Nov 2, 2022 · 55m · news
GoPuff CEO Rafael Ilishayev: The Plan to Make GoPuff Profitable by 2024 | 20VC #944 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
GoPuff co-founder and co-CEO Rafael Ilishayev details the company's shift from rapid expansion to rigorous fiscal discipline, explaining how optimizing unit economics, scaling high-margin secondary verticals, and focusing on customer retention will guide GoPuff to full profitability by 2024.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Harry holds 16.4% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Harry as informed peer 4.1 Guest teaching 5.3 Guest disagreement 1.8 Harry pushing back 3.7
speaking balance: gold is Harry, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 4:13 Rafael rejects low-margin premise
When Harry characterizes instant needs as an inherently capital-intensive and low-margin business model, Rafael directly refutes the host's premise by citing gross margins in the high 30s to low 40s.
Hardest push from Harry ▶ 19:30 Harry challenges batching economicsHarry pushes back directly on Rafael's operational explanation, questioning whether batching orders actually changes the core economic viability of instant needs or merely offers marginal improvements.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 19:50 Rafael breaks down driver density and ODH economicsRafael delivers a detailed explanation on how batching multiple orders per route increases orders per driver hour (ODH) and reduces variable cost per order by up to 50%.
Harry holds his own ▶ 28:52 Harry points out broken UK UI for loyalty pointsHarry uses his own experience as an active UK customer to call out a product flaw, forcing Rafael to admit that European product rollout lagged US loyalty feature implementation.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Harry as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Harry pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Why Capital Dried Up for Instant Needs | 3 | 5 | 2 | 2 | Harry sets up the market background regarding capital drying up for instant needs. Rafael explains the core difference between GoPuff's 'nail it then scale it' strategy versus competitors' unsustainable 'scale it then nail it' expansion. | |
| Margin Structures and Financial Health of GoPuff | 5 | 6 | 5 | 6 | Harry directly challenges GoPuff's sector classification as capital-intensive and low-margin based on his own investment experiences. Rafael pushes back on the premise, explaining that gross margins in the high 30s to low 40s make it a healthy business when executed properly. | |
| The Race to Profitability and Regional Unit Economics | 4 | 6 | 2 | 3 | Harry asks for specific margin variances between mature US markets and newer European markets. Rafael educates the host on gross margin percentage versus gross margin dollars, using alcohol basket sizes to show how lower percentages can yield higher absolute profit dollars. | |
| Implementing GoPuff's New Financial Plan | 3 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Harry asks about the structural differences between GoPuff's old and new financial plans. Rafael details opening fewer dark stores, controlling fixed costs, and pausing capital-intensive incubations like pharmacy delivery. | |
| Prioritizing Product Initiatives and Driver Routing | 4 | 5 | 1 | 3 | Harry references insights from advisor Emil Michael to ask about product roadmap prioritization. Rafael outlines post-order basket addition features for consumers and driver batching software rollouts. | |
| The Realities of Customer Experience and Batching Economics | 6 | 7 | 3 | 7 | Harry challenges Rafael on whether cost-cutting degrades customer experience and questions if batching actually moves the needle economically. Rafael admits trying to copy 10-minute delivery hype in the UK was a mistake and breaks down how order batching density can cut variable order costs by up to 50%. | |
| The Governing Metric of Success: Unit Economics | 4 | 5 | 1 | 3 | Harry probes whether orders per driver hour (ODH) is the governing success metric. Rafael explains that unit economics must be $4 to $8 positive per order before order volume matters for EBITDA fixed cost coverage. | |
| User Retention, Gamification, and the FAM Subscription | 5 | 6 | 2 | 6 | Harry references Facebook's early retention metrics to ask what defines a retained GoPuff user. Rafael reveals that buying across 3 categories on order one increases annual spend by $600, but Harry hits back with his own user experience to highlight that GoPuff's loyalty points are hidden in the UK UI. | |
| Price Elasticity and FAM Subscription Strategy | 4 | 5 | 1 | 4 | Harry asks if GoPuff has tested price elasticity for its FAM subscription program. Rafael discusses live pricing tests and outlines consumer behavior shifts toward budget alcohol and convenience during economic downturns. | |
| Lessons from Expanding and Pulling Out of Spain | 4 | 5 | 2 | 5 | Harry asks directly why GoPuff exited Spain. Rafael candidly admits launching in Spain was a mistake driven by bull market expansion pressures rather than owning their core market first. | |
| The Distraction of Fast-Paced Innovation and Saying 'No' | 5 | 5 | 2 | 4 | Harry asks if an economic slowdown is secretly advantageous by weeding out unprofitable competitors. Rafael agrees, emphasizing that paranoid founders win and explaining why acquiring poorly integrated competitors is rarely worth the operational distraction. | |
| The Future of Instant Needs and Proving Profitability | 3 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Harry asks for a 2-to-3 year outlook for the instant needs space. Rafael emphasizes GoPuff's chip on its shoulder to prove the sector can achieve full EBITDA profitability within 18 months. | |
| Admiration for Amazon and Logistics Inspiration | 4 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Harry initiates a quickfire section asking about admired competitors and growth drivers. Rafael praises Amazon's logistics playbook and discusses GoPuff Kitchens achieving 20% attachment rates. | |
| Board Alignments and the Speed of European Expansion | 4 | 5 | 2 | 4 | Harry asks if there were board disagreements regarding capital allocation. Rafael notes that investors pushed for faster European expansion during 2021, and reflects on hiring subject matter experts earlier. | |
| GoPuff's Five-Year Global Vision | 3 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Harry asks for GoPuff's 5-year outlook. Rafael details plans to dominate expanded retail categories in the US and execute disciplined market-by-market international growth. |
Statements from this episode (37)
Ilishayev: GoPuff raised no outside capital in first three years
“We didn't raise money for our first three years.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff operates in 1,000+ cities with 12,000 employees
“To now where we are today, you know over a thousand cities on a global scale, you know, 12,000 employees globally”
Ilishayev: Competitors' scale-first instant delivery strategies were fundamentally flawed
“Pretty much everyone else in the instant need space from across the globe had the opposite strategy. You know, all we need to do is open up a whole host of buildings. We'll figure out the tech later. We'll figure out the operational excellence later. We don't …”
Ilishayev: GoPuff achieves gross margins in the high 30s to low 40s
“We have gross margin in the high thirties, low forties, depending on the region that you're in.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff fulfillment center payback period dropped to just three months
“In the beginning, right. It took maybe a year or a year and a half for a building to recoup its investment. And now it's some buildings you open up and three months later, where you recouped all your fixed costs, right?”
Ilishayev: Capital markets will crush grow-at-all-costs delivery startups within three quarters
“Or you said, Hey, I want to grow at all costs. I want to expense as many cities as I can. And we'll figure out our distributors later. We'll figure our vendor relations later. We'll figure out our technology inside of the four walls and routing, binning and ba…”
Ilishayev: Alcohol yields GoPuff's lowest margin percentage but highest dollar margin
“Alcohol is our lowest gross margin percentage category, but our highest gross margin dollar category.”
Unprofitable startups ignoring cash flow will fail within 18 months
“Any company in any space that's not thinking about profitability right now and is not focused on profitability, there's a higher chance they're not that the, these companies will probably not exist in the next year or year and a half.”
GoPuff created a financial plan requiring no additional outside capital
“We built a new financial model that's completely self-funded. Right. One that doesn't require any more outside capital.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff will achieve full company profitability by 2024
“That balance for us at least meant that we're profitable in 20, 24.”
Ilishayev: All existing mature GoPuff metro markets generate positive cash flow
“If you look at like on a metro basis, all of our existing metros are producing, you know, cash flow. So you have your call calling your cash cows, right? Philadelphia, Chicago's Boston's, Miami's all of our Texas markets of the world that are producing cash fl…”
Ilishayev: GoPuff launched a prescription drug delivery service in Philadelphia
“We launched a pharmacy business in Philadelphia. We're actually delivering prescription drugs to folks.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff will not add hundreds of warehouses over the next 18 months
“We're not going to add a, you know, fleet of hundreds of more buildings in the next 18 months, right? We'll strategically open buildings where it makes sense, but we're not going to be opening up buildings like we were opening up buildings in the last 18 month…”
GoPuff routing update will boost batching efficiency near double digits and reduce CPO
“The first week of October, we have You know, kind of V-two of that launching which I think will keep P-ninety delivery time stable, but will improve our ability to bin and batch by, I think, you know, pretty close to double digits. So not only you know, that, …”
Ilishayev: 10-to-15 minute delivery is not a sustainable business model
“In the U.K., the consumer was almost taught that 10 or 15 minute delivery is a norm. Maybe in somewhat, in New York, that was the case too. And that's not a sustainable business model. Any stretch of the imagination.”
Ilishayev: Delivery customers value consistency over raw speed
“People don't necessarily want a really fast delivery. They want a really consistent delivery. So they read that really have like a 30 minute average with, you know, a seven, eight minute deviation, then like a 20 minute average with a 15 minute deviation, righ…”
Ilishayev: High driver order density reduces variable delivery costs by 50%
“You know, in a market that has a high ODH, the amount of orders a driver could fulfill an hour, versus a market that has a weak ODH, the cost difference on the variable cost side could be as high as 50%.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff operates markets generating $8 to $9 profit per order
“We have markets that are doing eight or nine dollars positive on a per order basis.”
GoPuff Average Order Value Has Reached the Thirties
“Our AOV has improved, you know, hundreds of percentages since we've launched the business, right? And we had an AOV in the teens, then in the twenties, now in the thirties.”
Ilishayev: First-order cross-category buyers spend $600 more in their first year
“A customer that orders across three categories in their first order will spend 600 dollars more than that year than a customer that orders from one or two categories.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff loses only 2% to 3% of customers after third order
“If you look at, you know, order three, customers that made it over three and you look at the retention cohorts over the next 12 months, we're losing like low double, low single digit percent of our customers, like two, three percent.”
GoPuff FAM subscription penetration grew from 11% to 30% in six months
“So we started the year with 11% of our subscribers being FAM customers. So FAM is our subscription program. Two quarters later, 11% has now become 30%.”
GoPuff targets over 55% to 60% steady-state FAM subscriber penetration
“We believe the steady state number is, you know, north of 55 or 60%.”
Ilishayev: Alcohol sales are particularly resistant to economic downturns
“Alcohol is particularly resistant to any effects of an economic downturn.”
Ilishayev: Recession basket values will hold, but product mix will shift
“I actually don't think baskets are going to change from a dollar amount perspective, but the assortment inside of the basket is going to change, right? More of the kind of budget budget bottles but more quantity versus one kind of high ticket, high end item.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff should have exited Spain immediately after acquiring Dija
“We got into Spain via the Deja acquisition, and We probably should have pulled out immediately instead of waiting to pull out.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff UK market share will reach low-to-mid 30s within two months
“We're now like, I think, 25% market share in the UK and instant needs. You know, that in the next two months will be in the low to mid thirties, right?”
Ilishayev: GoPuff controls 70% of the New York City instant needs market
“We own 70% of the instant needs market in New York right now.”
Ilishayev: GoPuff tested too many side initiatives and opened kitchens too fast
“Probably wouldn't have tested as many things as we've tested. Right. I mentioned pharmacy to you as one. It's like, it's not even the money aspect of the distraction factor for the team. I'm like, not focusing on the things that matter most. Like I mentioned k…”
Ilishayev: GoPuff will launch new business verticals within two quarters
“Whether it's FBA or AWS is something that we take a lot of inspiration from as we launch our new businesses, right? Whether it's a group of ads or some of the new businesses we have brewing that are launching in the next two quarters.”
Ilishayev: Unannounced GoPuff business line could eventually match core retail app
“I think that business one day can be as large as our retail business or as large as large as, you know, GoPub as it exists today, right? The GoPub app.”
Gopuff Kitchens achieves a 20% order attachment rate in active markets
“You're seeing in markets where we have go of kitchens, attachment rates of 20%. So 20% of all of consolidated orders, adding a kitchen item in there, something that we cook inside one of the, so I think that business shows a lot of promise, right?”
Gopuff Kitchens simultaneously boosts retention, frequency, and order basket size
“It increases retention. It's very rare that you introduce a category that improves retention, improves frequency and improves basket. Alcohol was one of those one of those categories. The go-up of the kitchen's business is another one of those categories that …”
Ilishayev: GoPuff investors pushed for faster European expansion in 2021
“I think midpoint last year, there was a lot of conversation, not just with our board, but investors on how fast we should be moving in Europe. And a lot of folks were really pushing us to expand to Germany faster expand to other areas in Europe faster.”
GoPuff co-founders spend one day every week visiting micro-fulfillment centers
“Kira and I still spend a day in the week inside of the MFC every single week, right? We travel to a new MFC and we visit it.”