Fournier: GraphQL rarely works well in practice outside of Facebook
Camille Fournier · The things engineers are desperate for PMs to understand | Camille Fournier (“The Manager’s Path”) · Sep 15, 2024 · at 29:32
Engineering leader Camille Fournier critiques GraphQL's premise of decoupling frontend and backend engineering collaboration.
0:00 / 0:17exact quote · 17.9s
▶ Watch the full episode on YouTube → 720p mp4 · rendered on demand · StarZero watermark
“The impression that I have from sort of listening to people talk about it is that GraphQL is kind of trying to promise front end engineers that they don't really have to like collaborate with back end engineers and they can just sort of build whatever and it'll all be fine. And it just doesn't ever seem to work out that well for anybody who actually does it in practice.”
quote is from the automated transcript, cleaned for reading: filler sounds and stutters are removed, nothing is rephrased. names can be misheard (the analysis reads context, assessments check outside sources). how →
More from Camille Fournier
Fournier: Product managers are far easier to manage than engineers
“PMs are way easier to manage. PMs are awesome to manage. PMs want to, like, they're just so helpful. They're, like, want to do things. They're good communicators. I love managing PMs. I have to say, I just, like, my experience, engineers are such a pain. They …”
Fournier: Ground-up software rewrites rarely succeed
“Trying to say, we're going to just go away, we're going to rewrite, we're going to build something brand new, and it's going to solve all our problems, it just very rarely works.”
Fournier: Big-company frameworks often fail when adopted outside their original context
“Some of the most time-wasting frameworks have also just come out of big companies, right? Where the context of the big company that may have made that framework super useful within that context doesn't translate to startup or small company or even big company …”
Fournier: Companies must allocate dedicated product managers to internal platform teams
“I actually think product, you need to have a product mindset. And frankly, you need to have product managers to build good platforms, internal platforms. A lot of companies just don't do this. They don't believe that they should waste headcount on product mana…”
Fournier: Excluding engineers from product ideation triggers massive over-engineering
“What I see happen in those cases is that I see engineers start to over-engineer things because engineers Are like, well, I need to take control of something, right? Like I want to have some creative outlet. So I'm going to use my engineering skills in my creat…”
Fournier: Many engineers underestimate what the product manager job actually requires
“Like I just, my experience is there are plenty of engineers who actually think they can be product managers and they don't really understand all of the elements of the product job. That they would need to be successful.”