why aren't all 16 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
What-if
Toshniwal: Taking venture capital would have worsened financial outcomes for YML employees
“I think the outcome would have been, probably the personal outcome would have been worse for not just me, but also the people at YML.”
Insight
Toshniwal: Early founder liquidity unlocks fearless growth instead of defensive downside optimization
“When founders are not financially secure, and let's say they put in five, six years in the company. They became, they become so fearful as this is a hundred percent of what they own. Yeah. This is a hundred percent of what they own. They cannot let it go becau…”
Insight
Product design is hard to offshore due to missing cultural context
“And design is such a thing, it's very hard to offshore, because it's so cultural. Just imagine if, you know, someone has not experienced Disney, and they have not experienced how healthcare system works, or they have never bought an automobile insurance in the…”
Insight
Founder CEOs cannot scale without firing and rehiring themselves
“And I don't think any founder CEO can scale a company until they do this.”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Ahluwalia: Toshniwal sold YML for $350M with $25M peak EBITDA
“You started from Kolkata, lived in a fifteen-member home with one washroom, and now you build a company and sold it for three fifty million dollars. It had like twenty-five million EBITDA at its peak.”
Assertion Supported
Toshniwal: Apple later hired YML as iOS experts for healthcare initiatives
“Actually Apple became a client too, you know, after a few years. So we were working with Apple on some, you know, healthcare initiatives and this was like working with their team, healthcare institutes, and we were the iOS expert.”
Disclosure
Toshniwal: He rejected early Credit Karma equity for cash building their app
“We built their first product mobile app and we were offered, and they were also very small. Those were like pre series a company. And they were like, look, Kashish, why don't you take some equity instead of”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Top YML enterprise client accounts exceeded $70M over seven-plus years
“In fact, some of the clients have stayed with us over six, seven, eight years, and each account was worth maybe over seventy million dollars, you know, sometimes over a seven, eight, nine year period.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Toshniwal: Individual enterprise client accounts generated over $70M in lifetime revenue
“Some of the clients have stayed with us over six, seven, eight years, and each account was worth maybe over seventy million dollars, you know, sometimes over a seven, eight, nine year period.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Toshniwal: YML generated roughly $80 million in cash flow over six years
“That is a significant, because if you look at those six, seven years, you know, if I accumulate the whole six, seven years, I think our cash flow was close to eighty million dollars.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Toshniwal: YML's early consumer apps brought major media fame but poor revenue
“Once we launched all these apps, it never did well. In the long run, it became, it made us famous. So, you know, we were on wall street journal, CNN, CNBC. We got a lot of fame, but I knew the reality. The business was very poor.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Toshniwal: YML maintained a 59% average annual growth rate for a decade
“So our growth from 2016 to 23 was, I think, seven times, seven to eight times. I think if I look at the growth over the last 10 years before I sold, we grew at like 59% as an average annual rate of growth.”
Assertion Supported
Toshniwal: YML reached approximately $10 million in revenue by 2015
“I think two, 15, 16, we were close to ten million in revenue.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Toshniwal: YML generated six acquisition offers in three weeks during 2015 process
“Like, I think he generated close to six offers in like two to three weeks.”
Disclosure
Toshniwal: YML's founders were the company's lowest-paid employees for seven years
“You know, I think like Sumit and I, we were the, probably one of the cheapest employees in the company, even after running it for like seven years, six years.”
Assertion Supported
Toshniwal: Pivoting YML to enterprise mobile development drove the company's ultimate success
“And Sumit and I discussed like, how about we Actually pivot to make other companies mobile first. And that pivot, you know, made YML what YML became. That was the most successful pivot.”