Jun 14, 2023 · 40m · a16z
Ben Horowitz on Executive Firing (and Hiring)
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of the a16z podcast, Andreessen Horowitz co-founder Ben Horowitz and Databricks CEO Ali Ghodsi discuss the full lifecycle of executive management, from hiring and onboarding to performance evaluation and respectful termination. They provide actionable frameworks for tech founders on evaluating growth potential, avoiding cultural friction, and conducting compassionate executive offboarding.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. How this is scored →
The host as informed peer 5.6 Guest teaching 3.3 Guest disagreement 1.2 The host pushing back 1.4
speaking balance: gold is the host, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 3:50 Ali pushes back on high leverage bar
Ali directly challenges Ben's standard that executives must provide more ideas than they receive, arguing that exceptional leaders frequently have significant weaknesses that CEOs must accommodate.
Hardest push from the host ▶ 31:28 Ben enforces review policy with financial sanctionsBen describes refusing to accept his sales chief's explicit dismissal of company review policies, withholding all raises and equity grants across the sales department until compliance was met.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 7:46 Ali's playbook for handling super ICsAli educates Ben on how over-promoted managers who excel strictly as individual contributors can be re-titled and repositioned into super IC roles to preserve critical organizational talent.
The host holds their own ▶ 21:53 Ben's LLM context framework for CEO intuitionBen delivers an authoritative breakdown comparing the CEO's accumulated historical context to a large language model, explaining precisely why brilliant external hires fail when operating without that context.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The host as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The host pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Identifying When an Executive Has Reached Their Limit | 5 | 3 | 2 | 2 | Ben proposes that an executive is done if the CEO gives them more ideas than receiving back. Ali gently reframes this as a high bar, noting that strong executives often have pronounced weaknesses that must be accepted alongside their strengths, though Ben defends his expectation based on high executive compensation. | |
| Evaluating Growth Potential, Domain Expertise, and Super ICs | 6 | 3 | 1 | 2 | Ben articulates a sharp rule distinguishing sales and marketing knowledge (external market expertise) from engineering knowledge (internal context). Ali complements this by explaining how over-promoted executives can be successfully transitioned into super individual contributor roles. | |
| Mastering the Difficult Executive Termination Conversation | 6 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Ben outlines the psychological mistake CEOs make when firing executives by factually listing flaws rather than acknowledging shared responsibility. Ali echoes this by sharing his tactical opening question 'How do you think it is going?' to align on reality smoothly. | |
| Offboarding Philosophy, Cross-Functional Alignment, and Preserving Dignity | 6 | 2 | 2 | 1 | Ali explains how he guides failing executives to see organizational misalignment before discussing career transitions, and explicitly rejects public firing approaches like Netflix's. Ben quotes Bill Campbell to emphasize taking an executive's job without stripping away their dignity. | |
| Onboarding Executives, Managing Context, and Securing Quick Wins | 6 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Ali describes his daily informal check-in routine for onboarding new executives to build context and trust quickly. Ben uses a large language model analogy to explain why external hires fail without the CEO's accumulated historical context, invoking Andy Grove's task relevant maturity. | |
| Integrating into Company Culture Before Driving Change | 5 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Ali warns new executives against arrogantly name-dropping past big-tech employers and forcing immediate cultural changes. Ben asks how Databricks successfully integrated a enterprise sales culture into an academic engineering environment, prompting Ali to describe how initial revenue struggles humbled the organization. | |
| Preventing Incompatible Micro-Cultures and Departmental Hostility | 5 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Ben shares a story from Opsware where he withheld compensation upgrades across an entire sales organization when the executive refused to submit performance reviews. Ali matches this with a story about eliminating the toxic phrase 'Sales Prevention Department' at Databricks. | |
| Hiring Executive Builders vs Playbook Copy Pasters | 6 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Ben highlights the critical difference between someone who can write a playbook versus someone who merely ran one in a larger company. Ali details his '5 Whys' interview method to probe whether candidates possess deep foundational operational knowledge. | |
| Early Search Timing and CEO Ownership in Executive Hiring | 5 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Ali outlines the nearly two-year cost of a bad executive hire, urging founders to start searches early. Ben adds that interviewing candidates before positions are officially open is the best way for inexperienced CEOs to learn what excellence looks like. |
Statements from this episode (27)
Ghodsi: A CEO questioning an executive's fit means they must be replaced
“It's when you're asking other people, what do you think? Or when you're starting to have the thoughts of like, is this the right person or is it not the right person? You're done.”
Horowitz: Effective executives educate the CEO on expanding their function
“If you have somebody who's really doing the job, what you always find as CEO is they're kind of teaching you about how the function should expand, how should it grow, and if you're giving them a lot of ideas, like more ideas than you're getting out, then that'…”
Horowitz: Executives who lose their team's trust must be fired
“The one thing that's always true is if the team doesn't believe in the executive anymore, it doesn't even matter. Like, they can, like, say whatever you want to me, Ali. I still have to fire you because nobody's following you.”
Horowitz: Sales leaders need external knowledge, engineering leaders need internal knowledge
“The other thing I'd say is, I think a mistake a lot of companies make is, You know, in engineering and in product and so forth, the knowledge of how your company works is really, really valuable. But in sales and marketing, the knowledge of how, like, other pe…”
Horowitz: Hiring an inexperienced internal MBA for sales leadership is a mistake
“Like go buy the knowledge, go buy the acceleration as opposed to, and I don't really care how much potential your internal smart MBA who doesn't have any experience has like, you know, the idea that they're going to run worldwide sales for you if you've got a …”
Ghodsi: Tech founders frequently underestimate the difficulty of sales and marketing
“You know, so you either have typically have tech CEOs and founders who are really good at tech, they're smart, maybe they have an engineering degree, and like, well, how hard can the sales or marketing be, right? Yeah, it turns out very hard.”
Ghodsi: CEOs must fire disengaged executives who check out after role changes
“But the disengaged, the person you like, who's kind of just disengaged, and kind of just phoning it in, is the hardest one. So, I think you have to do a hard thing about hard things, and there, I think there's really no option but to have the conversation, and…”
Horowitz: Firing an executive is usually more than half the CEO's fault
“And the actual truth, when you fire somebody, is mistakes were made. If you're being objective, it's always partially your fault, usually more than half your fault, if you're honest.”
Ghodsi: Executives admit performance issues in half of termination talks
“My first question is usually, how do you think it's going? And you know, in 50% of the cases they'll say it's not going well.”
Ghodsi: Founders who mis-hire executives owe them maximum offboarding generosity
“I disagree with that. I think from then on, it's you owe them. You're the one that made the mistake of hiring them to be as generous as possible within reason.”
Horowitz: Terminating an executive should never strip them of their dignity
“You have to take his job. You do not have to take his dignity. That's not, that is not necessary. And I think that, that just goes a long way also for the people who are still in the company.”
Ghodsi: Databricks CEO calls every new executive hire daily
“I try to, if I have a new executive, I call them every day. When they're new, I call them every day.”
Horowitz: Context deficiency is the primary cause of executive failure
“And that is like having watched executives fail, that's the number one thing they fail on is they don't have the context.”
Horowitz: New executives will always propose at least one nonsensical task
“And like, what I always find if you ask an executive what they're going to do tomorrow, and they're new, they'll always say at least one thing that makes no fucking sense at all.”
Horowitz: New executives who spend a month only learning get fired
“I once had an executive came and he had read like the Stephen Covey, Seven Habits, a highly effective people. And he's like, well, what I'm going to do is first I'm going to seek to understand and then be understood. And I'm going to spend like a month, like j…”
Ali Ghodsi: Execs must integrate into company culture before changing it
“You have to become part of the organism, and you have to kind of Succeed in it to change it. I think it's very hard otherwise from the outside.”
Ghodsi: Early product-led growth capped Databricks deal sizes at $30K
“And we could not do a deal that was bigger than 20 30 K. It was just impossible.”
Ghodsi: Enterprise sales drove 50% of Databricks revenue within one year
“It wasn't until he then went at it for one year and the end of that year, suddenly half of our revenue was enterprise.”
Ghodsi: Product-led growth is overrated for enterprise software
“This PLG thing is just overrated for the kind of business we have in the kind of market we are in.”
Horowitz: Good executive hires can introduce insidious, incompatible micro-cultures
“You know, when executives come in and they are good, sometimes they'll want to bring like a small piece of culture that is just incompatible. And I think that, that can be very insidious if you're not careful.”
Horowitz withheld a department's equity to force an executive to write reviews
“So he didn't write the review, and I just, I withhold, held all the raises, equity, ups, everything for his organization. I was like, you can't, nobody can get any, everybody else in the company got their equity and their money.”
Ghodsi: Big company departments hate each other more than external competitors
“Cause you know, you get into the big companies form cultures like this, like big companies where the different departments, yeah, it's like the different departments hate each other more than they hate the enemy.”
Horowitz: Hiring an AdWords sales executive for enterprise software always fails
“So like if you go, And hire like an enterprise sales guy who's selling Google AdWords. He's a hundred percent going to fail.”
Horowitz: Asking candidates to write a playbook exposes superficial executives
“Tell me what you did at your last company exactly. How was it built? How was it constructed to, okay, now imagine, like, you're here. How would you write this playbook? That'll screw people up if they've not done it, right? Like, if they only saw it It's a ver…”
Ghodsi: An executive hiring mistake costs two years of progress
“I say mistakes take between a year and a half to two years. Takes you six months. Jury's out. Is this, do we really need, nobody wants to Fired someone within six months of hiring someone, right? So you've taken six months, then you need to have this conversat…”
Horowitz: CEOs learn executive excellence by interviewing many candidates
“The best way to know is actually to talk to a bunch of CFOs Ask them how they know what's good. What's the difference between a good CFO and a great CFO? How do you know that? How do you interview for that? Like all those kinds of things, that knowledge you on…”
Ghodsi: New CEOs must personally handle executive searches and backdoors
“If you're new and you don't really know what a great CFO or CRO or VP of engineering looks like, you should be immersing yourself, spending all the time interviewing everyone, doing backdoors everyone. Doing dinners with people you can't get.”