why aren't all 11 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 1 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Open · timeframe Oct 2028
Rampell: Rumors suggest Google DeepMind will solve the Navier-Stokes equation
“There's a rumor that the Navier-Stokes equation is going to be solved by DeepMind, which would be huge.”
Insight
Shanahan: Reinforcement learning progress does not require massive datasets
“Actually, DeepMind are another example of the same thing, because if you want to apply reinforcement learning to games, and that's enabled them to make some quite fundamental sort of progress, you don't need vast amounts of data either.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Schuler: U of Alberta AI algorithms run four times faster than DeepMind's
“We're actually meeting some of the deep mind algorithms that they have right now. We're roughly four times faster, I believe.”
Insight
Shanahan: Machine learning must be embedded within larger cognitive architectures
“I see machine learning as a kind of subfield of artificial intelligence, and it's a subfield that's had tremendously a tremendous amount of success in recent years, and is going to go very, very far, but ultimately, the machine learning components have to be e…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Parker-Holder: Top robotics simulators still face significant sim-to-real gaps
“The robotic simulations are even the best ones, and we have some of the best ones at DeepMind and Majoko, right, which we work with. They're still quite far away from the real world, right? And so you have the sim to real gap.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Murati: OpenAI and DeepMind were the only AGI-focused labs
“There were two places at the time that were laser focused on this issue and OpenAI and DeepMind.”
Assertion Partly supported
Chen: AlphaGo Zero used 4 TPUs and 3 days, crushing prior versions
“It was 48 TPUs versus four. It was three days versus 40. It was thirty million trained games versus 4.9. So Order of magnitude improvement on all of those dimensions.”
Assertion Partly supported
Chen: Google powers DeepMind algorithms using commodity x86 PC hardware
“Like if you look at an x-a-t-e-s server in a data center, exactly the servers that Google is using to compute deep mind algorithms, they're PCs.”
Assertion Supported
Shanahan: DeepMind's published DQN algorithm lacks inner rehearsal capabilities
“For the bit of work that they actually published, I think one of its shortcomings, actually, is that, in fact, although it has done all that learning about what the right action to do in, in the right circumstance is, it doesn't actually do in a rehearsal. It …”
Assertion Supported
2022 DeepMind paper showed dataset size matters more than parameter count
“In fact, in twenty-twenty-two, a pivotal paper came out that changed the way that many people in the research community thought about this very calculus. And it demonstrated that datasets were actually more important than just the sheer size of the model.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Schuler: 20-25% of DeepMind staff at acquisition were University of Alberta students
“When DeepMind got bought, half the people there were actually Canadian-trained, and roughly 20 or 25% were our students.”