Jun 6, 2022 · 1h 3m · news
Tony Fadell: Product Marketing Lessons I Learned from Steve Jobs | 20VC #884 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of 20VC, tech pioneer Tony Fadell shares masterclasses on product design, the necessity of constraints, and the art of product marketing, providing frameworks for balancing data with emotional consumer needs.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Harry holds 13.5% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Harry as informed peer 2.4 Guest teaching 3.7 Guest disagreement 2.1 Harry pushing back 2.0
speaking balance: gold is Harry, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 47:43 Emphatic rejection of competitor-driven strategy
When Harry asks if competition should drive product strategy, Tony forcefully interrupts with 'No, no, no. Absolutely not. Never,' dismissing the concept of chasing competitors.
Hardest push from Harry ▶ 7:51 Harry challenges Tony's data framingHarry directly interrupts Tony to push back on his story about the Philips color screen, arguing that customer discovery insights represent a different type of data Tony failed to leverage.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 8:09 Tony explains why focus groups fail at retailTony educates Harry on the difference between what customers say during discovery interviews and how they actually buy emotionally when comparing products side-by-side on store shelves.
Harry holds his own ▶ 7:51 Harry distinguishes BOM costs from customer researchHarry demonstrates his venture acumen by pushing back on Tony's definition of data, distinguishing financial unit economics from customer discovery data.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Harry as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Harry pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Data vs. Opinion in Product Design | 2 | 5 | 3 | 2 | Harry asks if product design intuition replaces data as leaders become more experienced. Tony directly refutes the premise, arguing that relying solely on opinion is hubris and leads to product failure. | |
| The Phillips Color Screen Failure and Customer Insights | 4 | 4 | 3 | 6 | Harry explicitly interrupts Tony to challenge his framing of data, distinguishing BOM/unit costs from customer discovery research. Tony counters by explaining why traditional customer research fails to capture emotional impulse purchases at retail. | |
| The Nest Screwdriver & Brand Economics | 2 | 4 | 2 | 2 | Tony details why Nest included a custom screwdriver in every box despite internal pushback regarding margins. Harry inquires about balancing brand experience against unit economics. | |
| The "First Mile" Customer Experience and Defaults | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | Harry cites Scott Belsky and Dave Morin regarding the 'first mile' experience and default settings. Tony agrees, criticizing product teams that cater to technical reviewers over average consumers. | |
| How to Conduct Great Product Reviews | 2 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Tony breaks down how he runs internal product design reviews and how to maintain perspective as a beginner. Harry asks how leaders extrapolate themselves out of granular design details. | |
| The Art of Product Marketing and the Mock Press Release | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | Tony playfully turns the interview around by grilling Harry on the definition of product marketing, to which Harry jokes back. Tony then shares Steve Jobs' philosophy that great marketing is simply truth-telling. | |
| Hiring Product Marketers & the iPod's Windows Transition | 2 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Harry asks how to interview product marketers and what to do when product marketing fails. Tony illustrates using the initial failure of the iPod, which only succeeded commercially once Steve Jobs agreed to make it Windows-compatible. | |
| Analyzing Product Flops and the Importance of Constraints | 3 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Tony reflects on product flops like the iPod Hi-Fi and Apple Watch Gold edition, pointing out that unchecked budgets lead to over-engineering. Harry asks how leaders enforce discipline on well-capitalized teams. | |
| Managing Team Morale, Competition, and Conducting Postmortems | 2 | 4 | 4 | 2 | Harry asks if competition should drive product strategy, prompting an emphatic rejection from Tony. Tony argues that chasing competitors results in inferior 'me-too' products. | |
| Risk Mitigation and Sticking to the Core Product Press Release | 2 | 3 | 2 | 1 | During quickfire questions, Tony cautions founders against trying to remain the product manager as their startup scales. He stresses that CEOs must delegate execution to specialized product marketers. | |
| Why Tony Fadell Wrote his Book 'Build' | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Tony shares why he wrote 'Build', reflecting on the mentors who helped him in Silicon Valley and his desire to pass along those lessons to climate tech founders. |
Statements from this episode (17)
Fadell: General Magic Built the iPhone 15 Years Too Early
“Followed my heroes out to Silicon Valley at a company called General Magic, who was the Mac team creating the iPhone just 15 years before the iPhone came out. We were doing it too early.”
Fadell: Paying customers provide far better product feedback than free users
“I think as you go through successive versions, you get better and better data from people who are actually paying for whatever it is you're doing. You know, you're getting revenue in some form. So those people have real opinions because they're using it and th…”
Fadell: Stated customer feedback often contradicts actual retail purchasing behavior
“So you can't always just trust what the customer says because What happens is our framing of it, you know, when we're asking them, we're asking the questions come with all the other, oh, well, if you bought it would be like this, and this, and then here's the …”
Fadell: Nest included a custom screwdriver with its first thermostat
“When we shipped our first thermostat, we shipped the very first thermostat, we included a very expensive tool inside the package. And it was a screwdriver with changeable bits so that when you got it right out of the, you know, of the box, you could start moun…”
Fadell: Plant-based materials will be cheaper than petroleum at scale
“Typically, yeah, it might be more expensive today for that material, but as soon as that volume hits, And we get, it takes off. Actually, it's going to be cheaper than the petroleum based product because it's built with plants and it's easier to make the plant…”
Fadell: Products must have a single primary path to be structured correctly
“There's always got to be a one priority path. If not, you probably not structured your product right.”
Fadell: New product projects should begin with a mock press release
“So you have to start when you start a new project. Is you have to start early days in, and what I always say is build the mock press release. What is that page, page and a half press release that you're going to, you know, send out six months, nine months, a y…”
Fadell: Steve Jobs taught that the best marketing is truth-telling
“Steve said the best marketing, Steve Jobs, the best marketing is just truth telling. As long as the product meets the expectations you set for it, the best marketing is just telling the truth.”
Fadell: iPod wasn't a successful business until its third generation
“The iPod Was a critical success, but it didn't really turn into a successful business till the third generation. And the reason being was it didn't work with Windows based PCs. It only worked with Macs, which were a fraction of the market, less than a percent,…”
Fadell: iPod's original strategy was driving Mac sales, which failed
“We're going to sell the iPod. It's going to be so awesome that people will buy Macs so they could use their iPod. We're going to sell more Macs because they're going to need to buy one to use an iPod that they're going to have to have. Well, guess what? The fi…”
Fadell: General Magic sold only thousands of units despite $500M+ investment
“General Magic was a huge one. It maybe sold a few thousand units, you know, after a five hundred million dollars or more investment in the nineties.”
Fadell: Apple scrapped two and a half iPhone versions before shipping
“That was what we did on the iPhone. We had two and a half versions really of the iPhone before it shipped, because we kept revving it, getting to a certain point, throwing it away, trying again, getting a certain point, throwing it away because we make constra…”
Fadell: Excess capital prevents teams from imposing critical product constraints
“I don't like any team swimming in money. I saw that too many times at other companies I've worked with or for. And it does not set up for good constraints to make sure you're making great decisions because the market moves on.”
Fadell: Founders scaling past 20 people must hire dedicated product managers
“When you start growing past your, you know, 20 people, There is so much work to do product management, right? You need a person who's at least one person who's the voice of customer watching over all of this because as a founder, CEO, leader, you have so many …”
Fadell: Product marketing should be an independent team separate from engineering and PR
“Hire and build the right team around product marketing and make sure it's a separate team. It's not marketing. It's not communications. It's not engineering. It's not project management. It's something else.”
Stebbings passed on investing in Nothing's first funding round
“I'm fucking pissed I didn't do that first round when Buckley brought it to me. I was like, hardware company? Fuck off.”
Fadell matches book proceeds 5x to fund climate startups
“All proceeds, all net proceeds that are coming to me or what have you are going to a fund called the build climate fund. I'm going to match all of those proceeds five X, and we're only going to be investing in climate crisis companies, startups doing real stuf…”
Shorts cut from this episode
▶ Should competition drive product strategy · 20VC with Harry (@47:45)
▶ Steve Jobs' advice on Marketing · 20VC with Harry Stebbings (@28:46)
▶ POP QUIZ: What is Product Marketing? · 20VC with Harry Stebb (@29:26)
▶ Product advice from the creator of the iPhone · 20VC with Ha (@47:45)
▶ Macs then vs. Macs now | iPhone Creator Tony Fadell · 20VC w (@37:51)
▶ The first thing every Product Marketer should do · 20VC with (@25:28)
▶ Good Product Marketing is Arrogant · 20VC with Harry Stebbin (@26:35)