Oct 26, 2017 · 28m · a16z
The Future of Money: Banking on Fintech
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this presentation, Andreessen Horowitz General Partner Alex Rampell analyzes how software and digital platforms are systematically unbundling traditional banking and insurance institutions. He outlines key fintech investment opportunities, examining how startups leverage alternative data, novel product formats, and superior user experience to compete against legacy incumbents.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. How this is scored →
The host as informed peer 0.0 Guest teaching 0.0 Guest disagreement 0.0 The host pushing back 0.0
speaking balance: gold is the host, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 22:30 Critique of discretionary active fund managers
In an overall non-combative presentation, Rampell directly criticizes active fund managers for underperforming passive indexes and losing Warren Buffett's public bet.
Hardest push from the host ▶ 4:40 Pushback on the startup disruption narrativeBecause the host does not speak in this monologue, this moment captures Rampell pushing back against tech optimism by noting that incumbents usually beat startups in financial services.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 6:15 Explaining fundamental banking yield spreadsRampell provides a clear educational breakdown of how large banks generate substantial profits by taking near-zero interest deposits and lending them out via credit cards at 18%.
The host holds their own ▶ 27:30 Strategic analysis of infrastructure wedge modelsIn lieu of host participation, this segment highlights high-level strategic expertise as Rampell analyzes how payment processors use commodity infrastructure as a wedge to acquire zero-CAC lending customers.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The host as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The host pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unbundling Marketplaces: The Craigslist Example | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Alex Rampell delivers a solo presentation drawing an analogy between unbundling Craigslist and unbundling traditional banks like Wells Fargo. Because this is a monologue presentation without host participation, host expertise and pushback are scored zero. | |
| Startup vs. Incumbent: Innovation versus Distribution | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell discusses demographic shifts in consumer behavior and the core race between startup innovation and incumbent distribution. The host does not speak or intervene during this monologue segment. | |
| Disrupting Core Banking and Lending Spreads | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell breaks down the wide interest rate spreads in core banking and explains how peer-to-peer lending platforms attack these spreads. The presentation dynamic remains standard and non-combative with no host interaction. | |
| Driving Innovation: User Experience and Alternative Data Underwriting | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell details how fintechs leverage improved user experience and novel data inputs like mobile device usage and applicant behavior to underwrite credit. There is no host engagement in this segment. | |
| Novel Behavioral Data for Credit Underwriting | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell outlines how alternative data allows newer lending platforms to scale rapidly and expand from initial niche products into full banking offerings. The monologue format continues uninterrupted. | |
| Non-Traditional Financial Products Beyond Core Banking | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell explains non-traditional financial products that banks avoid, such as home equity sharing, and discusses the high capital challenges of starting insurance companies. Host scores remain zero. | |
| Customer Acquisition Challenges in Insurance Advertising | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell examines customer acquisition costs in insurance advertising on Google and introduces emerging insurance categories like autonomous vehicles and cybersecurity. No host dialogue occurs. | |
| Homogeneous Group Selection and Dynamic Risk Pooling | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell reviews group self-insurance dynamics, automated underwriting through apps, and real-time sensor data from connected cars and wearables. The presentation maintains a steady educational tone. | |
| Rise of Passive Indexing and Robo-Advisors | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell analyzes the rise of passive indexing over active managers, robo-advisors acting as arms merchants to banks, and key investment frameworks for fintech startups. The monologue contains no host participation. | |
| Financial Infrastructure as a Wedge for Value-Added Services | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Rampell concludes by emphasizing the value of unglamorous infrastructure companies like Stripe, Square, and Blend that scale by layering higher-margin financial products onto existing distribution. |
Statements from this episode (32)
Rampell: Banking faces an Amazon moment as physical branches become anachronistic
“We really think the Amazon moment is coming to banking, and I'll talk a little bit more about why and how, but a lot of it is really, it's predicated or it's related to this idea of the physical location being a little bit more of an anachronism than a buildin…”
Rampell: Wells Fargo's legacy tech is held together with scotch tape
“It's been kind of tied together with, ah, with bubble gum and scotch tape and paper clips for about 3040 years as they've continued merging and buying other banks.”
Rampell: Fintech startups are unbundling banks category by category like Craigslist
“Along have come many, many startups, and what the startups have done is, one by one, they've picked off a particular category. They've taken this broad horizontal marketplace, kind of like Craigslist, and category by category, they've attacked these different …”
Rampell: Incumbents must get innovation before startups get distribution
“The battle between every startup and incumbent really comes down to this one thing, which is whether the incumbent gets innovation before the startup gets distribution.”
Rampell: Incumbents usually defeat startups despite venture capital backing
“Generally speaking even though we're in the business of backing startups and we want them to win, generally speaking, the victor tends to be the incumbent.”
Rampell: Startups beat banks by entering non-bank financial services
“It actually provides an interesting way of beating this distribution versus innovation challenge, because if you're not competing with the bank, if you're going after a new area of financial services that banks don't want to be in, in many cases, the startup a…”
Rampell: Chase pays 0.1% yield on $1 trillion in core deposits
“So Chase has about a trillion dollars in core deposits, so it's a lot of money, and the average yield that they make on one of those, if you have a money market or a current account at Chase, you're earning about .one percent, so not a lot. Chase has the secon…”
Rampell: Government backing protects legacy mortgage markets from fintech disruption
“Mortgages are a little bit trickier because they often have an implicit or explicit government backing, so it's hard for a private company to kind of make a non-jumbo mortgage market.”
Rampell: Affirm underwrites loans in half a second using five fields
“This is actually a company that's in our portfolio that actually I co-founded called Affirm. We just need name, email, mobile number, birthday, and the last four of your social security number, and within about half a second, we can underwrite a loan.”
Rampell: Branch uses smartphone data to underwrite loans in Sub-Saharan Africa
“Where, ah, they do lending in Sub-Saharan Africa in Kenya, Tanzania, and also Nigeria. How do they do that? How do they figure out, do I make a loan to a particular person when there's no information on them? Well, it turns out there's a lot of information sit…”
Rampell: SoFi offers lower loan rates by targeting high-earning STEM graduates
“A company called SoFi, which is one of the biggest fintech companies in the U.S. And now expanding internationally, they look at, I mean, it's kind of a little cheat, But they look at where did you go to school, and do you have the prospect of being a high-ear…”
Rampell: LendUp found applicants spending longer on sliders are lower credit risks
“One of the things that they found is the longer time that you spend on this slider determining, like, how much of a loan should I take out, the better of a customer you are. The shorter the period that you go through a loan process, the worse of a customer you…”
Rampell: SoFi reached $15 billion in loan originations in six years
“SoFi has done about fifteen billion dollars of loan originations, and SoFi is only six years old.”
Rampell: Student loan refinancing is not a long-term sustainable business
“Student loan refinance is, it's a temporary arbitrage opportunity, but it's actually probably not a long-term sustainable business.”
Rampell: SoFi originates $150M+ monthly in mortgages via student loan acquisition
“So, SoFi, now they have jumbo mortgages that they offer. They're doing, Well over a hundred and fifty million dollars a month of mortgage originations on their platform because they got the customer through student lending.”
Rampell: Banks will not compete with private fix-and-flip lenders
“So private lenders like Lending Home and Pierce Street do that, and banks aren't going to compete with them.”
Rampell: Fragmented 1-800 search results signal ripe marketplace opportunities
“If you ever do a Google search and you see 10,000 results and every result ends up with a call this one 800 number and it has really bad clip art on it, that is an opportunity for a new marketplace to emerge.”
Rampell: Insurance received less venture capital funding due to underwriting difficulty
“Insurance for the longest time was almost an underfunded market. And part of the reason why insurance was underfunded relative to the size of the industry and relative to how big lending is, it's really hard to get insurance right.”
Rampell: Insurance advertising accounts for a big chunk of Google's value
“Google is now second most valuable company on earth, and a big chunk of their market cap is coming from insurance.”
Rampell: Roughly 25% of Google's most expensive keywords are insurance-related
“25%, more or less, of the most expensive keywords on Google are insurance related.”
Rampell: Geico spends $100M per year on Google search ads
“Geico spends a hundred million dollars a year buying keywords on Google.”
Rampell: Insurance startups suffer adverse selection from high-risk early adopters
“You don't want to get people that have a proclivity to die very quickly or get in car accidents very quickly, and those are the people that are most likely to want to get the brand new startup insurance product.”
Rampell: Canadian bank robberies average just $200 per branch heist
“I met the CEO of a large bank who was saying that when somebody robs This is one of their branches. The average take is about 200 dollars. This is a Canadian bank, which makes it the worst ROI of any crime in the world at this point in time, because if you're …”
Rampell: Insurance carriers were originally founded around homogeneous risk groups
“Many insurance companies, if you trace them back to their original formation point, they were founded around insuring a kind of homogeneous group. So farmers insurance or state farm, they were designed for farmers.”
Rampell: Internet-connected cars like Teslas will sell personalized insurance directly
“One of the really cool things about the new cars like the Teslas that have built in, ah, three G antennas because they're internet connected, is you could actually imagine your next car selling you insurance, because all the information that you need is actual…”
Rampell: Consumer fintechs pivot to B2B when direct distribution fails
“Many startups consequently in the financial services space, I think it's an interesting lesson, they give up on being consumer players because they realize that this distribution path is too hard. Instead, they are actually very content to be arms merchants to…”
Rampell: Chase robo-advisor is powered by startup InvestCloud
“So for example, Chase has a robo-advisor, and that is powered by a startup called InvestCloud.”
Rampell: Affirm Achieves Zero Customer Acquisition Cost via Merchants
“Affirm, our insight was We'll use merchants to get distribution. So our cost, cost of customer acquisition is zero because we partner with merchants”
Rampell: Credit Karma Valued at $5B with 55M Monthly Active Users
“So there's a company called Credit Karma, which is probably the most valuable private FinTech company in the market, about five billion dollar valuation right now. Hundreds of millions of dollars of revenue because fifty-five million people log into their Cred…”
Rampell: Boring financial infrastructure enables subsequent product innovation
“One of the key learnings is if you go very boring and build infrastructure, you can later layer on your own innovation.”
Rampell: Square's customer acquisition cost for Square Capital is zero
“The cost of acquiring customers for their lending product is zero.”
Rampell: Stripe will continually launch new financial services using merchant distribution
“Stripe will continue rolling out new products and services because they own the distribution layer for what is often pejoratively considered a very low margin commodity business, and that might be true, but they have a great engineering team on top of that.”