Aug 7, 2017 · 1h 12m · capital-allocators
Kip McDaniel – CIO Whisperer (Capital Allocators, EP.20)
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of Capital Allocators, host Ted Seides interviews Kip McDaniel, Chief Content Officer at Institutional Investor, to discuss allocator psychology, industry rankings, investigative journalism, and institutional governance models across global pension systems.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Ted holds 22.6% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Ted as informed peer 3.9 Guest teaching 4.4 Guest disagreement 1.4 Ted pushing back 0.3
speaking balance: gold is Ted, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 55:32 Blasting pension return assumptions as idiocy
Kip forcefully denounces unrealistic 8.25% public pension return targets, labeling the practice as pure accounting manipulation and willful self-deception.
Hardest push from Ted ▶ 47:35 Pushing back on the dismissal of bespoke solutionsTed counters Kip's cynical dismissal of the term 'solutions', explaining that post-crisis allocator dynamics genuinely forced asset managers to unbundle products into tailored mandates.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 50:50 Explaining the governance edge of Canadian pensionsKip educates the audience on why Canadian crown corporation structures, commercial comp models, and high institutional trust insulate allocators from the politicized meddling common in US public funds.
Ted holds their own ▶ 44:00 Grounding modern factor investing in Yale's historical portfolio constructionTed demonstrates deep insider domain expertise by pointing out that modern factor premia models mirror the deliberate small-cap/value equity tilts Yale implemented decades earlier.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Ted as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Ted pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unconventional Entry into Financial Journalism | 3 | 4 | 1 | 0 | Ted opens by inviting Kip to explain how he stumbled into financial journalism without formal training. Kip tells an engaging personal story regarding his rowing career, Jack Meyer, and Harvard Endowment coverage. The atmosphere is warm, collaborative, and conversational. | |
| First Allocator Meetings and the Four Pillars Framework | 4 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Kip outlines how early meetings with CIOs like Jim Dunn formed his core four-pillar framework (asset allocation, portfolio construction, manager selection, risk management) and shares insights into allocator career ambitions. Ted prompts Kip on how to make dry institutional finance concepts entertaining. | |
| The Origin of 40 Under 40 and the Power 100 Rankings | 3 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Ted inquires about the genesis of industry recognition lists like the 40 Under 40 and Power 100. Kip candidly admits the lists originated from a colleague's idea and details how recruiter involvement created a Zagat-style ranking system. | |
| Managing Egos and Practicing Responsible Provocation | 4 | 5 | 2 | 0 | Kip recounts an anecdote about an offended CIO and explains his editorial mantra of 'responsible provocation' alongside the five weighted criteria for institutional power. Ted facilitates the breakdown of how reputation and influence are scored. | |
| Evaluating Rising Allocators for the 40 Under 40 List | 4 | 6 | 2 | 0 | Kip discusses vetting rising talent with CIOs and consultants, contrasting allocator modesty with the controlling egos of billionaire asset managers. Ted observes the media perception differences between asset owners and asset managers. | |
| Sponsor: Ridgeline AI-Native Investment Technology | 3 | 4 | 1 | 0 | After an ad read for Ridgeline, Ted asks about journalistic investigative practices. Kip details handling anonymous sources, off-the-record guidelines, and unverified tip emails attempting to undermine competitors. | |
| The Social Side of the Allocator Community | 4 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Ted nudges Kip to reveal both the most fun and the diciest experiences in his career. Kip shares how a threatened 100-million-dollar lawsuit tested his publication's resolve against industry bullying. | |
| Short-Term Compensation and Benchmark Distortions | 6 | 4 | 2 | 1 | Ted and Kip engage in an expert peer exchange dissecting the perverse incentives created by 1-year compensation horizons and NACUBO peer ranking comparisons. Ted contributes direct historical context from his time at Yale. | |
| Scale Advantages and Strategic Partnerships | 6 | 4 | 1 | 0 | Kip outlines how mega-funds like Texas Teachers leverage scale through strategic partnerships, while Ted reflects on factor-based investing roots at Yale and the challenges of timing factor exposures. | |
| Marketing Hype: Risk Parity, Solutions, and Smart Beta | 6 | 4 | 3 | 1 | Kip vents strong cynicism toward empty marketing jargon like 'solutions' and 'smart beta', while acknowledging Bridgewater's early sponsorship of his publication. Ted offers nuanced counterexamples regarding how product packaging evolved post-GFC. | |
| The Canadian Pension Model and Governance Superiority | 5 | 5 | 2 | 0 | Kip explains why the Canadian pension model excels through independent governance, commercial market salaries, and political insulation, contrasting it with US public pension constraints. Ted supports the discussion around direct investing models like CDPQ. | |
| Australian Superannuation and Global Asset Owners | 5 | 5 | 3 | 1 | Kip attacks unrealistic 8.25% public pension return assumptions as accounting fiction and critiques lazy asset manager client service. Ted interjects that altering liability budget targets is slow and difficult in practice. | |
| Future Allocator Success and the Mentorship Deficit | 4 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Kip argues that future allocator excellence relies on intelligent risk-taking, cross-peer collaboration, and intentional mentorship pipelines modeled after David Swenson. Ted frames the forward-looking question on organizational success factors. | |
| Literary Influences and the Mechanics of Power | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Ted initiates rapid-fire closing questions, asking about non-work obsessions and literature. Kip shares his passion for building dry-stone rock walls and his fascination with Robert Caro's biographical studies of political power. | |
| Investigative Journalism and 'The Departed' | 2 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Kip narrates the backstory of his investigative reporting piece 'The Departed', which uncovered a 15-year Ponzi scheme committed by a former Olympic rowing teammate. Ted listens intently with supportive reactions. | |
| Lessons in Humility and Advice to Younger Self | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Kip reflects with self-deprecating humor on his personal investing missteps in 2008 and advises his younger self to maintain perspective and stay calm. Ted wraps up the interview warmly. |
Statements from this episode (31)
McDaniel: Harvard endowment paid bond managers $30M each in 2004
“It was when the students were protesting the pay of two bond managers, Samuels and Middleman. They got thirty million bucks a year, that year, to manage bonds for the university endowment.”
Private capital funded 80% of LaGuardia Airport's refurbishment
“So my understanding is that 80% of the capital into that refurbishment is private capital, is our core audience.”
Majority of allocators aspire to end careers as Ivy League CIOs
“There are huge exceptions to this rule, but I would say certainly a majority of the allocators would love to end their careers as a CIO of an Ivy League endowment, and they will make, take creative paths to go there.”
McDaniel predicts Scott Malpass will never leave Notre Dame
“Some people, Scott Malpass, will never leave Notre Dame. He's in his dream job.”
Institutional Investor writers must anticipate who they will upset
“When we're writing stuff at Institutional Investor, we're trying to be what I call responsibly provocative. We never are gonna slander anyone. We're never gonna be mean about it, but sometimes people do wrong or do poorly in this industry, and we have to be wi…”
CIOs name Canadian and Australian funds as most respected peers
“The question I ask in every meeting with CIOs is which one of your peers do you respect the most? And there's a lot of commonality there. They'll always say one of the Canadian plans, They'll always mention an Australian or a sort of Nordic style plan and then…”
McDaniel predicts Mass PRIM's Sarah Samuels will become a CIO
“Sarah is the deputy CIO. When you speak to her, she, you know, knows exactly what she's talking about. She's at a big public plan. She will be a CIO one day, and at that time she was she may still be in her late thirties.”
Ultra-wealthy individuals are infuriated when they cannot control the media
“The way I put it is, when people get to a certain amount of wealth, it could be ten million, could be a billion, when, there, there'll come a time when they control almost every aspect of their lives. They have the houses they want. They may always want more, …”
Unpleasant behavior increases moving down the financial services value chain
“You know, the further down the value chain you get in asset management, in my view, sort of, not asset management, financial services. You have asset allocators on the end. They're the nicest group. And then within that group, probably corporate funds are the …”
McDaniel estimates 95% of his conversations with sources are off the record
“95% of my conversations are off the record now.”
McDaniel receives fake tips monthly aimed at undermining competitors
“I would say once a month I get an email that's clearly a made up Gmail account sending me something.”
Asset manager threatened a $100M defamation lawsuit over an investigative story
“We, I was threatened with a hundred million dollar lawsuit. They never filed it, and in my view, it was a bullying tactic. We wrote something about an asset manager. I was the editor of the story, and we wrote something about this firm that I know to this day …”
A long-term horizon is often an allocator's only competitive advantage
“We all know that the, one of the major advantages is being long-term. That is, in some cases, the only advantage an institutional investor has.”
Annual compensation cycles prevent allocators from being true long-term investors
“You can't actually be a long-term investor if every single person making a decision is compensated on a twelve-month cycle.”
Britt Harris accelerated institutional use of private equity strategic partnerships
“He, maybe not pioneered, but really accelerated the use of strategic partnerships.”
Average private fund fees have dropped to 1.5 and 18
“Now, I think that's going the way of the dodo. You know, it's, what is it, 1.5 and 18 now, but nothing says it's going to rebound to where it was. In average.”
Asset managers offer economic concessions to secure Yale seed capital
“You know, asset managers would love seed capital from Yale, and we're willing to give up a lot to get it, because of what it tells the market for the next fund.”
Yale's 1990s equity portfolios were deliberately biased toward small-cap value
“In the early nineties, Yale's US equity portfolio and international equity portfolio long only were by choice biased towards small cap and value.”
Nearly all US corporate pension funds use risk parity strategies
“You'd be hard pressed to find a corporate fund without risk parity.”
NISA and Legal & General dominate the US LDI space
“I think of a NISA investment advisors who are just, you know, along now with legal in general, really own the liability-driven investing space in America.”
McDaniel says 70% of asset managers fake offering bespoke solutions
“Again, very much ballparking. I'd say 30% of the asset managers actually changed the way they did business. The other 70% just pretended to change the way they do business.”
Allocators must leverage their size instead of copying David Swensen
“Underlying that all is the people who are going to be successful going back are the people who, Are actually thinking long-term, are actually trying to use their size to almost bully the asset manager into giving them what they want, a true solution. Those are…”
Canadian pension governance structures insulate compensation from political control
“The Canadians really set up the model so they're paying market wages. They may not be able to pay as much as Goldman Sachs in Toronto, but they're pretty darn close. They also set it up so that pay doesn't, it's not one year thing, it's three or five year thin…”
Canada Pension Plan effectively doubled its Skype investment within a year
“I think of Canada Pension Plan joining with Silver Lake and buying Skype. And waiting it out for like six months, there are some legal issues, and effectively doubling their investment in a year.”
US public pensions are unlikely to fix governance flaws for 30 years
“You know, will we get there with American public plans? I'm not sure in the, in my career. Hopefully I still have out of 30 years doing this, but I'm not sure we'll get there.”
Clever asset managers prioritize Australia's highly sophisticated capital pools
“You can always tell which asset managers Are clever by the ones that invest a lot of time in Australia. Bridgewater was a very early player in that space, because I think Ray Dalio understood that these people were very sophisticated, and there's money coming …”
Australian institutional investors operate on par with top Canadian pensions
“When you ask people about the sharpest investors, Future Fund, Aussie Super, Uni Super down there, They're doing things that the Canadians are also doing.”
McDaniel says pensions with 8.25% return targets are gaming their accounting
“Anyone who has an 8.25% target, all they're doing is, is gaming the accounting.”
Asset owner polling reveals 80% of asset managers provide poor service
“No asset manager thinks they're bad at client service, but when you pull asset owners, and we have formally pulled them, 80% of asset managers have poor client service.”
Investment consultants have not lost their power since 2009
“They were saying that when I started covering this in O-Nine, and I, as far as I can tell, consultants haven't lost an iota of power. They're gonna be here”
Harvard rowing coach Harry Parker mentored Bill Ackman and Reade Griffith
“One of the most important people in my life, he actually was the most important people in a lot of people's lives in finance, is a guy named Harry Parker, who was the Harvard rowing coach for 53 years. He coached Bill Ackman, coached Reed Griffith, who runs Te…”