Jul 1, 2019 · 1h 22m · capital-allocators
Sam Sicilia – Seizing on a Long Time Horizon at HostPlus (EP.103)
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of Capital Allocators, host Ted Seides interviews Sam Sicilia, Chief Investment Officer of Hostplus, who explores how the Australian superannuation fund leverages its young demographic base, multi-decade time horizon, unlisted real assets, and human-centric manager selection to achieve sustained market outperformance.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Ted holds 17.3% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Ted as informed peer 3.9 Guest teaching 5.2 Guest disagreement 2.0 Ted pushing back 1.5
speaking balance: gold is Ted, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 58:02 Dismissing benchmark average return arguments
Sam bluntly rejects discussing average active management performance, asserting that macro averages are irrelevant to allocators targeting the extreme positive outlier tail.
Hardest push from Ted ▶ 36:21 Challenging development risk premium assumptionsTed directly challenges Sam's strategy of moving into development risk to maintain target returns, arguing that taking greater operational risk in a lower-yield environment still prices in compressed risk-adjusted margins.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 1:02:19 Redefining hedge funds as dry powder liquiditySam dismantles conventional allocator thinking regarding hedge funds as correlation hedges, schooling the host on using them strictly as gated cash-generating buffers to rebalance into discounted public equities.
Ted holds their own ▶ 55:23 Contrasting physics models with qualitative manager evaluationTed presses Sam on how a PhD mathematician reconciles quantitative factor models with purely qualitative assessments of individual manager motives.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Ted as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Ted pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Academic Foundations and the Limits of Quantitative Models | 4 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Ted probes into Sam's background in theoretical physics and mathematics. Sam explains why early quantitative models in finance failed due to human behavioral factors and unrealistic assumptions. | |
| Career Transition to Investment Consulting | 3 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Ted expresses surprise that an institution managing billions operated with just two people building spreadsheets in 2007. Sam clarifies the historical staffing context and Hostplus's transition to formal internal investment management. | |
| Demographics, Cash Flow, and Horizon Advantage | 3 | 6 | 2 | 1 | Sam educates Ted on the unique demographic profile of Hostplus, emphasizing that young member turnover continuously replenishes the fund's 30-to-40-year investment horizon. | |
| Return Objectives and Balancing Horizon vs Short-Term Risk | 4 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Sam outlines Hostplus's CPI plus 4 percent objective over 20-year periods while addressing how peer performance tables create short-term pressures. | |
| Industry Fund Collaboration and Shared Asset Management Entities | 4 | 6 | 2 | 1 | Ted asks about competitive dynamics among Australian super funds. Sam explains the distinct cooperative model where industry funds share due diligence costs and collectively own management platforms like IFM and ISPT. | |
| Strategic Asset Allocation and Unlisted Downside Protection | 4 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Sam details Hostplus's barbell asset allocation of 53 percent equities and 47 percent unlisted assets with zero allocation to fixed income and cash, explaining that unlisted asset cash flows serve as structural downside protection. | |
| Global Infrastructure Allocation and Responsible Asset Stewardship | 5 | 4 | 2 | 3 | Ted questions the political risks of foreign pension funds owning critical infrastructure and how principal-agent friction is managed. Sam insists long-term reputation and future capital access enforce alignment. | |
| Navigating Low Growth and Longevity Challenges | 6 | 5 | 3 | 5 | Ted pushes back on Sam's rationale for moving up the risk spectrum into development assets when core yields drop. Sam defends taking intentional development risk rather than settling for diluted single-digit operating yields. | |
| Restructuring Private Equity to Focus on People | 4 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Sam explains moving away from generic brand-name fund-of-funds toward identifying specific individuals and emerging GPs, arguing that manager pedigree matters far less than specific human motivation. | |
| Sponsor Announcement: Ridgeline Investment Platform | 3 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Following a sponsor break, Sam emphasizes that long-term relationships drive preferential access and lower fee terms, highlighting the appointment of Neil Stanford to structure the PE program. | |
| Dynamics of the Australian Venture Capital Ecosystem | 4 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Ted compares US venture access challenges with the Australian ecosystem. Sam explains the recovery of Australian VC post-dot-com crash and the influx of capital and talent into domestic tech and biotech. | |
| Public Equity Selection: Prioritizing Individual Manager Motivation | 4 | 6 | 3 | 1 | Sam describes an intense personal due diligence process that examines managers' private finances and lifestyle commitments to assess true retention risk and motivation. | |
| Quantitative Limits, Qualitative Alpha, and Market Inefficiencies | 5 | 6 | 4 | 2 | Ted asks how Sam reconciles his quantitative math training with subjective manager picking. Sam forcefully dismisses benchmark average comparisons, arguing that active management targets top-decile skew. | |
| Sourcing Emerging Managers and Boutique Advantages | 3 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Sam advocates backing hungry boutique spinouts and emerging managers early, creating long-term goodwill and guaranteed capacity in future funds. | |
| Redefining Hedge Funds as a Liquid Defensive Buffer | 5 | 6 | 3 | 1 | Sam reframes hedge funds away from equity volatility dampeners, defining them instead as a staged liquidity source to reallocate into equities during acute drawdowns. | |
| Investment Team Structure and Board Decision-Making Governance | 3 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Sam outlines Hostplus's lean investment structure and fiduciary decision-making model where the board acts like a jury and the investment team prosecutes the investment case. | |
| Fast-Tracking Co-Investments with the Special Investment Group | 3 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Sam explains how the Special Investment Group allows agile execution of co-investments and summarizes why Hostplus's unique demographics create sustained outperformance. |
Statements from this episode (28)
Sicilia: Human element and assumptions outweigh pure quantitative data in finance
“The tools were just that. But the human element in finance and that the assumptions that you need to make swamp any of the other benefits that the data provided at the time.”
Sicilia: Hostplus has grown to $42B in assets
“Today, Host Plus is forty two billion dollars in size, and so you can see that over a short 10 year period, that growth has been Remarkable.”
Hostplus outsources all $42B in asset management with 18 investment staff
“The investment staff is currently 18 people, but we do not manage any money in-house. At this point in time, we prefer to outsource all money management”
Sicilia: Hostplus Serves 1.2M Members with Average Age of 34
“We have a 180,000 contributing employers and 1.2 million members.
Average age, 34.”
Sicilia: Australia's Super Retirement Age Will Likely Reach 70
“In a system that you cannot take your money out of the system unless you reach retirement age, which is currently 65, but more likely going to be 70 by the time they get there.”
Sicilia: Hospitality and Retail Funds Capture Half of First-Time Workers
“About half of the first time job entrance belong to those two funds, and every other super fund in the country gets the other half.”
Sicilia: Hostplus placed top-quartile in 16 of past 20 years
“So over the last 20 financial years, Host Plus has been top quartile in 16 of them.”
Sicilia: Hostplus return target is inflation plus 4% over 20 years
“So for Host Plus, our return objectives are inflation plus four percent per annum over 20 year periods.”
Sicilia: Industry super funds collectively own asset managers IFM and ISPT
“We own two asset management firms. So, 20 or so industry funds, and almost 30 or so industry funds own IFM, Industry Fund Management Advisors, or IFM Advisors, and who does infrastructure globally, and another entity, ISPT, Industry Super Property Trust, who d…”
Sicilia views fee savings from fund-owned vehicles as a riskless return
“When you own those vehicles, and as I said, 20 or so industry funds own those vehicles. You can get preferential fees, and you can deliver the fee saving directly to your members as a riskless return.”
Hostplus allocates 0% to fixed income, opting for unlisted assets instead
“53% of our strategic asset allocation is public equities, listed equities. It's a combination of domestic equities and international equities developed markets and international equities emerging markets. 53% in total. The other 47% is unlisted infrastructure,…”
Sicilia: Unlisted asset stability stems from cash flows, not just valuation lag
“Our downside protection comes from unlisted assets. The volatility of the equity markets is dampened By the existence of unlisted assets in varying degrees, and that's not just a valuation lag. It's also to do with the quality of the cash flows that you get fr…”
Sicilia: Pension fund ownership prevents predatory wealth extraction from infrastructure
“So the concept of super normal extraction of wealth and abhorrent returns just isn't going to happen if you have pension fund owners. It's unnecessary.”
Sicilia: Allocators should resist deploying capital into 6% infrastructure returns
“So the temptation to invest in infrastructure assets that are generating six percent returns, therefore diluting your portfolio return,
Is huge.
But you should resist that temptation.
That is not a good idea to go down that path.
It's better to find some other…”
Traditional pension models are mathematically broken by multi-decade retirement lifespans
“The real issue is that pension funds were designed at times when people retired at age 65 and conveniently died at age 68.
Today, people retire at 65 or 70 and live to a 108.
How are you going to survive 30 or 40 years not working, not generating an income, li…”
Sicilia: Hostplus invests in specific individuals rather than brand-name asset managers
“In fact, if you look at Host Plus's website, you won't see too many brand names across any asset class, because we don't invest in brands We invest in individuals.”
Sicilia: Performance should never be the reason to exit an investment
“If you know why you make an investment, then you have a ready-made reason to get out of it if that reason changes. Performance is never one of them.”
Sicilia: Relationships drive 95% of private equity investing success
“And in some asset classes, like private equity in general, or private markets, but private equity in particular, without a relationship, we won't do the investment. Relationships are 95% of the driving force. People underestimate how important relationships ar…”
Sicilia: Hostplus committed $1.2B to VC, largest among Australian super funds
“Including Hostplus putting 1.2 billion dollars into venture capital, which makes Hostplus the biggest Australian institutional investor super fund in venture capital by a long shot”
Hostplus demands intrusive personal financial details from prospective fund managers
“How much money do you earn? How many kids do you have? What schools do they go to? What are the school fees like? At what stage are you at? What car do you drive? Is it mortgaged? There's a whole set of, you have a right not to answer those questions, but you'…”
Sicilia: Boutique, hungry investment managers bearing business risk outperform
“Boutique is better. Hungry is better. Having a business risk is better.”
Hostplus uses hedge funds as crisis liquidity, not for volatility protection
“So we view hedge funds playing that role rather than protecting the portfolio from The volatility of equity markets. Our unlisted assets have that role.”
Sicilia: Poor operational execution and vehicle structuring leaves money on the table
“You can leave money on the table by not implementing Investments properly, by not implementing board decisions properly, by not structuring vehicles properly, by not taking into account tax and other obligations that we have, FX, settlements, et cetera, proper…”
Hostplus board makes all investment decisions, acting as a jury
“The board makes all investment decisions. Our job is to work with Jana, our asset consultant. And prepare the case, if you like. Think of the board like a jury.”
Hostplus uses a 4-director subcommittee for agile co-investment approvals
“Internally, the board has formed a small subcommittee of four directors, which we call the SIG, the Special Investment Group, and they can be called on demand
On a deal by deal basis.
And they can get together and work with the internal team and have a delegat…”
Hostplus has never lost a frontline investment professional in its history
“In the frontline investment people, operations has had, you'd expect to have some turnover in the operations, but we've never lost an investment person. It's been cumulative, but it's never gone the other way.”
Sicilia: Asset management fees should plateau rather than increase linearly
“How do you justify the fact that if you're managing a bond portfolio or an equities portfolio and you're trading, that the fee goes up in a linear way, more or less, if I give you five hundred million or a billion or three billion? Surely it should plateau At …”
Institutional LPs hold the power to end two-and-twenty fee structures
“Institutional investors are the market. You're charging yourself, right? Who is going to change that? Who is going to take action to finally put an end to two and 20? Well, where is the power? Without your allocation, they can't generate a fee. I'm just asking…”