Jun 28, 2023 · 1h 4m · news
Jennifer Hyman: Rent The Runway's Journey to $1.7B IPO; Lessons from Beyoncé & Estée Lauder | E1031 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of 20VC, Rent the Runway co-founder and CEO Jennifer Hyman joins host Harry Stebbings to discuss the evolution of her clothing subscription business, her unconventional hiring philosophies, the transition from private fundraising to public market discipline, and the strategic integration of technology in modern retail.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Harry holds 14.2% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Harry as informed peer 4.6 Guest teaching 6.4 Guest disagreement 2.8 Harry pushing back 3.9
speaking balance: gold is Harry, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 45:41 Jennifer counters host's defense of paid ads
Jennifer forcefully rejects Harry's pushback on performance marketing, arguing that spending 90% of marketing budgets on bottom-of-funnel direct response ads was a systemic misallocation across venture-backed startups.
Hardest push from Harry ▶ 45:04 Harry directly disagrees on paid acquisitionHarry explicitly refuses Jennifer's framing that paid marketing ruined a generation of startups, stating 'I have to say, I disagree' and defending paid ads as a legitimate customer discovery channel.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 9:33 Jennifer reframes manager late-night expectationsWhen Harry complains about staff logging off at 6 PM while he works late, Jennifer corrects his management style by demonstrating that expecting 11 PM replies causes burnout and damages long-term employee retention.
Harry holds his own ▶ 29:56 Harry challenges guest on rising AI talent costsHarry demonstrates strong unit-economic insight by immediately probing whether Jennifer's AI pivot will inflate SG&A expenses through expensive machine learning engineering hires.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Harry as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Harry pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Early Skepticism and the Reality of Fast Fashion | 2 | 6 | 2 | 2 | Harry asks standard foundational questions about early skepticism. Jennifer reframes the concept of fast fashion, educating the host that buying cheap clothes to wear once or twice is structurally identical to clothing rental. | |
| Leading with a Missionary Mentality Through Crisis | 4 | 7 | 4 | 4 | Harry challenges Jennifer by sharing his experience that 99% of employees do not possess an owner mindset. Jennifer directly rejects his premise ('I feel the opposite of you') and schools him on how to interview for resilience and life history rather than corporate resume metrics. | |
| The Importance of a Fulfilling Personal Life | 3 | 7 | 4 | 4 | Harry complains about employees logging off at 6 PM while he sends messages late into the night. Jennifer pushes back firmly, explaining that expecting late-night responses leads to burnout and that employees perform best when they have rich, full personal lives. | |
| Managing Hiring Mistakes and Trusting Your Gut | 5 | 6 | 3 | 3 | Harry asks if Jennifer agrees with the 'hire fast, fire fast' adage and brings up Doug Leone's interviewing trick about asking candidates about their siblings. Jennifer rejects the 'hire fast' rule, advocating for 'hire slow, fire fast' based on gut feeling. | |
| Running a Private Startup with Public Discipline | 6 | 7 | 2 | 5 | Harry presses Jennifer on whether high logistics expenses were necessary for scale and whether reverse-logistics depress long-term margin profiles. Jennifer details the financial contrast between private startup self-perception and public company peer P&L benchmarking. | |
| Addressing Public Market Skepticism with Artificial Intelligence | 6 | 6 | 2 | 5 | Harry asks sharp public market questions regarding what Wall Street misunderstands and whether quarterly reporting conflicts with long-term tech investments in AI. Jennifer addresses market skepticism by outlining gross margin expansion and AI benefits for physical logistics. | |
| Decoupling Tech Infrastructure from Circular Fashion Identity | 6 | 7 | 4 | 6 | Harry challenges Jennifer on whether building AI capability adds an expensive headcount burden to SG&A and questions whether Rent the Runway is a tech or fashion company. Jennifer corrects him, noting off-the-shelf AI tooling reduces expense, and firmly identifies the business as a fashion company. | |
| The Strategic Failures of Early Growth Hacking | 7 | 7 | 5 | 7 | Harry explicitly pushes back against Jennifer's claim that paid performance marketing ruined startups, defending performance ads as vital discovery tools. Jennifer counters forcefully, explaining how an inverted marketing funnel focused on bottom-of-funnel acquisition destroyed startup economics. | |
| Stewardship and Strength Based Leadership on Corporate Boards | 4 | 6 | 1 | 2 | Harry asks about board governance dynamics and differences between leading vs serving on a board. Jennifer explains the distinction between strategic stewardship and operational execution, sharing lessons on strength-based leadership learned from Estee Lauder leadership. | |
| Quick Fire Questions on Beyonce and the Future | 3 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Harry guides a rapid-fire sequence covering Beyoncé, work-life balance, and business momentum. Jennifer shares a personal story of connecting with Beyoncé through her former manager and reflects on missed commercial opportunities. |
Statements from this episode (31)
Hyman: Forward momentum is the single most important factor in business
“The most important thing about building a business is forward momentum.”
Hyman: Rent the Runway was sparked by sister's single-use dress debt
“Aha moment was my sister going into credit card debt after buying a expensive dress that she knew she was only going to wear once.”
Hyman: Leaders must build teams of missionaries, not mercenaries, to survive crises
“Even 10 or 12 years into a business, whatever it was at that time, you still have to lead a team of missionaries and not mercenaries.”
Stebbings: None of my employees feel or act like owners
“I wish everyone felt like an owner of my businesses, but the truth is, Jen, none of them do. None of them. Only I act like an owner, and that may be unhealthy in many respects, but like, how do you hire this ownership mentality?”
Hyman: Over 99% of Rent the Runway employees act like missionaries
“I think that the team here is, you know, 99 plus percent missionary, and that's actually been the greatest privilege of my experience leading Rent the Runway, that over the past 14 years I've worked with people that really consider themselves to be founders of…”
Hyman: Interviewers overindex on career history instead of personal resilience
“I think that people, when they interview, are focused way too much on someone's career experiences. You may have shown resilience in a career experience, but more often at the point when, you know, I'm interviewing someone, the resilience that has shown up in …”
Hyman: Employees cannot give 110% without personal life happiness
“Unless people are happy in their lives, they're never gonna be happy at work, and they're never gonna be able to give a 110%.”
Hyman: Demanding 24/7 work causes burnout and turnover within two years
“I think that people who put in twenty-four-seven just related to their job are just gonna burn out, and you might have them with intensity for a year or two, but then they're gonna be gone”
Hyman: Managers must address hiring mismatches within 2-3 months, not years
“Being open about that earlier on in someone's tenure at the company is so much easier than waiting for, you know, 12 to 24 months in when they're already kind of set into the vibe and the culture of the company. So just like those early conversations when you …”
Hyman: Rent the Runway inventory costs are 30% versus 50-55% for competitors
“The cost of our inventory is about 30% of our revenue. And in most apparel businesses, apparel, the inventory cost is 50 to 55% of revenue.”
Hyman: Rent the Runway expanded gross margin from 30% to 44% year-over-year
“Q four of you know, 21, our gross margins were around 30%. Q four of 22, our gross margins were 44%.”
Hyman: Viewing private startups as special snowflakes hides bad financial metrics
“Don't Talk to yourself as a private company as if everything you do is different. The harm in doing that is then you can make an excuse for all of your metrics.”
Hyman: Rent the Runway will reach profitability exceeding industry peer margins
“So there's no reason why you shouldn't believe that Rent the Runway will be profitable, and in fact, should be more profitable than those companies, because we already have a 15 to 20 point gross margin advantage.”
Hyman: Over 50% of future closets will not consist of permanently owned items
“I believe that 50% plus of the closet in the future doesn't have to be filled with items that we own forever.”
Hyman: AI will be the biggest business operational shift since the iPhone
“There are gonna be companies that are AI beneficiaries, and then there are gonna be companies and full industries that are just decimated by AI. I am of the mindset that AI is going to be the biggest change to how we operate businesses, you know, since, since …”
Hyman: Tech roles make up majority of Rent the Runway workforce
“The majority of my employees are tech. They're engineers, they're data scientists, they're product, they're UX, and that's always been the case at Rent the Runway”
Hyman: Average Rent the Runway subscriber spends $2,000 yearly
“My average subscriber spends about 2000 dollars with me per year.”
Hyman: 98% of Rent the Runway users rent brands they never owned
“98% of my customers say That they're renting brands on Rent the Runway that they have never owned before.”
Hyman: Trying on clothing increases purchase intent by 70%
“When women put on the clothes, they have a 70% higher likelihood to want to purchase the clothes.”
Hyman: Rent the Runway retains 100% of designer brand partners
“Yeah, so we have a hundred percent retention of all the brands who have ever worked with us.”
Hyman: Fast fashion commands over 80% of $3T global market
“Over 80% of what's purchased in this nearly three trillion dollar global market is fast fashion now.”
Hyman: Great brands scale through organic virality, not paid ads
“The best brands on earth are brands that grow virally and organically. And the way that you do that is you invest in either delivering a much better customer experience, or you invest in building a brand that is so emotionally resonant with the consumer that t…”
Hyman: Over 90% of Airbnb's traffic is organic
“Airbnb has said, let's forget everything about paid marketing. Let's take all of our dollars and invest it into the brand, into PR, into product innovation that's actually going to breed loyalty, and I think now, like, over 90% of Airbnb's traffic is organic.”
Hyman: Rent the Runway acquires over 80% of customers organically
“Over 80% of our traffic and over, sorry, over 80% of our customers have always come to us organically.”
Hyman: Rent the Runway fulfillment costs are 30% of revenue
“Our fulfillment expense, which has two-way shipping, which has restoration of garments, which has cleaning, which has repair, still is only 30% of revenue, which leads us to that 44% gross margin.”
Hyman: Average American buys 70 clothing items annually
“The average American buys 70 new articles of apparel per year.”
Hyman: Rent the Runway turns fashion into a replenishment model like grocery
“Rent the Runway has taken the business and turned fashion into a replenishment business, similar to grocery.”
Hyman: Board members should challenge executives with questions, not dictate strategy
“A board member's job is not to come up with the strategy of the company. A board member's job is to ask the right questions that might, you know, engage the CEO and the executive team in, you know, slightly different conversations.”
Hyman: Effective leaders ignore employee weaknesses and focus entirely on accelerating strengths
“So Fabrizio is a huge proponent that you should spend almost no time thinking about someone's weaknesses and how to improve them. And you should identify What are the things that make someone great? What are their superpowers? And how do you accelerate those s…”
Hyman: Rent the Runway went from losing all revenue to IPO in 18 months
“All of our revenue kind of go away and then it all come back. You know, us going from losing all of our revenue essentially overnight to IPO-ing the business 18 months later with our full team and, you know, all of our alumni kind of standing by and being part…”