Sep 24, 2018 · 1h 31m · capital-allocators
Raphael Arndt – Australia's Sovereign Wealth Fund CIO (Capital Allocators, Episode 70)
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of Capital Allocators, Ted Seides interviews Raphael Arndt, Chief Investment Officer of Australia's $145 billion Future Fund, exploring the sovereign wealth fund's total portfolio philosophy, factor-based risk modeling, external manager architecture, and collaborative governance culture. Arndt details how the fund navigates late-cycle macro risks by rejecting asset-class silos, avoiding levered mega-buyouts, dynamically managing liquidity, and aligning organizational incentives around whole-of-fund performance.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Ted holds 17.2% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Ted as informed peer 5.0 Guest teaching 4.8 Guest disagreement 1.3 Ted pushing back 1.8
speaking balance: gold is Ted, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 42:21 Dismissal of mega-cap private equity buyouts as levered beta
Arndt bluntly rejects conventional institutional allocation to mega buyouts, arguing they are merely levered equities stripped of excess returns by egregious manager fees.
Hardest push from Ted ▶ 38:15 Host challenges guest on market-neutral portfolio concentrationTed directly pushes back on Arndt's assertion of concentrated market-neutral books, noting multi-manager platforms typically hold thousands of diversified positions.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 15:01 Deconstruction of backward-looking mean-variance optimizationArndt educates listeners on the theoretical flaws of traditional CAPM and historical variance modeling, showing why dynamic forward-looking factor scenarios are essential.
Ted holds their own ▶ 31:04 Host probes manager capacity and internal management trade-offsTed leverages his deep institutional knowledge of peer Australian super funds to challenge how the Future Fund can deploy over a billion dollars per manager without internalizing.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Ted as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Ted pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raphael Arndt's Path from Engineering to Infrastructure | 3 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Ted opens the interview by asking Arndt to explain his non-traditional career trajectory. Arndt describes transitioning from civil engineering and oil platform design to private infrastructure policy and asset management. | |
| The Inception and Initial Mandate of the Future Fund | 4 | 4 | 0 | 1 | Ted inquires about the establishment and capitalization of Australia's Future Fund. Arndt details the government's budget surplus dilemma, unfunded pension obligations, and the Telstra privatization proceeds. | |
| The 'One Team, One Portfolio' Investment Philosophy | 5 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Ted asks how the 'one team, one portfolio' philosophy differs from legacy asset management models. Arndt explains how portfolio-level tail hedging works much better without siloed asset class incentives. | |
| Factor Attribution and Joined-Up Top-Down and Bottom-Up Analysis | 5 | 6 | 2 | 1 | Arndt critiques traditional backward-looking CAPM and mean-variance optimization, advocating instead for forward-looking factor attribution and top-down macro integration. He gives the concrete example of assessing Spanish toll roads alongside macroeconomic sovereign risk. | |
| Flexible Mandate, Governance, and Board Risk Parameters | 5 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Ted probes on how a flexible risk posture is governed with an oversight board. Arndt explains their mandate to dynamically vary risk according to prospective rewards rather than maintaining static allocations. | |
| Macro Risk Horizon and Skill-Based Real Estate Strategy | 5 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Ted questions how illiquid assets can be adjusted dynamically over a macro horizon. Arndt explains avoiding long-duration core real estate and rotating capital toward shorter-duration, skill-based demographic opportunities like US senior housing. | |
| Public Equities Exposure and Fund-Wide Asset Allocation | 5 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Ted asks for a breakdown of the overall asset allocation. Arndt details their 30% equity weighting, emerging markets tilt, 15% cash optionality, and intentional absence of physical bonds. | |
| External Manager Model and Navigating Capacity at Scale | 6 | 4 | 1 | 4 | Ted points out that large Australian superannuation peers shifted to internal management to solve capacity issues and asks how the Future Fund navigates external manager constraints. Arndt explains their strategy of cultivating high-conviction, peer-to-peer manager partnerships. | |
| Disaggregating Factors, Beta, and Alpha in Listed Equities | 6 | 6 | 2 | 3 | Arndt explains how performance attribution revealed that traditional long-only active managers largely canceled out to deliver expensive beta. He details unbundling low-cost factors from true alpha in market-neutral hedge funds. | |
| Sponsor Message: Ridgeline Investment Management Tech | 6 | 5 | 2 | 4 | Ted pushes back on the claim that market-neutral equity managers run concentrated portfolios, noting that multi-managers usually hold thousands of positions. Arndt clarifies that their underlying managers hold concentrated books within separated, non-overlapping managed accounts. | |
| Private Equity Strategy: Avoiding Levered Mega-Buyouts | 5 | 6 | 2 | 2 | Arndt explains their deliberate exclusion of mega-cap private equity buyouts, framing them as levered equities masked by high fee structures. He outlines their rigorous public market equivalent (PME) and leverage-stripping due diligence. | |
| Framework and Due Diligence for Co-Investments | 5 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Ted inquires about the due diligence process and performance tracking for co-investments. Arndt details their criteria, emphasizing manager alignment, avoiding secondary sell-downs, and tracking roughly 60-70 co-investments across PE and venture. | |
| Venture Capital Focus and Early-Stage Persistence | 5 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Ted asks why a sovereign wealth fund of their scale bothers with capacity-constrained venture capital. Arndt explains venture's persistent top-quartile power laws, recession correlation benefits, and 20%+ net returns over a decade. | |
| Navigating the 2008 Crisis and Opportunistic Credit Deployment | 5 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Arndt recounts the Future Fund's early days heading into the 2008 GFC with 80% cash. He describes deploying 15-20% of the portfolio rapidly into discounted senior and investment-grade credit mandates. | |
| Current Macro Outlook, Liquidity Stress-Testing, and Defensive Stance | 6 | 6 | 2 | 2 | Arndt outlines the fund's conservative macro positioning, nightly currency/equity stress-testing, rising US recession risk, and growing populist geopolitical friction. He emphasizes maintaining liquidity to seize future dislocation opportunities. | |
| Governance Model, Team Structure, and Collaborative Culture | 4 | 4 | 0 | 1 | Ted explores internal governance and decision-making structures. Arndt details the board composition, the 60-person investment team split across public, private, and portfolio strategy divisions, and their non-hierarchical culture. | |
| Mitigating Cognitive Bias and Total-Fund Compensation Alignment | 5 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Arndt explains how their chief culture officer introduced pre-meeting voting procedures to counter committee groupthink and hierarchy bias. He adds that all senior incentive compensation is tied purely to three-year total fund performance. | |
| US vs Australian Allocators and Long-Term Views on China | 5 | 6 | 2 | 1 | Ted asks about the differences between US and Australian allocators. Arndt notes US investor currency introspection and articulates the Future Fund's optimistic long-term view on China's emerging middle-class consumer demand and tech sector. | |
| Future Initiatives: Moving Toward a Networked Organization | 4 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Ted asks about multi-year strategic priorities. Arndt discusses replacing traditional top-down corporate hierarchy with a networked organizational model powered by modern collaborative technology. | |
| Fee Philosophy and Innovative Infrastructure Mandate Structuring | 6 | 6 | 2 | 2 | Arndt explains their refusal to pay private equity-style fees for core asset beta, using the Melbourne and Perth airport transactions to illustrate unbundling operational KPIs and negotiating cost-plus management contracts. |
Statements from this episode (31)
Future Fund started with A$60B including A$10B in escrowed Telstra shares
“Well, if you include all the inflows over a year or so, it was about sixty billion Australian dollars, of which about fifty billion was in cash, and about ten billion was in Telstra shares that were still in escrow, and were not allowed to be sold for two year…”
Arndt: Build Back Office and Custody Before Hiring Investors
“Very wisely made the decision that it was better to build the back office and the custody system and the legal approach first before you start hiring investment people, because, believe it or not, investment people want to start investing straight away.”
Future Fund Allocates 20% of Hedge Fund Book to Tail Protection
“So we have a couple of hedge fund strategies that really are sort of volatility traders or tail protection type mandates. And if we had diversified hedge fund portfolio, and if the person running that or the team running that were incentivized just based on th…”
Arndt: Most Funds Rely on Flawed, Backward-Looking Portfolio Construction
“Most funds, I would say, I might not like to think of it this way, but I would say they're quite backward looking in their portfolio construction. What I mean by that is they take this sort of cap M theory and their main variance optimization, and they look at…”
Future Fund Manages Its Massive Portfolio With 60 Melbourne-Based Investors
“We try to bring those things together by having a small team of 60 investors all in one office here in Melbourne, Australia.”
Future Fund Measures Risk Through Three-Year Rolling Cumulative Drawdowns
“And then secondly, we think about risk in terms of the cumulative drawdown over a three year rolling period, because we think as a public fund, we've got a responsibility to the public and to the taxpayer and the tolerance for bigger drawdowns over longer time…”
Arndt: Implied equity risk premium reliably predicts 10-year returns
“We can take the long bond rate or some forecast beyond that and say, disaggregate that and say, what is the implied equity risk premia? And that's actually a pretty good predictor of future returns over 10 years so.”
Arndt: Populist Politics Detracts From Economic Growth and Drives Inflation
“And then we're also looking at things like geopolitics trade disputes and things like that, which populist politics in general is usually detractive from economic growth and inflationary.”
Future Fund invests in US aged care development and infill housing
“For example, we're doing aged care development in the US at the moment because the demographics are such that there's just a definite need for more facilities in that space, or infill housing in places where, because of the impact of the financial crisis, peop…”
Arndt: Future Fund allocates 30% of its portfolio to public equities
“The equity exposure overall is about 30% of the fund, and that's roughly about half developed market equities and a quarter h of emerging market in Australian Equities.”
Future Fund Holds Almost No Physical Bonds Due to Low Yields
“We hold almost no physical bonds. We don't have any concept of liability matching. We've only got a return target, and bonds aren't paying all that well at the moment, so there doesn't seem to be a Strong reason to hold them, but we do have some rates exposure…”
Future Fund Manages Zero Assets Internally, Relying on 120 External Managers
“We actually don't manage any assets internally. So we use managers for all of our implementation, and we've probably got about a 120 or so managers on the books at the moment, and would like it not to grow too much more than that, just so that we have the band…”
Future Fund's 20 Active Equity Mandates Canceled Out to Beta
“When we aggregated up All of the maybe 20 or so mandates we had across that portfolio, by and large, they canceled each other out at the whole portfolio level, and I would have expected we would end up with something like beta less fees. Now, actually, as I sa…”
Arndt: Stock-picking skill is scarce and rapidly arbitraged away by tech
“We don't think that skill is widely available in equity markets today. Technology means that it's being arbitraged away very quickly”
Future Fund Shifted Equity Alpha Pursuit to Market-Neutral Hedge Funds
“Mainly our alpha program has now migrated to long short market neutral hedge funds, because we can pick managers with pure skill, and it's very evident if they have it or not very quickly. We're only paying for the alpha, but secondly, they have very concentra…”
Arndt: Many Large Multi-Strategy Hedge Funds Merely Deliver Expensive Beta
“Those large hedge fund, sort of multi-strategy hedge funds, many of them have delivered significant beta, whether it's equity beta, or credit beta, or other sort of momentum type exposure. And that is not something we want to pay for.”
Arndt: There Is Not Enough Global Skill to Allocate $45B to Alpha
“Today the equity book is maybe forty-five billion dollars, and we're just not going to find enough skill out there in the world to invest forty-five billion dollars”
Future Fund Avoids Large-Cap Buyouts Entirely in Private Equity Portfolio
“Our portfolio has no large buyout at all, because we think that, well, that makes the capacity so much harder, by the way, but we think that large buyout is really just levered equities, typically. And if there's skill added on top, and there might be, then mo…”
Arndt: Private Equity Leverage Adds LP Risk While Benefiting Managers
“Usually just using more debt gives the LPs more risk and more upside for the manager. But with a lot of downside risk”
Future Fund Never Re-Underwrites Co-Investments, Focusing Strictly on Manager Alignment
“We don't try to re underwrite the deal. We've already underwritten this manager. We've already backed them and we trust them. So our due diligence process will be focused on, is it in their skill set? Firstly, secondly, Is there alignment with the manager? Are…”
Arndt: Top-performing venture capital managers demonstrate rare performance persistence
“Firstly, our research showed that unlike almost any other asset class, the strongly performing managers tend to be persistent.”
Arndt: 80% of Venture Capital Managers Fail to Return Capital
“I think the data we saw at the time was something like 80% of venture Managers don't return capital and only six or seven percent return enough capital to justify their existence.”
Future Fund's Venture Capital Portfolio Generated Over 20% Net Across Decade
“And that portfolio has delivered, you know, really strong over 20% net returns over 10 years now, which is very satisfying considering what's been happening in the world.”
Future Fund Held Approximately 80% in Cash When Lehman Brothers Collapsed
“Fortuitously, and through some good decisions made by the people who were here before me, we were sitting with about 80% in cash when layman's went broke.”
Future Fund Deployed 20% Into Credit During 2008 Crisis, Returning 20%
“It was probably about 15 to 20% of the portfolio into credit over about three months. So it was quite a big decision, and clearly that decision paid off very well. Those initial investments returned above 20%.”
Arndt: Future Fund holds over 15% of portfolio in cash
“And so that's why you see us sitting with sort of a bit over 15% in cash.”
Future Fund CIO Focuses on Culture and Process Over Investment Decisions
“My job actually is much more about team structure and process and strategy and most importantly, culture than about making investment decisions.”
Future Fund Bonuses Depend Solely on Rolling Three-Year Total-Fund Returns
“So obviously we get base salaries, but we also have a bonus arrangement, which is linked to some extent to personal goals, which might be about the team or the individual responsibilities. Ah, and they're assessed by the managers, but the quantitative performa…”
Arndt: Total-Fund Fee Caps Exclude Essential Private Equity and VC Investments
“Some of our local peers here in superannuation who have to compete for members have decided to go down a road of setting a fee budget for the whole fund, and then reporting those fees as a competitive advantage in their marketing, and we think that risks cutti…”
Arndt: Big funds internalizing real assets will force industry-wide change
“What's happening in infrastructure and properties, the big funds, rather than doing that, they're internalizing, as you pointed out, and that is creating pressure on the industry. And that will force change.”
Arndt: Past investment regimes cannot be assumed to continue into the future
“One is just people who assume the future will be like the past, and I don't think that's a valid assumption. You know, there's a whole lot of things over the last 50 to 80 years, a huge leveraging cycle, a huge demographic boom post-war that have meant that ce…”