why aren't all 20 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Wang: China will not implode; US-China competition is a long-term grind
“There is no implosion. When one side is ahead, the other side will overstep, and then the, then, and then they'll need to catch up. And so I want to say that there is no winner here. There is no loser here. It's not a race. Nobody gets to hit the win button. A…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wang: US infrastructure and clean tech legislation has produced minimal tangible construction
“There's been very little by way of infrastructure actually built by the Infrastructure Act, and there's been very little built by the way of clean technology.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wang: Chinese manufacturers retooled faster than US firms in COVID crisis
“When China had a crisis, as it did in with the COVID pandemic, when it had a production issue, there were a lot of pretty inefficient state-owned enterprises, as well as entrepreneurial firms that had a giant workforce that had a lot of slack in the system, an…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Wang: U.S.-China competition will last decades, unresolvable by AI alone
“What I want to say is that the competition, I believe, between the U.S. And China will Last for decades. It will not be solved or resolved through any single technology, not even a technology as crucial as artificial intelligence.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Dan Wang: China is advancing tech capabilities faster than the US
“Over the last 15 years, the U.S. Has a lead on software, no question about that. But its manufacturing and hardware has not gotten that much better. So the Chinese are learning at a much faster rate and patching up their deficiencies than the Americans are.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Wang: Military conflict between China and Taiwan is not imminent or inevitable
“In his view, the their conflict between Beijing and Taipei is not imminent and not inevitable, and that's kind of my view.”
Assertion Supported
Wang: Zero passengers have ridden California High Speed Rail 15 years post-approval
“Not far away is the California High Speed Rail Project meant to connect San Francisco and Los Angeles. It's been more than 15 years since voters approved this referendum to build this train. How many people have taken this train? Precisely zero.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wang: Federal personnel costs are a minor part of US budget
“Personnel costs are not a giant aspect of America's budget, and arguably we need a lot more personnel in order to, you know, process drug discoveries and make the FDA much more efficient, Process high-skilled immigrant visas and have a much more functional gov…”
Assertion Supported
Wang: Xi Jinping promoted aerospace and defense leaders to govern Chinese provinces
“What Xi Jinping did was that he elevated a lot of the leaders of China's military industrial complex, the people who ran China's crewed space missions, the people who ran China's biggest weapons companies, and he elevated them to be provincial party secretarie…”
Assertion Partly supported
Wang: China controls 90% of the global solar supply chain
“On the other hand, China owns pretty much 90% of this industry, everything from the polysilicon processing down to module assembly.”
Assertion Partly supported
Wang: 35 of 40 global nuclear plants under construction are in China
“There's something like something like 40 nuclear plants under construction in the world, and 35 of them are in China right now.”
Assertion Supported
Wang: Cancer Rates Near Chinese Rare Earth Facilities Are Extremely High
“If we take a look at some of the rare earth processing facilities around China, the cancer rates are off the charts.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Wang: China's demographic contraction is a 50-year problem, not 5-year crisis
“Yeah, I think that China's demographic situation is a problem more in the next 50 years rather than the next five years.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wang: Chinese rural areas have high-speed rail while US relies on cars
“In the Chinese countryside, a lot of the remote villages are still really well connected by bridges, by high-speed rail, by highways, and in the U.S. Countryside, there's basically roads and cars and almost nothing else.”
Assertion Contradicted
Wang: Silicon Valley is the only place home to trillion-dollar companies
“What Silicon Valley does have, what we have here is, you know, companies worth trillions of dollars, which is not something that any other country is able to claim.”
Assertion Partly supported
Wang: 47 US senators attended law school; only one holds STEM degree
“Right now, I think there's something like 47 U.S. Senators who went to law school, and one has had any degree that resembles a STEM degree.”
Assertion Supported
Wang: Adding a San Francisco bus lane took 20 years to complete
“Van Ness Avenue has tried to add a bus line onto the avenue for something like 20 years. It took about 20 years, more or less, to add a bus lane.”
Assertion Supported
Wang: China's strategic industries are dominated by three state-owned enterprises each
“So all of these upstream strategic industries like telecommunications airlines energy, essentially these are always organized by three giant state-owned companies that control pretty much the entire state of the business.”
Assertion Partly supported
Wang: China manufacturing is ~27% of GDP vs US 10-11%
“Right now, last I checked, China's share of its economy dedicated to manufacturing is about something like 26, 27%, and for the U.S. It is about 10, 11%.”
Assertion Partly supported
Wang: China accounts for one-third of global manufacturing value-added
“China is responsible for about a third of manufacturing value added globally.”