May 23, 2024 · 1h 24m · capital-allocators
Dan Tennebaum - The Case for India at India Capital (EP.387)
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
Host Ted Seides interviews Dan Tannenbaum, Managing Director at India Capital, exploring his 25-year journey investing in India and the structural case for allocating capital to Indian public equities. Tannenbaum breaks down India Capital's bottom-up fundamental research, governance diligence, and concentrated portfolio strategy designed to capture India's rapid economic expansion.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Ted holds 12.6% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Ted as informed peer 2.9 Guest teaching 4.7 Guest disagreement 0.3 Ted pushing back 0.1
speaking balance: gold is Ted, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 1:02:40 Rejecting the 'Late to the Party' Foreign Investor Premise
Dan directly contradicts the widespread institutional narrative that foreign money has crowded the Indian market, pointing out that foreign net flows have been net flat while domestic retail drove the rally.
Hardest push from Ted ▶ 55:30 Challenging Premature Exits on Long-Term HoldingsTed presses Dan on how to balance giving a founder the benefit of the doubt versus cutting a long-held compounder when management pivots into unproven adjacencies.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 30:25 Deconstructing India vs China Shareholder Value CreationDan breaks down hard comparative data showing that while China grew GDP 16x with only 2.5x index returns, India's 8x GDP growth translated directly into 8x equity index returns due to superior capital discipline.
Ted holds their own ▶ 29:17 Framing the Macro Beta and Chindia ComparisonTed frames the historical 'BRICs' and 'Chindia' narrative to steer Dan into a rigorous structural comparison between Chinese state-led growth and Indian private market returns.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Ted as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Ted pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Episode Overview: Dan Tannenbaum on India Capital | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Introductory monologue and mailbag segment by the host introducing Dan Tannenbaum and India Capital. No guest interaction takes place. | |
| From Minnesota to Mumbai: Joining India Life | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Ted prompts Dan on his unusual background moving from Minnesota to Mumbai. Dan shares the history of joining India Life and early outsourcing dynamics in late 1990s India. | |
| Navigating Bureaucracy and Infrastructure in 1990s India | 2 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Dan vividly explains the intense bureaucratic delays, naming disputes with regulators, and infrastructure bottlenecks faced by early startups in Mumbai. | |
| Harvard Business School and Early Venture Capital Lessons | 3 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Dan details why venture capital struggled in India historically with weak arbitration enforcement and 35-cent dollar realizations, contrasting it with strong public equity returns. | |
| Entrepreneurial Grit and Shifting to Public Equities | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Dan explains the founding of India Capital by John Thorne in 1994 and how they built an eclectic team of non-traditional research analysts. | |
| Weathering the Global Financial Crisis | 3 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Dan describes navigating the psychological strain of the 2008 financial crisis in India and highlights the high structural manager attrition in Indian public equities. | |
| Comparing Long-Term Value Creation: India vs. China | 4 | 6 | 1 | 1 | Ted asks about the macro beta thesis comparing India to China. Dan provides concrete data showing India's capital efficiency and GDP growth translating into index returns far better than China's. | |
| India Capital's Deep Fundamental Research Philosophy | 3 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Dan explains India Capital's core thesis that research matters in an under-covered market where index constituents are often not the best return-on-equity performers. | |
| Growth, Valuation Discipline, and the Power Ecosystem | 3 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Ted probes on growth versus valuation, and Dan counters standard Western assumptions by showing how capital goods and power in India are fast-growing sectors with mispriced niche players. | |
| Proprietary Research in Action: Gas Pipeline Diligence | 3 | 6 | 0 | 0 | Dan walks through a detailed case study of proprietary channel checks on a natural gas pipeline, reconstructing industrial customer substitute costs that sell-side analysts overlooked. | |
| Assessing Management Quality and Spotting Governance Red Flags | 3 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Dan pushes back against the myth that foreign investors need insider connections to spot fraud in India, explaining that forensic examination of financial statements reveals the governance red flags. | |
| Government Regulation and State-Owned Enterprises | 3 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Dan discusses navigating regulatory uncertainty and notes that certain state-owned enterprises actually make focused, high-dividend, disciplined investments. | |
| Portfolio Construction and Discipline in Exits | 4 | 5 | 0 | 1 | Ted asks how Dan manages exits in a concentrated 16-stock portfolio. Dan details an example of an auto component supplier transitioning to defense under succession. | |
| Managing Operational Inflation and Investor Communication | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Dan explains how their domestic-facing portfolio weathered input cost inflation post-Ukraine invasion and how transparent communication retained LP capital through downturns. | |
| Evolution of LP Base and Institutional Demand for India | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Dan reflects on how India transitioned from an esoteric allocation backed by large institutional contrarians like Soros to a mainstream single-country mandate. | |
| Debunking Misconceptions: Valuations and Domestic Flows | 3 | 6 | 1 | 0 | Dan dispels two major investor misconceptions: that foreigners have already crowded into India (net flows are near zero while domestic retail drove fifty-five billion dollars) and that valuations are purely multiple-driven. | |
| Small Cap Froth and Banking Sector Dynamics | 3 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Dan points out that small-cap indices in India are trading at an anomalous premium to large caps and discusses technological scale advantages in leading private banks. | |
| Deep Dive Case Study: Power Project Finance | 3 | 6 | 0 | 0 | Dan lays out an in-depth case study of an unloved, state-affiliated power transmission lender, demonstrating how granular asset inspections revealed strong underlying recoveries. | |
| India's Future Drivers: Consumption and Credit Expansion | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Dan outlines forward-looking opportunities in domestic consumption and credit penetration before answering Ted's closing questions about career and life lessons. |
Statements from this episode (37)
Tannenbaum: 90% to 95% of top Indian graduates emigrated in the 1990s
“I think of top Indian schools back then, 90, 95% of people left.”
Tannenbaum: Indian regulators delayed startup funding a year over company name
“The venture capital investment that we were expecting any day from overseas, the government body called the Foreign Investment Promotion Board that was responsible for reviewing and approving this investment determined that all the paperwork was in order, ever…”
Tannenbaum: In 1990s India, top university graduates made $100 per month
“The average Indian back then was earning barely a dollar a day, and even the people who were my colleagues who'd gone to top flight universities were earning maybe a hundred dollars a month.”
Tannenbaum: India's share of world economy fell from one-third to 3%
“What had once upon a time been pushing a third of global economic activity after the depredations of conquest and colonialism and a flirtation with socialism was three percent of the global economy.”
Tannenbaum: Indian private markets returned 35 cents per dollar since 2000
“Of every dollar invested since 2000, something like 35 cents has come back, and I'm sure the industry will come good, but as I was sort of looking over the proverbial wall at other asset classes, it's not exactly apples to apples comparison, but for example, i…”
Tannenbaum: Conglomerates are suboptimal everywhere in the world except in India
“So much so that there's a Harvard Business School professor I worked with named Tarun Khanna, who'd done this seminal research where he said, conglomerates are the worst form of business unit and organization and suboptimal everywhere in the world, except Indi…”
Tannenbaum: Indian Markets Suffer High Manager Attrition and Weak Duration
“In the Indian context, that's a curious thing that market performance has been pretty strong, but manager attrition is really high and duration is not so hot.”
Tannenbaum: India Has 700 to 1,500 Institutionally Investable Public Companies
“There are more than 5000 publicly traded companies. Of which, depending on how you cut it, anywhere from 700 to upwards of 1500 are investable at institutional scale.”
Tannenbaum: India Is Among the Most Fragmented and Liquid Emerging Markets
“It's among the most fragmented markets in the world in terms of all the different themes and industries that are represented, and it is among the most liquid for an emerging market.”
Tannenbaum: Two-Thirds of Indian Public Companies Lack Analyst Coverage
“Two thirds or three quarters of companies have one or zero sell side analysts covering them.”
Tannenbaum: India's stock index matched 8x GDP growth since 1999, beating China
“China's GDP growth has been 16 X versus eight X for India, but China's index performance on that 16 X GDP growth has been two and a half X, and India's index performance on that eight X GDP growth has also been eight X.”
Tannenbaum: India's private sector debt-to-GDP is ~53% compared to China's ~195%
“Private sector debt to GDP in India is like, 53%. I think in China it's a 195%.”
Tannenbaum: 5% of Indian public companies are state-owned versus China's 30%
“About five percent of the companies are majority government owned. I think in China, it's 30 or 40 or more percent.”
Tannenbaum: India adds 1M labor force entrants and 1M urban migrants monthly
“And now it's India where there are a million people joining the labor force each month and a million more moving from the hinterlands to the cities.”
Tannenbaum: Top Indian index constituents often lag smaller peers in ROE
“In many cases, it's not the largest, the highest profile, the indexed constituent Representative of a particular theme that's actually gonna do best from a shareholder or return on equity standpoint, and it's that appetite to roll up our sleeves and try and un…”
Tannenbaum: Top 3-6 Indian lenders capture outsized revenue and earnings
“You'll tend to see historically very fragmented industries in India where there are 300 publicly traded bank and non-bank lenders that are beginning to give way To concentration where the top three or five or six are accounting for an outside share of top line…”
Tannenbaum: Cement, power, and real estate are high-growth sectors in India
“There are growth businesses like cement, like power, like real estate, that from a US context, we say, oh, they're pretty mature sectors. In India, they're not mature at all.”
Tannenbaum: Highest ROE Indian power company trades at 8x earnings
“One of the fastest growing in By some distance, the highest return on equity participant in the power sector is trading at eight times earnings.”
Tannenbaum: Indian power transmission lender earns 22% ROE
“There is a specialized lender to power transmission companies that earns a 22% ROE”
Tannenbaum: Indian corporate disclosure is strong but data aggregation is poor
“In India where data disclosure is really good, but data aggregation isn't so good, that's allowed us to do some pretty classic filters for earnings, consistency, quality, things of that nature.”
Tannenbaum: Fundamental research creates bigger, longer-lasting edge in India than US
“Whereas when I think about my US experience, and it doesn't matter how small the company, how novel the research approach, there are a lot of other people poring over the same idea in The differentiated edge is going to be small and short-lived. In India, some…”
Tannenbaum: Major Indian corporate blowups were large caps with unanimous buy ratings
“Just in the time I've been investing, there have been permanent losses of capital in one of the largest banks, in more than one of the leading telecom companies, in the largest brick and mortar retail company, one of the big software companies, and these were …”
Tannenbaum: Indian corporate collapses almost always show public red flags beforehand
“Very seldom have these things gone bust, and afterwards people said there's absolutely nothing that would have suggested this. Usually there's something in how they've allocated capital, How they've done business with associated companies, margins they earn th…”
Tannenbaum: Strict regulation has limited asset quality collapses in Indian banking
“In the Indian banking sector, which is small and fast growing, there have been relatively few asset quality collapses in part because the regulator has been fairly strict in what they allow banks to pursue and what they don't.”
Tannenbaum: India Capital previously bought airplane seats for physical share certificate boxes
“There were times that we had to buy an airplane ticket, one for a custodian, and a second airplane ticket in the seat next to them for a box full of share certificates, so they could be physically delivered to The buyer, so the trade would close smoothly.”
Tannenbaum: Tactical trading in Indian equities has a very limited success rate
“I think in the Indian context, what we found is anything that starts to approach tactical trading in and out of a position for any reason has a pretty limited success rate”
Tannenbaum: Indian index return drops from 17x to 0.3x excluding 25 days
“I think since 1990, I want to say the index is up 17 fold in dollar terms. If you take out the top 25 trading days, it's up .3 X in dollar terms”
Tannenbaum: Net Foreign Allocator Flows to India Are Functionally Zero
“Net flows from foreign allocators are functionally zero to India.”
Tannenbaum: Domestic Capital and 75M Mutual Fund Accounts Fuel Indian Market
“What's been fueling the market is domestic investment, which over that same period is something like fifty-five billion dollars, and there are seventy-five million new mutual fund investors, which even in the Indian context is a big number, and pension exposur…”
Tannenbaum: 75% to 80% of Indian Large-Cap Returns Are EPS-Driven
“The other is that valuations must be expensive, and because India has had a relatively decent run, that too feels like it should be the case, but when you decompose it, yes, returns have been okay, but because earnings growth has been pretty strong for the lar…”
Tannenbaum: Indian Small-Caps Trade at 3 to 5 Turn Premium Over Large-Caps
“Very small companies are actually unusually expensive right now, where there are small cap indexes trading at a three or four or five turn premium to the larger cap index.”
Tannenbaum: Top Six Indian Private Banks Combined Are 1/7th Size of ICBC
“India's largest bank is smaller than China's 11th largest bank. Its largest six private sector banks put together are one seventh the size of ICBC.”
Tannenbaum: Indian share prices historically lagged operational performance for years
“In the past, one of the hard things about India is you could be absolutely right about the operating performance trajectory, and the transmission to share prices could be incredibly slow.”
Tannenbaum: 80% of new power generating capacity in India is renewable
“In reality, 80% of new generating capacity in India is renewable.”
Tannenbaum: 300M Indians are entering the lower middle class
“Some of it's in the consumption basket with income per capita now at 2500 dollars. You're going from a place where two-thirds of that was consumed by food and shelter In housing to a place where people really have disposable income. Three hundred million India…”