StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Jan 11, 2016 · 31m · 20vc

20 VC: David Tisch @ Box Group on The Future of Consumer Mobile, Developing Pattern Recognition and FOMO

David Tisch · 24m spoken Harry Stebbings · 5m spoken
0:00 / 0:00

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

In this episode of The 20 Minute VC, host Harry Stebbings interviews David Tisch, Managing Partner at Box Group and co-founder of Spring. Tisch shares insights on early-stage seed investing, pattern recognition, navigating venture FOMO, the evolution of New York City's tech ecosystem, consumer mobile distribution challenges, and his hands-on experience building an e-commerce platform.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Harry holds 18% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Harry as informed peer 2.7 Guest teaching 2.3 Guest disagreement 1.1 Harry pushing back 1.4
05100:0010:0020:0030:001:51–4:31 · Harry as informed peer 1/10 David Tisch's Background and Entry into Venture Capital Stebbings open with a standard background prompt asking Tisch how he entered startups and venture capital. Tisch provides a extended monologue detailing his transition from law and real estate into startup execution and Techstars. Stebbings remains entirely passive while listening.4:31–8:40 · Harry as informed peer 3/10 Analyzing the Growth and Maturity of NYC's Tech Ecosystem Stebbings brings up a specific topic from NYC investor Kanye Macubella regarding whether New York truly needs an anchor tech company. Tisch softly reframes the premise by distinguishing between ecosystem needs and desires. The dynamic remains collaborative and exploratory.8:43–12:27 · Harry as informed peer 2/10 Box Group's Origin, Long-Term Vision, and Founder Relations Stebbings asks about Box Group's origin story and how long feedback loops affect pattern recognition. Tisch cautions that true pattern recognition takes decades to build and assuming one has it figured out early is a mistake. Stebbings follows along with conversational questions.12:27–18:00 · Harry as informed peer 3/10 Time Allocation, Decision Dynamics, and Managing Venture FOMO Stebbings probes Tisch on how Box differentiates itself in a market filled with founder-friendly VCs. Tisch bluntly dismisses standard VC differentiation talk as BS, insisting that investors don't add value beyond baseline chemistry. Stebbings prompts with good operational questions on deal pace and FOMO.18:00–20:43 · Harry as informed peer 5/10 State of Consumer Mobile and Overcoming Distribution Hurdles Stebbings demonstrates high prep by citing Mattermark data on Box's 37% consumer mobile allocation and confronting Tisch with Fred Wilson's thesis on the mobile app downturn. Tisch acknowledges the distribution hurdles while countering that massive smartphone usage guarantees new category winners.20:43–26:31 · Harry as informed peer 3/10 Building Spring: E-Commerce Innovation and Operational Leadership Stebbings references a prior interview where Tisch reportedly called his brother's company idea 'stupid'. Tisch immediately corrects Stebbings on the misquote, clarifying he advised against starting a company out of general caution rather than mocking the idea. Stebbings quickly backs down and apologizes.26:31–31:06 · Harry as informed peer 2/10 Quickfire Round: Books, Tools, and Smart Home Investments Stebbings runs through rapid-fire questions covering favorite books, productivity hacks, and smart home investments. Tisch provides engaging answers regarding his preference for TV over books and his investment in Nucleus intercoms. The segment is lighthearted and harmonious.1:51–4:31 · Guest teaching 1/10 David Tisch's Background and Entry into Venture Capital Stebbings open with a standard background prompt asking Tisch how he entered startups and venture capital. Tisch provides a extended monologue detailing his transition from law and real estate into startup execution and Techstars. Stebbings remains entirely passive while listening.4:31–8:40 · Guest teaching 2/10 Analyzing the Growth and Maturity of NYC's Tech Ecosystem Stebbings brings up a specific topic from NYC investor Kanye Macubella regarding whether New York truly needs an anchor tech company. Tisch softly reframes the premise by distinguishing between ecosystem needs and desires. The dynamic remains collaborative and exploratory.8:43–12:27 · Guest teaching 3/10 Box Group's Origin, Long-Term Vision, and Founder Relations Stebbings asks about Box Group's origin story and how long feedback loops affect pattern recognition. Tisch cautions that true pattern recognition takes decades to build and assuming one has it figured out early is a mistake. Stebbings follows along with conversational questions.12:27–18:00 · Guest teaching 3/10 Time Allocation, Decision Dynamics, and Managing Venture FOMO Stebbings probes Tisch on how Box differentiates itself in a market filled with founder-friendly VCs. Tisch bluntly dismisses standard VC differentiation talk as BS, insisting that investors don't add value beyond baseline chemistry. Stebbings prompts with good operational questions on deal pace and FOMO.18:00–20:43 · Guest teaching 3/10 State of Consumer Mobile and Overcoming Distribution Hurdles Stebbings demonstrates high prep by citing Mattermark data on Box's 37% consumer mobile allocation and confronting Tisch with Fred Wilson's thesis on the mobile app downturn. Tisch acknowledges the distribution hurdles while countering that massive smartphone usage guarantees new category winners.20:43–26:31 · Guest teaching 3/10 Building Spring: E-Commerce Innovation and Operational Leadership Stebbings references a prior interview where Tisch reportedly called his brother's company idea 'stupid'. Tisch immediately corrects Stebbings on the misquote, clarifying he advised against starting a company out of general caution rather than mocking the idea. Stebbings quickly backs down and apologizes.26:31–31:06 · Guest teaching 1/10 Quickfire Round: Books, Tools, and Smart Home Investments Stebbings runs through rapid-fire questions covering favorite books, productivity hacks, and smart home investments. Tisch provides engaging answers regarding his preference for TV over books and his investment in Nucleus intercoms. The segment is lighthearted and harmonious.1:51–4:31 · Guest disagreement 0/10 David Tisch's Background and Entry into Venture Capital Stebbings open with a standard background prompt asking Tisch how he entered startups and venture capital. Tisch provides a extended monologue detailing his transition from law and real estate into startup execution and Techstars. Stebbings remains entirely passive while listening.4:31–8:40 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Analyzing the Growth and Maturity of NYC's Tech Ecosystem Stebbings brings up a specific topic from NYC investor Kanye Macubella regarding whether New York truly needs an anchor tech company. Tisch softly reframes the premise by distinguishing between ecosystem needs and desires. The dynamic remains collaborative and exploratory.8:43–12:27 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Box Group's Origin, Long-Term Vision, and Founder Relations Stebbings asks about Box Group's origin story and how long feedback loops affect pattern recognition. Tisch cautions that true pattern recognition takes decades to build and assuming one has it figured out early is a mistake. Stebbings follows along with conversational questions.12:27–18:00 · Guest disagreement 2/10 Time Allocation, Decision Dynamics, and Managing Venture FOMO Stebbings probes Tisch on how Box differentiates itself in a market filled with founder-friendly VCs. Tisch bluntly dismisses standard VC differentiation talk as BS, insisting that investors don't add value beyond baseline chemistry. Stebbings prompts with good operational questions on deal pace and FOMO.18:00–20:43 · Guest disagreement 2/10 State of Consumer Mobile and Overcoming Distribution Hurdles Stebbings demonstrates high prep by citing Mattermark data on Box's 37% consumer mobile allocation and confronting Tisch with Fred Wilson's thesis on the mobile app downturn. Tisch acknowledges the distribution hurdles while countering that massive smartphone usage guarantees new category winners.20:43–26:31 · Guest disagreement 2/10 Building Spring: E-Commerce Innovation and Operational Leadership Stebbings references a prior interview where Tisch reportedly called his brother's company idea 'stupid'. Tisch immediately corrects Stebbings on the misquote, clarifying he advised against starting a company out of general caution rather than mocking the idea. Stebbings quickly backs down and apologizes.26:31–31:06 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Quickfire Round: Books, Tools, and Smart Home Investments Stebbings runs through rapid-fire questions covering favorite books, productivity hacks, and smart home investments. Tisch provides engaging answers regarding his preference for TV over books and his investment in Nucleus intercoms. The segment is lighthearted and harmonious.1:51–4:31 · Harry pushing back 0/10 David Tisch's Background and Entry into Venture Capital Stebbings open with a standard background prompt asking Tisch how he entered startups and venture capital. Tisch provides a extended monologue detailing his transition from law and real estate into startup execution and Techstars. Stebbings remains entirely passive while listening.4:31–8:40 · Harry pushing back 2/10 Analyzing the Growth and Maturity of NYC's Tech Ecosystem Stebbings brings up a specific topic from NYC investor Kanye Macubella regarding whether New York truly needs an anchor tech company. Tisch softly reframes the premise by distinguishing between ecosystem needs and desires. The dynamic remains collaborative and exploratory.8:43–12:27 · Harry pushing back 1/10 Box Group's Origin, Long-Term Vision, and Founder Relations Stebbings asks about Box Group's origin story and how long feedback loops affect pattern recognition. Tisch cautions that true pattern recognition takes decades to build and assuming one has it figured out early is a mistake. Stebbings follows along with conversational questions.12:27–18:00 · Harry pushing back 2/10 Time Allocation, Decision Dynamics, and Managing Venture FOMO Stebbings probes Tisch on how Box differentiates itself in a market filled with founder-friendly VCs. Tisch bluntly dismisses standard VC differentiation talk as BS, insisting that investors don't add value beyond baseline chemistry. Stebbings prompts with good operational questions on deal pace and FOMO.18:00–20:43 · Harry pushing back 4/10 State of Consumer Mobile and Overcoming Distribution Hurdles Stebbings demonstrates high prep by citing Mattermark data on Box's 37% consumer mobile allocation and confronting Tisch with Fred Wilson's thesis on the mobile app downturn. Tisch acknowledges the distribution hurdles while countering that massive smartphone usage guarantees new category winners.20:43–26:31 · Harry pushing back 1/10 Building Spring: E-Commerce Innovation and Operational Leadership Stebbings references a prior interview where Tisch reportedly called his brother's company idea 'stupid'. Tisch immediately corrects Stebbings on the misquote, clarifying he advised against starting a company out of general caution rather than mocking the idea. Stebbings quickly backs down and apologizes.26:31–31:06 · Harry pushing back 0/10 Quickfire Round: Books, Tools, and Smart Home Investments Stebbings runs through rapid-fire questions covering favorite books, productivity hacks, and smart home investments. Tisch provides engaging answers regarding his preference for TV over books and his investment in Nucleus intercoms. The segment is lighthearted and harmonious.

speaking balance: gold is Harry, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Harry 60.2% · guest 39.8%0:00 · Harry 60.2% · guest 39.8%3:00 · Harry 9.9% · guest 90.1%3:00 · Harry 9.9% · guest 90.1%6:00 · Harry 10.6% · guest 89.4%6:00 · Harry 10.6% · guest 89.4%9:00 · Harry 7.5% · guest 92.5%9:00 · Harry 7.5% · guest 92.5%12:00 · Harry 12.5% · guest 87.5%12:00 · Harry 12.5% · guest 87.5%15:00 · Harry 4.8% · guest 95.2%15:00 · Harry 4.8% · guest 95.2%18:00 · Harry 23.3% · guest 76.7%18:00 · Harry 23.3% · guest 76.7%21:00 · Harry 11.1% · guest 88.9%21:00 · Harry 11.1% · guest 88.9%24:00 · Harry 17% · guest 83%24:00 · Harry 17% · guest 83%27:00 · Harry 9.4% · guest 90.6%27:00 · Harry 9.4% · guest 90.6%30:00 · Harry 43.3% · guest 56.7%30:00 · Harry 43.3% · guest 56.7%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 13:45 Dismissing VC Value-Add Claims as BS

Tisch forcefully rejects standard venture capital marketing tropes, labeling typical VC claims of adding value as BS and admitting he tells founders that investors don't add value.

 Hardest push from Harry ▶ 18:08 Pressing Tisch on Mobile Downturn and Portfolio Risk

Stebbings challenges Tisch's portfolio strategy by citing Mattermark data on Box's heavy 37% mobile weighting alongside Fred Wilson's prominent critique of mobile app distribution.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 23:05 Correcting Host's Misquote on Spring's Founding

Tisch explicitly corrects Stebbings' premise that he called his brother's startup idea 'stupid', clarifying his actual advice and prompting an immediate apology from the host.

 Harry holds his own ▶ 18:08 Citing Mattermark Data and Industry Analysis

Stebbings demonstrates deep domain knowledge by accurately referencing Box Group's specific Mattermark portfolio stats and contrasting them with Fred Wilson's macro market perspective.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicHarry as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementHarry pushing backWhy
David Tisch's Background and Entry into Venture Capital 1100 Stebbings open with a standard background prompt asking Tisch how he entered startups and venture capital. Tisch provides a extended monologue detailing his transition from law and real estate into startup execution and Techstars. Stebbings remains entirely passive while listening.
Analyzing the Growth and Maturity of NYC's Tech Ecosystem 3212 Stebbings brings up a specific topic from NYC investor Kanye Macubella regarding whether New York truly needs an anchor tech company. Tisch softly reframes the premise by distinguishing between ecosystem needs and desires. The dynamic remains collaborative and exploratory.
Box Group's Origin, Long-Term Vision, and Founder Relations 2311 Stebbings asks about Box Group's origin story and how long feedback loops affect pattern recognition. Tisch cautions that true pattern recognition takes decades to build and assuming one has it figured out early is a mistake. Stebbings follows along with conversational questions.
Time Allocation, Decision Dynamics, and Managing Venture FOMO 3322 Stebbings probes Tisch on how Box differentiates itself in a market filled with founder-friendly VCs. Tisch bluntly dismisses standard VC differentiation talk as BS, insisting that investors don't add value beyond baseline chemistry. Stebbings prompts with good operational questions on deal pace and FOMO.
State of Consumer Mobile and Overcoming Distribution Hurdles 5324 Stebbings demonstrates high prep by citing Mattermark data on Box's 37% consumer mobile allocation and confronting Tisch with Fred Wilson's thesis on the mobile app downturn. Tisch acknowledges the distribution hurdles while countering that massive smartphone usage guarantees new category winners.
Building Spring: E-Commerce Innovation and Operational Leadership 3321 Stebbings references a prior interview where Tisch reportedly called his brother's company idea 'stupid'. Tisch immediately corrects Stebbings on the misquote, clarifying he advised against starting a company out of general caution rather than mocking the idea. Stebbings quickly backs down and apologizes.
Quickfire Round: Books, Tools, and Smart Home Investments 2100 Stebbings runs through rapid-fire questions covering favorite books, productivity hacks, and smart home investments. Tisch provides engaging answers regarding his preference for TV over books and his investment in Nucleus intercoms. The segment is lighthearted and harmonious.

Statements from this episode (11)

Assertion Supported
NYC tech ecosystem lacks a mega-scale anchor company
“The negative of what's happened here in the past seven years is you haven't seen the true emergence of a destination company, right? We have incredible companies that are building incredible foundations here. Some have went, went public already. Some will go p…”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 5:03
Prediction Not checkable as stated
West Coast tech hubs in NYC risk stifling local giants
“All the big companies from the West Coast have set up product offices here over the past five years, and I think that that might on one hand prevent the emergence of a standalone New York A monster, but it also brings more talent here, and so you've seen what …”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 6:53
Insight
VCs claiming pattern recognition under 10 years experience are mistaken
“Trying to sort of assume you have it and have figured it out this soon I think is, is probably a mistake.”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 11:17
Disclosure
Box Group invests in approximately 40 companies per year
“And the way that we invest, we, you know, invest in about 40 companies a year.”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 12:03
Insight
A startup's 20th employee is exponentially more valuable than a seed investor
“The 20th employee at a company is exponentially more valuable than you know, a seed stage investor when a company's taking off.”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 12:56
Opinion
Venture capital investors do not add value to startups
“When entrepreneurs in a meeting ask us, you know, what value do we add? My initial response is always, investors don't add value, and that's what we'll promise you.”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 14:30
Insight
Mobile startups must launch finished, polished products to succeed today
“The barrier, I think, to be successful is you need to be great from the minute somebody gets you, and that could be either this magical utility, could be this magical happiness you bring to a user, or it could be an incredibly polished product with a clear pat…”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 19:52
Prediction Held up
New breakout consumer mobile companies will emerge soon
“And I think you'll see new companies emerge. Is it going to happen this year? Is it going to happen next year? It's going to happen soon. It hasn't happened since Snapchat, right? They're the Snapchat, Tinder are the last big consumer companies to emerge. Thos…”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 20:26
Insight
Early-stage VCs must be increasingly excited about each new investment
“I think the key to being an early stage investor is that every day, and every company you invest in, you need to be more excited about than the last one. Otherwise, it's hard to keep your energy up.”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 27:16
Opinion
Fred Wilson is the icon of New York venture capital
“Fred Wilson, I think, and you know, he's the icon in New York.”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 28:31
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Smartphones will not remain the primary remote controls for technology
“I don't believe the phone is your remote control. I think there's other input methods that are going to allow you to interact with technology.”
David Tisch Jan 11, 2016 ▶ 30:14
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 1,200 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more