why aren't all 33 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Power: U.S. would take 5 years to rebuild exhausted ballistics inventory
“But if we have one conflict with China where we expand most of our ballistics inventory, We might not be able to remake it for like five years. Then we're basically standing around, you know, with our hands tied behind our backs.”
Assertion Contradicted
Chris Power claims 90% of US solar panels use Chinese slave labor
“90% of the solar panels in the country are being made in China by basically slave labor where millions of minority and immigrant women are being chemically castrated every year and forced into servitude.”
Assertion Partly supported
Ukraine depleted three years of US missile inventory in three weeks
“We shipped the Ukrainians what we thought was three years of inventory of stinger and javelin missiles, which are shoulder mounted, really cheap missiles that can take out a tank or something. So for providing that to a human force in Taiwan or the Ukraine, it…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Power: China is 20 years ahead of the US in manufacturing autonomy
“As of right now, if you look at, like, the PlayStation five as a product, like, that is effectively, I would say, 90% of fully automated production line, and, like, writ large across the board, people really miss this, and I think it's, like, strategic CCP com…”
Assertion Contradicted
Power: US no longer manufactures capital equipment for domestic factories
“We don't even make the CapEx that goes into the factories in the US anymore. Like it's all German, South Korean, Japanese or whatever, and they're controlled products.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Power: Legacy defense manufacturing facilities could not be permitted today
“Even the basics, like some of the exquisite stuff can only be made in a certain state to feed the defense ecosystem because all the other states banned it or like they're literally in facilities that got certified 50 years ago and you could like, you literally…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Power: US government will pick category winners in defense within two years
“I think alongside that certain areas of the government where there's a lot of immature companies, they're going to spend the next year making eight bets and seeing how it plays out. And in certain other areas, I think in the next two years, what you're going t…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Power: China demographic decline accelerates Taiwan conflict timeline
“My thesis on this is because of the one child policy is going to really drop off China's population very quickly at a certain period of time. It creates this forcing function where in my opinion that the Taiwan scenario is more likely to happen because if they…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Power: Deterring China for 10-15 years secures peace for 300 years
“I think that unless it goes hot in 28 is going to be 10 to 15 years. And as long as we can Hold them off there. Then their population drops off and we're good for another 300 years. Like that's kind of how I view the equation.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Hadrian waited months for Los Angeles power permits after fast construction
“Designed and launched the actual building and all the construction in three months, and then sat around waiting for permits and energy for six to nine months and probably had to put more documentation together to convince Southern California Edison to give me …”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Power: U.S. way of life faces existential risk without manufacturing reform
“Unless we solve this problem, I think the country and, you know, our way of life is, is a six existential risk.”
Assertion Supported
US had to reverse-engineer B-2 bomber parts due to lost documentation
“About a year ago, the government had to issue an RFQ for some of the parts on the B to not just to replace the parts, but because no one, you know, the guy that designed it or engineered it retired and they didn't have it documented anywhere. Like there's lite…”
Assertion Contradicted
Over 50% of the US F-16 fleet is grounded missing parts
“If you look at the DOD stats, more than 50% of the F-sixteans are grounded, and it's mostly because they can't maintain them, and it's mostly because they can't get parts, and what ends up happening is they end up cannibalizing other planes for parts, and that…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Chris Power: Legacy defense supply chains break half of their promises
“Culturally, basically the entire industry is tooled up around 50% of our promises we break all the time.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Replenishing US ballistics after a China conflict could take five years
“In reality, we're probably so far away from doing that, that if we have one conflict with China, where we expand most of our ballistics inventory, we might not be able to remake it for like five years.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Destroying fewer than 10 GPS satellites could cripple Western infrastructure
“There are like less than 50 GPS satellites, and all of those can be shot out of the air pretty easily, and all that's preventing, you know, some adversary doing that and basically collapsing Western civilization in one fell swoop, taking out, you know, less th…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
The US lacks 1,000 workers qualified to build advanced semiconductor fabs
“You know, you can't go and hire 20,000 people or even a thousand people that know how to go and execute that construction, how to go engineer that factory, how to go run that factory. They just simply don't exist.”
Assertion Contradicted
Power: Traditional manufacturing factories lack real-time operational observability dashboards
“No factory on the planet has observability. So you can't simply, and maybe like Foxconn does but you can't simply throw up in a dashboard and go, what is my uptime? Where are the costs for this job? How much labor did we spend on it? It's all kind of swags and…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Power: Reliable supply chains will cut aerospace manufacturing costs by 30-50%
“Most of the products will be able to drop their manufacturing costs by like 30 to 50%, not because of cheaper parts, but because of the reliability and the ability to compress schedule around that reliability.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
API-driven manufacturing will let hardware startups launch without $40M in funding
“It's going to be amazing in a couple of years to see, you know, a bunch of like engineering grads you know, tooling around at their garage and like, Seeing, seeing Google style startups happen without forty million dollars in funding and just to get off the gr…”
Assertion Contradicted
Power: Most highly skilled U.S. manufacturing workers are 62 years old
“And then the real underlying problem is my thesis is that basically everyone that's highly skilled in any manufacturing domain is basically 62.”
Assertion Contradicted
Most skilled US defense manufacturing workers are 62 years old
“The thesis of the company is basically, if people don't know this, most of the skilled labor in the defense industrial base is 62 years old. That makes the components or Widgets that end up getting assembled into drones, fighter jets, missiles any hardware tha…”
Assertion Partly supported
The average US defense manufacturing owner-operator is 62 years old
“Average age of a worker is like 55. Average age of an owner-operator who's a small business owner that is actually, you know, needed to function in the business is 62.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Power: Geopolitical defense wake-up call coming within two years
“It's incredibly scary, and I think people are going to get a really hard wake up call in the next two years.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Chris Power: Hadrian gives factory technicians equity tied to software engineer tiers
“And I think we're probably the only factory on the planet outside of SpaceX that is giving everyone in these roles, you know, the same tier of equity as the best software engineers have, you know every technician in Hadrian, whether you're packing boxes or whe…”
Assertion Contradicted
Power: Electricity accounts for 95% of aluminum manufacturing costs
“Like, 95% of the cost of aluminum is just the kilowatt hour of the power price.”
Prediction Partly held up
Hadrian will launch two 500,000-square-foot manufacturing facilities next year
“We built a 100,000 square foot in LA, and then we're going to launch two new facilities next year, which are about half a million square foot each, and then we'll keep expanding to every state”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Power: Hadrian software engineers must work factory floor jobs biweekly
“Trying to get it down to single threaded, like the person that's building the automation for this part of the product is capable of actually doing that job. And it's forced to do that job every couple of weeks and like relearn the real Real user pain is, is an…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Power: Legacy machine shops suffer from extreme, non-standardized hardware variability
“Most legacy machine shops have one of every machine ever made. And even within, you know, they have 20 machines, five of them might be the same, but even those five are set up a completely different way.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Power: Space Technology Will Function as Infrastructure, Not Have a Killer App
“No, I don't think there's a killer app and I don't think there will be because it's like you know, does your average consumer, You know, know about AWS, not really like outside of our technology domain, but like can any of the stuff that they love exist withou…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Power: Microgravity R&D Enables Superior Medical and Materials Research
“So much of the like cancer or genetic research is. Can only be performed or can be performed like far, far better in terms of materials or chemical research in space. And I think there, if there's a major pharma breakthrough where it's like, oh, we cured the l…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Chris Power: US won WWII through manufacturing scale, not superior weapons
“You know, in the US really won World War II because of manufacturing and logistics, not because we necessarily had The shiniest missile or whatever.”
Assertion Supported
Power: 20,000 to 30,000 small businesses form U.S. defense base
“So there's something like 20 to 30,000 small businesses that make up the majority of the defense industrial base.”