why aren't all 171 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 8 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Kim: AI Recursive Self-Improvement Could Arrive Within Nine Months, Massively Draining Compute
“RSI, I think, is a lot closer than people think. And if RSI actually happens in the next three, six, nine months, That's gonna soak up insane amount of compute.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Amodei: AI models will surpass human cognitive capabilities within years
“My fundamental view is that AI has been on an exponential for the last 10 years and as part of a sort of Moore's law for intelligence, and that we are now well advanced on that curve, and there are only a small number of years for AI models surpassing the cogn…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Shkreli: Aschenbrenner shopped Anthropic stake at $1.1T valuation for liquidity
“And the rumor is over the weekend, he contacted about 10 parties to place Anthropic in an effort to shore up liquidity, selling the Anthropic stake for allegedly the offer was at a 1.1 trillion equivalent market cap which, you know, I think roughly where it's …”
Opinion
Tae Kim: NVIDIA United the Tech Industry Against Anthropic
“I think it's been very impressive what they've been, they've basically united the entire tech industry against Anthropic in the last, like, three, four days.”
Assertion Partly supported
Coogan: Alibaba has repeatedly distilled Anthropic's Claude model
“Anthropix's Alibaba has distilled, clawed many, many times, and I saw a chart of the amount of tokens that are getting resold.”
Prediction Open · timeframe Dec 2027
Gerstner: OpenAI and Anthropic compute capacity will scale from 3GW to 20GW
“OpenAI and Anthropic combined to start the year had three gigawatts of compute. Three combined. They're gonna end the year closer to 10, and end next year closer to 20.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gerstner: Anthropic is fastest-growing company in history of capitalism
“OpenAI has not blown away their numbers. Google has not blown away their numbers. Like numbers have been good, but the fundamental driver of outperformance in terms of offtake of AI revenues has been Anthropic, which is the fastest growing company in the histo…”
Assertion Supported
Hays: Anthropic Officially Designated as a Federal Supply Chain Risk
“This also coincided with Anthropic, I guess, officially being designated as a supply chain risk”
Opinion
Thompson: US Government Actively Trying to Hurt Anthropic Over Subservience
“The goal isn't to, fine, we just won't use Anthropic. I do think the goal is to hurt Anthropic. And you're, if you're not going to be subservient to us, you're not going to be allowed to build a power base, period.”
Insight
Thompson: Private AI Labs Imposing Unilateral Limits Invites Severe State Backlash
“Unilaterally imposing restrictions, even if those restrictions are good, isn't just an issue as far as who rules us, the democracy issue, that sort of Palmer Luckey, I think very eloquently raised. It's inviting Very bad outcomes for those asserting that in ge…”
Opinion
Thompson: Trusting Dario Amodei Over Congress Abandons Democratic Governance
“You could say Congress isn't gonna do anything, therefore, Amadei should. Just appreciate that is giving up on the democratic process and saying we should have unelected, unaccountable individuals making weighty decisions.”
Assertion Supported
Hays: Anthropic Battles Pentagon Over Surveillance and Lethal AI Uses
“It's also locked in a battle with the Defense Department over how its clawed suite are used after it told the Pentagon it couldn't be used for domestic surveillance or autonomous lethal activities.”
Opinion
Hays: Anthropic's ad campaign plants false impression of ChatGPT ads
“It's brilliant, well-timed, and incredibly strategic for a few reasons I'll outline below, and it's designed to plant a false impression of Chad GPT's forthcoming ad product in the minds of hundreds of millions of Americans.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Hays: Claude has lost the race to reach billions of users
“Anthropic has already lost the race to serve billions of people, right? I don't think that they're, when you look at Gemini's sort of traction, OpenAI's, ChatGPT traction, like it seems like the race to get to Three billion monthly actives is kind of over. I d…”
Opinion
Altman calls Anthropic's Super Bowl ad deceptive
“The main thing that's wrong with the ads is, like, using a deceptive ad to criticize deceptive ads feels, I don't know, something doesn't sit right with me about that.”
Disclosure
Altman: OpenAI will never put ads into the LLM output stream
“Our first principle with ads is that we're not gonna put stuff into the LLM stream.”
Prediction Open · timeframe Dec 2030
Patel: Anthropic's $300B revenue target for 2030 is too low
“And when Anthropic says in their funding, like, hey, we're gonna have three hundred billion dollars of revenue by the end of the decade, and it's like, actually I think that number's too low. Because the economic value of what they're gonna create is gonna be …”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gurman: Anthropic demanded $1B+ in year one to power Siri
“Anthropic wanted multiples of billions. I believe starting in a billion in year one and doubling every year thereafter, at least for the next three years.”
Assertion Supported
Coogan: Analysts predict OpenAI and Anthropic IPOs within next year
“Some analysis, some analysts who study the AI industry say the two companies which are preparing for public listings in the next year, they just want to eliminate the competition.”
Assertion Supported
Coogan: Anthropic Halted Mythos After Model Hacked NSA Systems in Red-Teaming
“There was, of course, that news that the NSA commented that Mythos was able to hack into a bunch of their systems. That was during a red teaming exercise. The unprecedented intervention led Anthropik to halt all access to comply with the new rule.”
Assertion Supported
Coogan: U.S. Export Controls Bar Foreign Nationals From Accessing Anthropic Models
“The US government is restricting both Fable Five and Mythos Five from being used by any foreign national, whether inside or outside the US, including foreign national Anthropic employees, and so that's a huge compliance burden, very sudden, and that led Anthro…”
Assertion Supported
Coogan: Anthropic Suspended Fable 5 Following Commerce Department Directive
“And on June 12th, just five days after the end of the week, Fable Five gets suspended after the Commerce Department issues an export control directive.”
Assertion Supported
Coogan: The Information Reported Amazon's Jassy Raised AI Jailbreak Concerns With White House
“Then the information reported that Andy Jassy at Amazon had raised concerns with the senior administration officials about jailbreaking. The risk of jailbreaking fable and getting access to all of Anthropic.”
Prediction Open · timeframe May 2029
Gerstner: Anthropic and OpenAI will keep growing despite enterprise spend optimization
“Of course, I believe that optimization will continue, but my hunch is that anthropic and open and these companies will continue to grow right through the optimization because the growth curve on penetration of both enterprise and use case is so steep.”
What-if
Gerstner: Without Anthropic's revenue, stock market would be down 10-15%
“Had Anthropic not delivered its revenues that it's delivered this year, I think the stock market would be down 10 or 15%.”
Assertion Supported
Ries: Trust-governed PBCs are roughly five times more likely to reach year 50
“They created something called the long-term benefit trust. Which is like a multi-branch government, right? So you have the for-profit PPC, and then you have the board of directors accountable to a second entity, this outside trust, and the data shows that comp…”
Assertion Partly supported
Hays: Anthropic objected to AI use in Maduro raid
“Anthropic had taken issue with how their products were used in the Maduro raid.”
Opinion
Thompson: Anthropic Commands SF Talent While OpenAI Aligns With America
“Anthropic has a local advantage in that most people, I think, in the industry are with them, and they have a national PR problem in that I think a lot of folks outside of tech don't understand why tech companies always try to Or resist helping the US governmen…”
Assertion Supported
Coogan: Supply chain risk labels have only targeted foreign companies
“It's only been used for foreign countries. Kaspersky Labs was a Russian cybersecurity company that was deemed to be a supply chain threat. Huawei is a supply chain risk because of the five G towers that could potentially have back doors.”
Assertion Supported
Hays: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Are Terminating Anthropic Products
“The US federal housing, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are also terminating the use of anthropic products, which was announced this morning.”
Assertion Supported
Coogan: Anthropic Clashed over Surveillance and Lethal Weapons Clauses Permitted to OpenAI
“So there were two main sticking points that they went back and forth on. No mass domestic surveillance, and no fully autonomous lethal weapons, and there's been a question as to why OpenAI was allowed to Include that language in their contract and say, like, h…”
Assertion Partly supported
Hays: Emil Michael claimed Dario Amodei skipped a critical defense call
“Emil Michael came out Friday night and said, it was five, 13, 13 minutes past the deadline. I'm trying to get in touch with Anthropic. I try to get on the phone with Dario. Dario says he's in a meeting.”
Opinion
Coogan: Amodei used classified contracts to restrict military AI
“He clearly believes that, that the Department of War should not be using AI broadly, and then he was trying to use his contract as a way to sort of enforce that, because he has that leadership position with the most deep integration to classified systems.”
Assertion Supported
Hays: Hackers Used Claude to Breach 195M Mexican Government Records
“Hackers use Claude to steal a 150 gigabytes of Mexican government data. They told Claude they're doing a bug bounty. Claude initially refused. A hacker just kept asking and manages to successfully steal some documents. Apparently, it's four state governments, …”
Assertion Supported
Hays: Anthropic Abandons AI Safety Pauses if Rivals Release Comparable Models
“Anthropic previously paused development work on its model. If it could be Classified as dangerous, but it said it would end that practice if a comparable or superior model was released by a competitor, given that they are at the frontier, that kind of opens th…”
Prediction Held up
Shah: Anthropic will likely IPO in the next 3 to 6 months
“I have a strong suspicion that Anthropic is going to go, you know, in the next three to six months. They just have so much momentum and there's a lot of value being first.”
Assertion Supported
Anthropic restricts Claude OAuth tokens exclusively to its first-party apps
“In the Cloud Code docs, OAuth, and OAuth authentication, which is used with the Free, Pro, and Max plans, is intended exclusively for Cloud Code and Cloud.ai. Using OAuth tokens obtained through Cloud Free, Pro, or Max accounts in any other product, tool, or s…”
Insight
Amodei: Deployed AI models are profitable, but labs lose money scaling training
“Each model makes money, but the company loses money.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Amodei: Frontier AI gross margins are currently very positive
“Yeah, so the, again, the gross margins right now are very positive.”
Assertion Supported
Hays: Reports indicate Claude was used in Maduro raid planning
“There was reporting last week that Claude was leveraged in some way during the Maduro planning, the planning of the Maduro raid.”
Insight
Amodei: Frontier AI oligopoly will not equilibrate to zero margins
“If there's like three firms, if there's three firms in the economy, all are kind of independently behaving, behaving rationally, it doesn't equilibrate to zero.”
Insight
Amodei: AI models make money individually while companies lose money scaling
“Each model makes money, but the company loses money.”
Insight
Amodei: AI market with three rational firms will not collapse to zero margins
“The point is it doesn't equilibrate to perfect competition with zero margins. If there's like three firms, if there's three firms in the economy, All are kind of independently behaving, behaving rationally. It doesn't equilibrate to zero.”
Assertion Partly supported
Coogan: Anthropic reached $14 billion in revenue after 10x yearly growth
“We've all seen the revenue chart, 10 X growth four years in a row, a hundred million, a billion, now fourteen billion.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Hays: The real SaaS crash won't begin until frontier AI labs IPO
“I think the real Sasspocalypse might not start until you have some of the labs public, and people can actually really rotate out of software fully and say, I don't want to own this thing that I don't fully understand how AI is going to impact it when I could o…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
O'Laughlin: Anthropic's margins are lower than perceived due to lack of free users
“Honestly, Anthropic has no free users, or like on a relative basis, so their margins are ironically like, kind of on a like-to-like basis, kind of not as good as you think.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Hays: Anthropic falsely implies ChatGPT display ads will manipulate model responses
“As the ads that are coming to chat to be to your effectively display ads. Everybody in the industry by now should know this, yet this campaign implies that the ads will influence the response and that you cannot trust it.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Hays: Effectively zero percent chance OpenAI wins the Super Bowl ad battle
“And there is zero, I will go out now and say, I would say there's effectively a zero percent chance that OpenAI can win the Super Bowl this year.”