why aren't all 20 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Luckey: U.S. Suffers Severe Disadvantages in Almost All Simulated China War Games
“And the result of this is that today, in almost every war game that the United States simulates against China or their proxies, the United States, ah, if we don't lose, certainly end up in a very, very bad situation.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Luckey: John Deere Tractors Have More AI Than Any Fielded DOD System
“There's more AI in a John Deere tractor than there is in any system that the U.S. DOD is fielding.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Luckey: Silicon Valley execs used anti-defense protests to mask China dependence
“I could give a whole talk on how the executives of Silicon Valley used the vocal minority of their rank and file as a smoke screen for their dependence on China, but that's a different talk for a different day.”
Opinion
Luckey: US Engineers Must Choose Defense Over Ad Optimization and Photo Filters
“Tens of thousands of engineers across our entire country that are not working on defense currently are going to have to ask themselves if there are more important things in their careers than building photo filters or doing ad optimization.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Luckey: U.S. Government Has No Secret Game-Changing Defense Technology
“For the most part, what you saw was what you got, and of course, there's a lot of interesting classified programs and a lot of interesting black programs, but there was nothing that was going to fundamentally alter the nature of the types of conflicts that wer…”
Assertion Supported
Luckey: Nearly two-thirds of major US weapons contracts have one bidder
“Nearly two-thirds of major weapons system contracts in the United States have just one bidder.”
Opinion
Luckey: Silicon Valley was the last to understand national security threats
“The technology industry prides itself on being the first to understand where things are heading, but on national security and the rise of our strategic adversaries, it was the last.”
Disclosure
Luckey: Early VCs rejected Anduril due to moral objections to defense tech
“Many early investors actually turned us down, because while they believed that we had a good team, good people, good technology, good product market fit, they thought that it was inherently wrong to build tools capable of being used for violence.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Luckey: China and Russia outpace US in adopting commercial tech
“China and Russia and our adversarial nations are not waiting and have, in many ways, been much more successful at adopting commercial technology into their military process.”
What-if
Luckey: Pre-arming Ukraine with advanced weapons would have prevented invasion
“If the Ukrainians had an arsenal of advanced technologically sophisticated weaponry from the start, if we'd been able to equip them and make them a prickly porcupine that nobody wanted to step on, then this conflict likely never would have even started.”
Assertion Supported
Luckey: U.S. Nuclear Arsenal Operated on Floppy Disks Until 2019
“And until 2019, the United States' nuclear arsenal was still operating off of floppy disks.”
Assertion Partly supported
Luckey: SpaceX and Palantir were the only DoD defense unicorns in 30 years
“And if you look at the last 30 years that preceded Andrel, there were only two unicorns doing business with the DoD, Palantir and SpaceX that were able to become unicorns.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Luckey: Future battlefields will be driven by cheap autonomous AI
“The battle of the field of the future is going to team with artificially intelligent autonomous systems that are built with much lower cost in mind.”
Opinion
Luckey: Modernizing Military Requires New Startups, Not Just Existing Billionaires
“We need dozens of new innovative companies that are going to modernize our military, and I want to point out these can't be companies that are founded by people who have already made billions of dollars running other companies.”
Assertion Supported
Luckey: Legacy defense contractors spend only 1-4% on internal R&D
“We now have a defense industry that spends a measly one to four percent of revenue on internal research and development, IRAD.”
Disclosure
Luckey: Anduril spends over 50% of revenue on R&D
“Anderil's currently spending over 50% of our revenue on research and development.”
Assertion Partly supported
Luckey: Top 10 US defense firms capture over 80% of industry revenue
“The 10 largest defense companies in the United States account for over 80% of the industry's revenue.”
Assertion Contradicted
Luckey: Non-defense sectors produced hundreds of unicorns while defense yielded two
“In that same thirty-year time period, there have been I think it's four mattress unicorns 12 fast casual dining unicorns, over 50 gaming unicorns, over a hundred social media and mobile application unicorns, over a hundred financial technology unicorns, over a…”
Assertion Partly supported
Luckey: DoD funded half of Stanford's engineering budget in 1947
“In, in 1947, half of Stanford's engineering budget came from the Department of Defense.”
Assertion Supported
Luckey: US DoD accounted for 36% of global R&D in 1960
“And that's why in 1960, the Department of Defense accounted for 36% of all research and development in the entire world.”