Oct 1, 2023 · 1h 29m · lennys-podcast
What sets great teams apart | Lane Shackleton (CPO of Coda)
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this interview with Lenny Rachitsky, Coda CPO Lane Shackleton explores first-principles product leadership, detailing how mountaineering lessons, repeatable team rituals, and seeking out uncomfortable 'oh shit moments' drive high-performing organizations.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Lenny holds 24.5% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Lenny as informed peer 4.7 Guest teaching 5.0 Guest disagreement 0.1 Lenny pushing back 0.1
speaking balance: gold is Lenny, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 10:25 Lane rejects traditional multi-tier corporate ladders
Lane forcefully critiques standard 10-15 level ladders at large tech companies like Google, stating you need a PhD to decipher them and arguing they fuel an unhealthy individual rat race.
Hardest push from Lenny ▶ 14:11 Lenny presses on cross-functional role levelingLenny stops Lane to clarify whether Coda's five role stages are truly applied uniformly across distinct disciplines like design, engineering, and product management.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 37:00 Lane educates Lenny on HubSpot's flash tagsLane provides a clear, structured breakdown of HubSpot's four-tiered feedback hierarchy, showing how it removes feedback ambiguity and saves teams hundreds of hours.
Lenny holds their own ▶ 1:09:41 Lenny shares Chip Conley's hospitality insight at AirbnbLenny demonstrates deep product and domain expertise by drawing a powerful parallel between AdWords customer behavior and Chip Conley's discovery that Airbnb hosts view their physical home, not the website, as the actual product.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Lenny as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Lenny pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Antarctic Namesakes, Mountaineering in Alaska, and Crisis Management | 4 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Lenny opens with light banter about Ernest Shackleton and asks how Lane transitioned from mountaineering to product. Lane recounts harrowing mountaineering stories and lessons in preparation and crisis management. | |
| The Origins of Studying PM Principles and Critiquing Career Ladders | 3 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Lane explains why he began codifying product principles, critiquing traditional corporate career ladders as overly complex and misaligned. Lenny listens closely and prompts further exploration of Coda's framework. | |
| Coda's Five-Stage Role Framework and First-Principles Leveling | 4 | 6 | 0 | 1 | Lane breaks down Coda's five-stage role framework from apprentice to principal, noting how compensation is detached from individual managers. Lenny asks clarifying questions about cross-functional consistency. | |
| Systems Over Goals, Active Listening, and the Beginner's Mind | 6 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Lane explains 'systems over goals' using Jerry Seinfeld's routine, while Lenny actively matches and elevates the discussion with an Airbnb host lunch example and Rick Rubin's philosophy on art and beginner's mind. | |
| Cathedrals Not Bricks and Finding Cross-Disciplinary Inspiration | 6 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Lane details the 'cathedrals, not bricks' principle and the power of multidisciplinary inspiration. Lenny augments the point with a famous Antoine de Saint-Exupery quote and insights on story arcs. | |
| Embracing 'Oh Shit' Moments and Moving Toward Obstacles | 5 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Lane discusses using 'oh shit' moments as a sharp metric for personal and professional growth. Lenny shares his own experience of fear and resistance when starting the podcast. | |
| Team Rituals and Calibrating Feedback with HubSpot's Flash Tags | 4 | 6 | 0 | 0 | Lane teaches Lenny Dharmesh Shah's HubSpot 'flash tags' ritual (FYI, suggestion, recommendation, plea) to calibrate feedback severity. Lenny expresses enthusiasm and reflects on executive communication dynamics. | |
| Sponsor Message: Ezra Full-Body MRI Screening | 5 | 7 | 0 | 0 | After an Ezra sponsor read, Lane explains Coda's multi-threaded review framework 'Catalyst,' $100 voting, and 'Tag ups' to avoid the telephone game of 1-on-1s. Lenny asks practical implementation questions. | |
| Creating the Rituals Handbook and YouTube's TrueView Ads Creation | 4 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Lane discusses compiling the Rituals Handbook and shares the origin story of TrueView skippable ads at YouTube, illustrating the principle 'learn by making, not talking.' Lenny connects it to Twitter's experimental velocity. | |
| Career Progression from the Tech Mailroom to Product Leadership | 6 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Lane details starting at Google manually reviewing AdWords ads and moving through customer support. Lenny connects Lane's customer-first lesson to Chip Conley's hospitality lessons at Airbnb. | |
| Tim Ferriss Day, Two-Way Write-Ups, and the 10% Planning Rule | 5 | 6 | 0 | 0 | Lane shares the viral Tim Ferriss Day story, the evolution of two-way write-ups replacing PowerPoint/one-way memos, and the 10% planning heuristic. Lenny enthusiastically endorses the 10% rule. | |
| Lightning Round, Parental Lessons, and Mountaineering Insights | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Lenny runs through the rapid-fire lightning round covering favorite books, interview techniques, parental lessons on active listening, and mountaineering tips before closing the interview. |
Statements from this episode (19)
Shackleton: Repeating advice in one-on-ones is a signal to document it
“Anytime you find as a leader yourself kind of like repeating the same lessons, it's a good, it should be a good flag to say like, oh, I could, I should probably scale this in some way.”
Shackleton: Tech career ladders are overly complex and inconsistent
“Most companies have career ladders with, like, 10 or 15 levels, and, you know, as soon as they hit some scale, the levels, there's, like, levels between levels, and I feel like I looked at the one at Google and, you know, you kind of, like, needed a PhD to dec…”
Shackleton: Career ladders flip employee focus from company to individual
“As soon as you introduce this, then the incentives sort of like flipped from being company focused to being individual focused.”
Shackleton: Most large tech companies have 10-15 levels, Coda has five
“I think most other companies, especially large companies has, have 10 to 15 levels. I think we've made a really conscious choice to have only five.”
Shackleton: Coda does not make employee levels publicly visible internally
“Role stages are not visible across the whole company. Like, you know, we're not showing levels of any individual PM or designer, and that's partially because we just don't want to put a big focus on it.”
Shackleton: Coda uses a centralized committee rather than managers for compensation
“We have a centralized compensation committee and that's who decides compensation. And so it's not the manager that drives your compensation.”
Shackleton: Product teams should focus on systems rather than goals
“Instead of being as obsessed with a goal, You know, be obsessed with the system that gets you there. And so the phrase I sometimes use is, you know, goals with good intentions don't work.”
Coda scheduled mandatory weekly Friday customer demo sessions in its early days
“In the early days of Coda, we actually did something similar. We had a time allotted on Fridays. And it was basically like, it was on the calendar, a customer or a potential customer was coming in. And so you knew that it was going to happen. And you had to ha…”
Shackleton: Great stories are built around a five-second moment of transformation
“The nugget of a great story is like five seconds of transformation. So if you just orient like everything else around that, like moment of trans, you know, transformation, then you end up usually telling a reasonably good story.”
Shackleton: Tracking 'Oh Shit' Moments Calibrates Career Growth
“The basic kind of thesis is that moments that stretch you are moments that you feel uncomfortable in, or you find yourself saying like, oh shit, you know, I shouldn't be here. I'm underqualified to be here. Those are the moments you should be seeking out, righ…”
Shackleton: Weighting all feedback equally slows organizations down
“Otherwise every bit of feedback is taken the same, which is just fundamentally like the impact of that is it slows everything down. Cause now you're looking at like a list of pieces, a hundred pieces of feedback and you're going like, oh man, we gotta address …”
Shackleton: Product reviews fail due to standing attendees and single-threaded agendas
“Most review forums are You know, product reviews or decision forums is that they generally suffer from two problems that are like kind of hard to spot unless you've sat through, you know, hundreds of them. The first is they have standing attendees. And the sec…”
Shackleton: Discussing product work in 1-on-1s is an anti-pattern
“A lot of work and project work tends to get discussed in one on ones. And actually that's like an, it's really an anti pattern. It's a pattern you should try to avoid. So if you're talking to your manager about product work what's not happening in that moment …”
Shackleton: Google previously required a CS degree for PM transitions
“I probably worked for at least four or five years before being able to move to PM. And that was, I think that was like a slightly harrowing journey because at the time you had to have a computer science degree.”
Shackleton: Assume people don't care to force sharper, concise communication
“You know, I think most people can be like way more concise with their communication. Like even internally, people don't care. You know, like you should assume that people don't care. Or, you know, if you're, you know, talking to customers, writing a blog post …”
Shackleton: Decision-making is shifting to interactive 'two-way write-ups'
“And then kind of the thesis is that we're like in the midst of a new phase, which is essentially two-way write-ups and that's where it's more conversational and feedback and discussion is like actually part of the content itself.”
Shackleton: OKRs are not strategy and must be separated from planning
“The first that I end up seeing a lot is just this idea that like, okay, ours are not actually strategy. So, you know, I think the way that, that we plan and the way that our customers plan, the kind of key point is it's critical to disconnect like strategy dis…”
Shackleton: Teams should spend at most 10% of execution time planning
“What we call a 10% planning rule, which is essentially, you know, just ensure that you're not for a given time period planning for more than 10% of that execution period.”
Shackleton: Test candidates by having them explain topics to laypeople and experts
“I sometimes do a version of making them explain it two different ways after and making the candidate explain it two different ways and saying like, okay, now you have to explain that to, you know, your grandparent. And then like now, you know, you just told me…”