Jul 17, 2018 · 47m · 20vc
20VC: Elad Gil's High Growth Handbook on The Commonalities of The Truly Great CEOs, How To Hire The Very Best Execs, Why Cash is A Defensible Moat Today & The Pros and Cons of M&A and IPOs
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of The 20 Minute VC, host Harry Stebbings interviews entrepreneur and investor Elad Gil about key lessons from his High Growth Handbook. Gil shares insights on scaling executive leadership, navigating shifting venture capital dynamics, evaluating preemptive funding, and weighing M&A against public market IPOs.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Harry holds 25.8% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Harry as informed peer 2.9 Guest teaching 3.7 Guest disagreement 0.8 Harry pushing back 0.6
speaking balance: gold is Harry, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 28:28 Rejecting the Amazon business model bias
Elad directly challenges the dominant Silicon Valley mindset, arguing that founders mistakenly treat Amazon's low-margin retail model as a universal blueprint when high prices and high margins are far more successful.
Hardest push from Harry ▶ 9:21 Pushing back on forward-hiring timelineHarry resists Elad's suggestion to hire 6-12 months ahead by raising real-world founder runway constraints and asking how startups can afford that luxury.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 17:30 Re-framing startups as distribution enginesElad educates the host on how successful tech companies falter by viewing themselves strictly as product organizations rather than leveraging their distribution as defensive and offensive moats.
Harry holds his own ▶ 10:19 Citing Jason Lemkin's executive hiring dilemmaHarry demonstrates deep industry domain knowledge by bringing up Jason Lemkin's specific analysis regarding early generalists versus semi-burnt-out corporate executives.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Harry as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Harry pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Welcome and Background of Elad Gil | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Harry introduces Elad with high praise and asks a standard opening question about defining the CEO role. Elad systematically breaks down early-stage versus scaling CEO responsibilities into five clear pillars. | |
| Hiring Top Executive Talent | 2 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Harry asks how top CEOs hire elite executives. Elad provides a structured framework on hiring for the next 12-18 months and conducting expert tours before drafting role requirements. | |
| Balancing Growth Speed, Hiring Ahead, and Cultural Integrity | 5 | 5 | 2 | 4 | Harry challenges the conventional wisdom of hiring six months ahead by citing founder runway constraints and quotes Jason Lemkin's thesis on executive hiring trade-offs. Elad reframes Lemkin's argument by distinguishing pre-product market fit from post-product market fit companies. | |
| Executive Role Allocation and Organizational Structure | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Harry asks about executive role allocation and warning signs of unscaling talent. Elad explains organizational trade-offs around tie-breaking authority and illustrates warning signs like micromanagement and poor recruiting capability. | |
| Common Mistakes CEOs Make During High-Growth Periods | 2 | 4 | 1 | 0 | Harry asks where CEOs make critical mistakes during rapid expansion. Elad outlines missteps in internal communication, failing to replace merely good talent, and overlooking company distribution power. | |
| The Drivers and Dynamics Behind Preemptive Venture Rounds | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Harry prompts a discussion on the surge of preemptive venture rounds. Elad outlines four structural drivers including ballooning fund sizes, scarcity of quality deals, and proven multi-stage double-down strategies. | |
| Founder Considerations When Offered Preemptive Capital | 3 | 4 | 1 | 0 | Harry asks how to evaluate preemptive capital as an investor and advisor. Elad details the trade-offs for founders, warning that preemptive rounds lock entrepreneurs into longer trajectories and concentrate governance power. | |
| The Impact of Mega Funds and Multi-Stage Investors on VC | 3 | 3 | 1 | 0 | Harry brings up mega funds like SoftBank and multi-stage firms entering seed rounds. Elad notes SoftBank's asymmetric market impact and predicts VCs will develop sharper elbows to protect ownership. | |
| Pricing Strategy, Market Share, and Cash as a Defensible Moat | 3 | 5 | 3 | 1 | Harry asks about pricing versus market share and whether cash serves as a moat. Elad rejects the Valley's obsession with Amazon's low-margin approach and argues higher prices combined with capital leverage create superior moats. | |
| M&A Trends, Valuation Disconnects, and Founder Considerations | 2 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Harry asks about the decline in tech M&A activity. Elad explains how mid-tier tech companies lack professional corp dev teams while inflated private valuations create acquisition price disconnects. | |
| Post-Acquisition Founder Retention and Autonomy | 5 | 4 | 2 | 2 | Harry references Hunter Walk's tweet on Instagram's leadership and cites Keith Raboy regarding IPO aversion. Elad dispels public market myths, explaining why public companies remain tech's most innovative entities. | |
| Quickfire Round with Elad Gil | 3 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Harry conducts a rapid quickfire round. He shares a personal anecdote about creating a working-with-me guide for his co-founder after Elad highlights Claire Hughes Johnson's approach. |
Statements from this episode (38)
Elad Gil's High Growth Handbook Outselling Zero to One in Pre-Orders
“Not only is this the first book that I've read voraciously from cover to cover in a long, long time, but it's now outselling Zero to One and Lean Startup as pre-order.”
Elad Gil: Early-Stage Startups Only Need to Solve Three Core Priorities
“There's only three things you need to do at an early company. Number one is find product market fit. Number two is don't run out of money, which is another way of saying find product market fit. And number three is don't fight and implode as a founding team.”
Elad Gil: Scaling CEO Responsibilities Consolidate Into Five Core Areas
“The role of the CEO kind of adapts to that complexity and really shifts, and really it consolidates down to four or five different areas. The first is hiring executives and talent. The second is really resource allocation, so determining where capital should g…”
Elad Gil: Hire Executives Tailored for Next 12 to 18 Months
“A key point, I think Ben Horowitz makes this in his book is, and I think it's a general truism is to really focus on hiring people who will be great for the next 12 to 18 months. Hiring somebody who's ran a multi-thousand person team, if you're only a 50 perso…”
Elad Gil: Interview Domain Experts Before Hiring Unfamiliar Executive Roles
“One of the best tactics is to really go almost on a tour of the experts in a specific functional area. So for example, if you've never hired a general counsel, or if you've never hired a CFO, really what you want to do is figure out what is great in that role.…”
Elad Gil: Fast-Scaling Startups Must Sometimes Slow Growth to Protect Culture
“And so you sometimes actually have to slow down growth rather than accelerate it, not because of capital constraints. Usually you have the money to do it if things are really working well. But more because you're just going to kind of blow up the way that the …”
Gil: Pre-PMF startups should hire generalists over functional specialists
“The type of team that you want very early on is the team that can be geared towards finding product market fit, which generally means either generalists or Are people who know the industry well enough, but who can do other functions or roles?”
Elad Gil: Hire Hungry Senior Directors Instead of Established Enterprise SVPs
“Instead of hiring the SVP of engineering from an organization, you hire their Key senior director or their key VP who is really excited to take on an entire functional org.”
Elad Gil: Structure reporting lines around decision-making tie-breakers
“The second thing that you want to think about from an org structure perspective is tie-breaking. Where do you want the decisions to be made? So for example, if you want decisions between product and engineering to be made by you, then both functions should rep…”
Gil: An Executive's Inability to Recruit Signals Lack of Competence
“So exceptional people want to work for people that they feel like they can learn from. And if that individual just can't attract great talent, that means that people of that function just don't view them as very competent.”
Gil: Executives Not Planning Six Months Ahead Aren't Ready for Role
“If basically they seem behind the ball versus six months ahead in terms of planning and thinking forward and what should be done next, then that's usually a sign that they just aren't really ready for that role.”
Elad Gil: Startups with product-market fit are anti-fragile
“And in general, startups with product market fit tend to have enormous momentum and actually be anti-fragile.”
Elad Gil: Recent tech startups fail to leverage distribution moats
“And so I think the most recent wave of companies tend to be much less aggressive about reimagining themselves as a distribution centric company and not just a product centric company.”
Elad Gil: Average Startup Quality Has Fallen as Seed Volume Quadrupled
“The average company has gotten worse rather than better, and the number of companies has gone up dramatically. I think there's now a few thousand venture-backed companies a year, or seed companies, I should say, a year, when a few years ago was maybe a quarter…”
Gil: Preemptive VC rounds favor large funds over individual investors
“Preemptive rounds are best suited for venture capitalists who have large funds, because I think it's much harder as an individual to manage capital relative to guessing whether something will work or not.”
Elad Gil: Most Investors Making Preemptive VC Bets Will Make Costly Mistakes
“I do think a lot of people will be making mistakes on the preemptive side, though, because they're basically investing ahead of time with little data evaluations that aren't merited by the data, and so you either have to be extremely good or extremely lucky, a…”
Gil: Preemptive VC Capital Locks Founders In and Destroys Early Exit Options
“And so I think the downside of preemptive rounds and extra capital is it also locks in the entrepreneur to a longer story, and it removes the option value of actually exiting at a valuation where lots of people would have bought them.”
Gil: Multiple Preemptive Rounds Give Single Investors Too Much Board Control
“The second point is if somebody preempts multiple rounds for you end up with perhaps too much concentration in the hands of a single investor where they can really end up controlling the board.”
Gil: Half of Unicorns Are Dramatically Overvalued
“Half of the unicorns are probably dramatically overvalued, and if they were public companies, their valuations would get chopped down pretty dramatically relative to where they are today.”
Gil: Extended Privatization Traps Capital and Talent in Undeserving Startups
“It's actually been positive for them to be private for longer, but it may be bad for the ecosystem overall because it's tying up a lot of capital and talent into pockets that may not deserve that capital and talent as much.”
Gil: Angel Investors Are Quitting Due to Lack of Exit Liquidity
“I know a few angels have dropped out entirely because they just ran out of money to keep investing, and ultimately it removes the ability to really measure what's working.”
Elad Gil: SoftBank Has Had the Greatest Impact of All VC Mega Funds
“I think that the sort of mega fund that's mattered the most in terms of impact is probably SoftBank, Simply because at a hundred billion dollars, SoftBank is the equivalent of a hundred general catalysts or 12 Sequoia funds. So just the sheer scale of capital …”
Elad Gil: Mega funds will drive preemptive rounds and VC defensiveness
“I do think these billion dollar funds will effectively lead to an ongoing trend of preemption. And it also means that certain VCs will double down much more aggressively on companies that are working and potentially shut out others from participating in their …”
Elad Gil: I Took Lower Valuations at Both Startups for Better Investors
“Or anything else, you know, for my own companies, as I've run them, I've started two companies. And in both cases, there have been rounds where I've taken lower valuations to get a better investor on board or somebody that I thought would be more helpful. So I…”
Elad Gil: Avoid Taking Seed Checks From Growth Funds to Preserve Capacity
“The other thing I would keep in mind is that people who tend to invest late may be good sources of capital later. And if they own a lot of the company early, they're just not going to participate later. So there may be some funds that you want to sort of keep …”
Elad Gil: Amazon's Low-Margin Playbook Fails for Most Tech Companies
“I think that in Silicon Valley, too many people are stuck on Amazon as the primary model for what will succeed as a company, and Amazon is actually the exception versus the rule. In other words, Amazon is a company that went for very high market share with ver…”
Elad Gil: Capital acts as a moat when paired with high customer LTV
“Despite large amounts of capital in the system, there does become a point where It becomes reasonably uneconomical for other people to compete from a capital perspective. I don't think that there's ever been a business where the sole defensible point is capita…”
Elad Gil: Google Spent Hundreds of Millions Buying Firefox Homepage and Toolbars
“Google was spending hundreds of millions of dollars on To acquire customers via things like toolbar distribution. They bought the homepage of Firefox for many years. They basically did whatever they could to push distribution as hard as possible.”
Elad Gil: Facebook Bought Ads Targeted at Specific Individuals' Names in Europe
“Facebook ultimately ended up doing the same thing where they were literally buying ads in Europe against individuals' names so that they could convert those people onto Facebook as a platform.”
Gil: Multi-billion-dollar startups should aggressively pursue M&A for talent and product
“Any company that has a market cap of a few billion or more, in my opinion, if they're new, should actually be buying up other companies pretty rapidly, and I think in some cases, those teams just haven't hired a corp dev person, or they haven't professionalize…”
Gil: Founders underestimate the upside of selling early to breakout acquirers
“On the financial side, I actually think people tend to undercount the value of exiting early to a breakout company, because if a company is truly breaking out and it still has a five or 10 or 20 X on top of it, then that magnifies the impact of the acquisition…”
Elad Gil: Twitter's Valuation Grew Over 10x Following Its Acquisition of MixerLabs
“When I sold my last startup, or my second to last startup to Twitter, we sold in part because we were really excited about Twitter, and we thought we could have a lot of impact there, and I thought my team would be really happy there. But we also sold in part …”
Gil: Android had 11 to 12 employees when acquired by Google
“Andy Rubin was acquired when Android was, I think, about 11, 12 people, and then obviously that led to this amazing handset OS and sort of platform for the world.”
Gil: Google gave Android independent hiring autonomy post-acquisition
“Android actually had its own hiring practices, which at the time was Anthema at Google, and it was set up so that they could really run their team very independently, hire independently, make decisions independently, and that was a very explicit choice so that…”
Gil: Google, Apple, and Amazon prove public companies stay innovative
“The most innovative companies in technology are actually the big public ones, right? I would argue that Google and Apple and, you know, Amazon are the most innovative companies in the world, and they do that as public companies.”
Elad Gil: Tech Companies Close More Candidates at Lower Compensation Post-IPO
“So a friend of mine runs a technology recruiting firm, and he has data that shows that when a company goes public, they actually close more candidates at lower price than right before they went public.”
Gil: Every manager should write a one-page guide on how to work with them
“And I think that every executive or potentially every manager Should basically write up the one page description of how to engage them, how to work with them. What are the things that work well or don't work with well with them?”
Gil: Career success relies on identifying and maximizing time with a core network
“I think when all is said and done, the key thing to navigating a career is to figure out who's the network or group of people that you kind of want to work with repeatedly, and how do you increase the amount of time spent with those individuals”