why aren't all 9 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Not checkable as stated
DLJ had zero ethical lapses while Credit Suisse failed despite massive compliance
“Credit Suisse had all kinds of ethical lapses. DLJ had none, but they had immense controllers and process and whatnot. DLJ was skeletal.”
Insight
Tony James: High ethical norms protect firms better than heavy compliance layers
“Putting more controls in doesn't necessarily protect you. That a lot of it, if you have good people, and you trust them, and you hold them to very high ethical standards, and that becomes the behavioral norm, That's much better than having lots of watchers and…”
Opinion
Tony James: DLJ merchant banking wasted away under Credit Suisse
“Once it got put into a Swiss bank, they had all of the institutional issues and the lack of commitment to the principal business that all the other big firms had, so it kind of started to waste away”
Assertion Partly supported
DLJ extracted $400M in equity the day after the Household buyout
“I think it was the third biggest LBO ever called we bought the retailing subsidiaries from Household International. We ended up with Vons and Ben Franklin and TGI and Coast to Coast Hardware Stores, and we sliced and diced and sold them all, and we closed, and…”
Assertion Supported
Tony James: DLJ had $29B AUM when sold to Credit Suisse
“And that, and we built that business when we sold DOJ to Credit Suisse, it was about a twenty-nine billion dollar AUM business. Blackstone at the time was high teens”
Disclosure
DLJ risked 40% of firm equity per bridge loan in 2000
“Our success in, in, in high yield and private equity meant we'd running out of balance sheet. Our bridge fund was one billion dollars, and all of a sudden you were doing one billion dollar bridge loans, so you can do one deal at a time, and if one mistake and …”
Assertion Partly supported
DLJ's first private equity fund achieved a 90% IRR
“I think our first fund had a 90% IRR.”
Disclosure
Tony James reveals DLJ made early investments in Starbucks alongside Costco
“Starbucks too, by the way.”
Assertion Partly supported
Tony James: DLJ grew over 15% annually for 25 consecutive years
“We grew DLJ from essentially nothing to the fifth largest securities firm. We grew it at over 15% for 25 consecutive years.”