Josh Wolfe on cognitive diversity to challenge Ari's contrarian views. Ari counters by arguing that early-stage startups require tactical alignment and homogeneous thought rather than cognitive diversity to move quickly.15:03–17:50 · Harry as informed peer 5/10 Financial Discipline and Unit Economics in On-Demand Logistics Harry quotes Ari's recent tweet regarding competitors failing to understand unit economics to guide the conversation into financial discipline. Ari explains how hiring finance-minded executives enabled Clutter to achieve positive gross margins across operating regions.17:55–20:34 · Harry as informed peer 2/10 Quick-Fire Insights and Clutter's Five-Year Expansion Plan Harry guides Ari through a standard quick-fire round covering books, mentors, and competition mindsets before concluding with Clutter's five-year international expansion plans. Ari shares reflections on tennis versus golf as metaphors for startup competition.2:03–4:18 · Guest teaching 2/10 Ari Mir's Background and the Origin Story of Clutter Harry introduces Ari Mir and prompts him to share his background and the founding story of Clutter. Ari explains his previous startup successes and failures before detailing how applying an on-demand business model to traditional self-storage yielded Clutter's core value proposition.4:18–10:45 · Guest teaching 5/10 Building High-Performance Cultures: Sports Team vs. Family Model Harry actively probes Ari's management philosophy, asking if his sports team model creates an unhealthy culture of fear and pushing for specific timelines on performance termination. Ari defends his high-performance culture by distinguishing rational from irrational fear and outlining Clutter's rigorous six-month audit process.10:46–15:03 · Guest teaching 6/10 Implementing Extreme Cultures and Rethinking Cognitive Diversity Harry demonstrates notable industry knowledge by citing Lux Capital's Josh Wolfe on cognitive diversity to challenge Ari's contrarian views. Ari counters by arguing that early-stage startups require tactical alignment and homogeneous thought rather than cognitive diversity to move quickly.15:03–17:50 · Guest teaching 3/10 Financial Discipline and Unit Economics in On-Demand Logistics Harry quotes Ari's recent tweet regarding competitors failing to understand unit economics to guide the conversation into financial discipline. Ari explains how hiring finance-minded executives enabled Clutter to achieve positive gross margins across operating regions.17:55–20:34 · Guest teaching 2/10 Quick-Fire Insights and Clutter's Five-Year Expansion Plan Harry guides Ari through a standard quick-fire round covering books, mentors, and competition mindsets before concluding with Clutter's five-year international expansion plans. Ari shares reflections on tennis versus golf as metaphors for startup competition.2:03–4:18 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Ari Mir's Background and the Origin Story of Clutter Harry introduces Ari Mir and prompts him to share his background and the founding story of Clutter. Ari explains his previous startup successes and failures before detailing how applying an on-demand business model to traditional self-storage yielded Clutter's core value proposition.4:18–10:45 · Guest disagreement 4/10 Building High-Performance Cultures: Sports Team vs. Family Model Harry actively probes Ari's management philosophy, asking if his sports team model creates an unhealthy culture of fear and pushing for specific timelines on performance termination. Ari defends his high-performance culture by distinguishing rational from irrational fear and outlining Clutter's rigorous six-month audit process.10:46–15:03 · Guest disagreement 5/10 Implementing Extreme Cultures and Rethinking Cognitive Diversity Harry demonstrates notable industry knowledge by citing Lux Capital's Josh Wolfe on cognitive diversity to challenge Ari's contrarian views. Ari counters by arguing that early-stage startups require tactical alignment and homogeneous thought rather than cognitive diversity to move quickly.15:03–17:50 · Guest disagreement 2/10 Financial Discipline and Unit Economics in On-Demand Logistics Harry quotes Ari's recent tweet regarding competitors failing to understand unit economics to guide the conversation into financial discipline. Ari explains how hiring finance-minded executives enabled Clutter to achieve positive gross margins across operating regions.17:55–20:34 · Guest disagreement 2/10 Quick-Fire Insights and Clutter's Five-Year Expansion Plan Harry guides Ari through a standard quick-fire round covering books, mentors, and competition mindsets before concluding with Clutter's five-year international expansion plans. Ari shares reflections on tennis versus golf as metaphors for startup competition.2:03–4:18 · Harry pushing back 0/10 Ari Mir's Background and the Origin Story of Clutter Harry introduces Ari Mir and prompts him to share his background and the founding story of Clutter. Ari explains his previous startup successes and failures before detailing how applying an on-demand business model to traditional self-storage yielded Clutter's core value proposition.4:18–10:45 · Harry pushing back 6/10 Building High-Performance Cultures: Sports Team vs. Family Model Harry actively probes Ari's management philosophy, asking if his sports team model creates an unhealthy culture of fear and pushing for specific timelines on performance termination. Ari defends his high-performance culture by distinguishing rational from irrational fear and outlining Clutter's rigorous six-month audit process.10:46–15:03 · Harry pushing back 6/10 Implementing Extreme Cultures and Rethinking Cognitive Diversity Harry demonstrates notable industry knowledge by citing Lux Capital's Josh Wolfe on cognitive diversity to challenge Ari's contrarian views. Ari counters by arguing that early-stage startups require tactical alignment and homogeneous thought rather than cognitive diversity to move quickly.15:03–17:50 · Harry pushing back 2/10 Financial Discipline and Unit Economics in On-Demand Logistics Harry quotes Ari's recent tweet regarding competitors failing to understand unit economics to guide the conversation into financial discipline. Ari explains how hiring finance-minded executives enabled Clutter to achieve positive gross margins across operating regions.17:55–20:34 · Harry pushing back 1/10 Quick-Fire Insights and Clutter's Five-Year Expansion Plan Harry guides Ari through a standard quick-fire round covering books, mentors, and competition mindsets before concluding with Clutter's five-year international expansion plans. Ari shares reflections on tennis versus golf as metaphors for startup competition.

speaking balance: gold is Harry, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Harry 71.4% · guest 28.6%0:00 · Harry 71.4% · guest 28.6%3:00 · Harry 13.5% · guest 86.5%3:00 · Harry 13.5% · guest 86.5%6:00 · Harry 11.1% · guest 88.9%6:00 · Harry 11.1% · guest 88.9%9:00 · Harry 13.3% · guest 86.7%9:00 · Harry 13.3% · guest 86.7%12:00 · Harry 13.6% · guest 86.4%12:00 · Harry 13.6% · guest 86.4%15:00 · Harry 21.8% · guest 78.2%15:00 · Harry 21.8% · guest 78.2%18:00 · Harry 34.7% · guest 65.3%18:00 · Harry 34.7% · guest 65.3%21:00 · Harry 100% · guest 0%21:00 · Harry 100% · guest 0%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 12:54 Rejecting Diversity of Thought in Early Startups

Ari explicitly rejects standard tech industry wisdom by stating that early-stage startups under 300 people should actively avoid diversity of thought in favor of homogeneous execution.

 Hardest push from Harry ▶ 7:27 Challenging the Sports Team Culture of Fear

Harry directly challenges Ari's strict sports team corporate model, asking if intense performance management creates an environment rooted in fear.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 13:30 Explaining the Football Metaphor for Startup Execution

Ari reframes the discussion around diversity by using a football metaphor to demonstrate why early-stage alignment is necessary before scaling to broader cognitive perspectives.

 Harry holds his own ▶ 12:29 Countering Guest with Josh Wolfe's Cognitive Diversity Thesis

Harry demonstrates deep podcast research and industry grounding by bringing up VC Josh Wolfe's opposing perspective on cognitive diversity to put the guest on the spot.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicHarry as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementHarry pushing backWhy
Ari Mir's Background and the Origin Story of Clutter 1210 Harry introduces Ari Mir and prompts him to share his background and the founding story of Clutter. Ari explains his previous startup successes and failures before detailing how applying an on-demand business model to traditional self-storage yielded Clutter's core value proposition.
Building High-Performance Cultures: Sports Team vs. Family Model 3546 Harry actively probes Ari's management philosophy, asking if his sports team model creates an unhealthy culture of fear and pushing for specific timelines on performance termination. Ari defends his high-performance culture by distinguishing rational from irrational fear and outlining Clutter's rigorous six-month audit process.
Implementing Extreme Cultures and Rethinking Cognitive Diversity 7656 Harry demonstrates notable industry knowledge by citing Lux Capital's Josh Wolfe on cognitive diversity to challenge Ari's contrarian views. Ari counters by arguing that early-stage startups require tactical alignment and homogeneous thought rather than cognitive diversity to move quickly.
Financial Discipline and Unit Economics in On-Demand Logistics 5322 Harry quotes Ari's recent tweet regarding competitors failing to understand unit economics to guide the conversation into financial discipline. Ari explains how hiring finance-minded executives enabled Clutter to achieve positive gross margins across operating regions.
Quick-Fire Insights and Clutter's Five-Year Expansion Plan 2221 Harry guides Ari through a standard quick-fire round covering books, mentors, and competition mindsets before concluding with Clutter's five-year international expansion plans. Ari shares reflections on tennis versus golf as metaphors for startup competition.

Statements from this episode (9)

Assertion Supported
Clutter raises $64 million Series C led by Atomico
“In the last fortnight, they raised a whopping sixty-four million Series C, led by Atomico, with participation from Sequoia, Google Ventures, or GV, and the fantastic Brendan Wallace at Fifth Wall.”
Harry Stebbings Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 0:10
Insight
Ari Mir: Company culture is hiring and performance management, not perks
“Culture is not happy hour. It's not a foosball table. It's not swag. Culture is Your hiring methodology and your performance management methodology.”
Ari Mir Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 4:36
Disclosure
Ari Mir: Clutter uses random work audits and strict performance timelines
“We will randomly audit your work at any point within the first six months. And we'll do this several times to be clear. And what we're looking for is one of three different outcomes. The first is that the audit shows your work product is amazing. What then hap…”
Ari Mir Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 9:14
Insight
Ari Mir: Managers should invest time in top performers, not low performers
“We fundamentally don't believe it's fair to the rest of the team for us to continue to invest in you. What's more fair is that we invest more of our time in the top performers within the company and help them really create an exponential return to their invest…”
Ari Mir Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 10:09
Insight
Mir: Extreme company culture is easier to understand than gray area culture
“I like to always say an extreme culture is much easier for people to understand, whether it's on one end or another, it doesn't matter. Just it being an extreme culture is actually much easier for team members to understand than having a mediocre culture that'…”
Ari Mir Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 11:19
Insight
Mir: Early-stage startups should avoid diversity of thought in favor of alignment
“But what we don't want, which I think is not commonly supported by other early stage startups is what we don't really want at this stage is diversity of thoughts, and I know that doesn't make sense. It's a little counterintuitive, but the reason why we don't i…”
Ari Mir Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 13:31
Assertion Contradicted
Mir: Clutter's early employees all had finance backgrounds
“Every single person we employed in the early days had a finance background.”
Ari Mir Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 16:44
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Mir: Clutter achieves positive gross profit across all operating regions
“Even though it's only been two years into our company, we are producing positive unit economics on our customers. We're producing a positive gross profit in every single region that we operate in.”
Ari Mir Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 17:17
Prediction Didn’t hold up
Clutter plans expansion to top 25 NFL cities within three years
“We're excited by our sixty-four million dollar Series C announcement that we recently made that was led by Atomico, and that capital is primarily going to be used for Aggressive geo expansion. And so, you'll see us in the top 25 NFL cities over the next two to…”
Ari Mir Jun 30, 2017 ▶ 19:49
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 1,200 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more