why aren't all 2,194 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 7 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Adaptive AI systems will eliminate the need for major software re-platforms
“So using AI to continuously modernize, you can think of systems of the future that are self-tuning and adaptive. We no longer have to catch the latest trend or optimization By doing major re-platforms.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Human software engineers will write very little code in 20 years
“If I had a bet, since you gave me the 20 year out, I would say yes. I think very little code, if any, will be written by engineers.”
Insight
Zima: Rigorous feature prioritization frameworks are a waste of time
“I just, I really think it's hard to come up with a great, like scoring framework for how to pick out the next 10 features, because I found that every single time that we tried to apply some sort of rigorous, like scoring framework to difficulty and reach and Y…”
Disclosure
Zima: Looker deprioritized app crashes for two years to build features
“Whereas like I had to go to the support team over and over again for probably a period of two years and say the app crashing is not a priority right now because I want to do more feature work and we can suffer through this and I know it's bad, but I don't thin…”
Opinion
Zima: Looker Failed to Adapt to Modern Data Ecosystem Shifts
“Looker was not able to adapt to the changes that its sort of founding and popularization had resulted in.”
Opinion
Salesforce wins through its massive distribution engine, not product superiority
“The thing that actually helps Salesforce win. It's not necessarily that the product is amazing. It's that they have this incredible distribution engine that is really difficult to compete against.”
Insight
Startup people problems are often just symptoms of underlying business model issues
“A good business makes a lot of this stuff a lot easier. Like, if you're making good money, if you're growing, if there's plenty of opportunity to go around, there's plenty of money to go around, salaries and bonuses and things like that, everything gets way ea…”
Insight
'Don't hire until it hurts' forces founders to learn every role firsthand
“We had this rule, don't hire till it hurts... One, it meant we did every single job. So we understood every piece of our business. So when we hired somebody in that meant we knew exactly how they were going to be effective, what was going to help them win. And…”
Opinion
Siroker: Rewind's 20-person team executes faster than Optimizely's 450-person team
“Today we have 20 people and rewind we had 450 and I feel like with 20 people we're able to do more and execute faster and be More tightly aligned than and ship than we ever did at Optimizely.”
Insight
Siroker: Ex-Apple founders often fail to ship due to unrealistic quality expectations
“I see a lot of companies today that are ex Apple people who've built amazing things and they go off and they spend years and years toiling away and never really ship anything. And, you know, I think they have this sense of like, it needs to be As good as the l…”
Prediction Open · timeframe Sep 2028
Siroker: Thousands of multi-billion-dollar vertical LLM application companies will emerge
“There's whole categories of companies that are going to be cat, you know, Category defining independent successful big public multi-billion dollar companies that are just applications of large language models in a specific domain for a specific user with a gre…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Siroker predicts 50% of work will be fundamentally changed within 10 years
“I think a lot of jobs will be gone in 10 years, but they'll likely be replaced with new ones.
I think that's probably an obvious
Conclusion.
I think on the order of probably 50% of work will go away.
It would be fundamentally changed.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Siroker: AGI will eventually perform half the work of human engineering teams
“Eventually, you know, I don't think it will necessarily replace engineers, but it'll certainly augment them. You'll have plenty of, you know, half the work that an engineering team does will be done by AGI, and half will be done by humans, and the human stuff …”
Disclosure
Siroker: Rewind published its unredacted investor pitch deck and video on Twitter
“That's why I announced and shared our investor deck unredacted. I didn't hide any numbers. You know, you can find it on Twitter, you know, seven minute pitch you know, millions of people have seen it.”
Insight
Defining correctness in AI outputs is becoming increasingly subjective
“As we, I think, trend towards artificial general intelligence, the definition of correct or the definition of whether something is, you know, valid or not, It's becoming increasingly subjective”
Insight
Elliott-McCrea: Slow engineering execution always stems from leadership's lack of clarity
“When I'm going and having these conversations with leaders, and this is, I think the standard conversation most people have is it starts with leadership. If we're moving too slow, it always does. We've always believed that we've been more clear. We've created …”
Insight
Elliott-McCrea: Dropbox's runaway early success created a flawed product development mindset
“Dropbox hit a home run basically out of the gate. And there was kind of an expectation that that's how you built products. And like people came from different places and very different experiences, but pretty deep in the culture was this idea that you build it…”
Insight
Elliott-McCrea: Google hires often struggle elsewhere because its internal systems don't replicate
“I think the canonical example of this is Google, by the way. I mean, I think that
Sort of in industry. Now we've kind of learned you hire people out of Google and they show up and they don't know how to operate because they've been such a determined high funct…”
Opinion
Berson: Modeling startup cultures after Google caused net damage to the ecosystem
“I'd also argue that a lot of people trying to model their orgs and culture after Google has probably created
More damage to our ecosystem than sort of positive outcomes.”
Insight
Elliott-McCrea: Leaders should not automatically bring former colleagues into new organizations
“One of the things that people ask me is you look like you've worked with a bunch of great people. Like, do you just like bring them with you to every organization? And the answer is, of course not. Like every organization is different and partially I need the …”
Insight
Elliott-McCrea: Shielding engineering teams from company chaos causes them to misalign
“Actually, one of the early stereotypes about engineering managers in our industry is as the shit umbrella, you know, just gonna keep people from being distracted by all the crazy. And what that is, is those teams end up just drifting off. You know, you talk ab…”
Insight
Kracov: Redefining existing categories gains traction faster than creating new ones
“It is really hard to just go out and create a brand new category and Lattice did a tiny bit later, which we get into, but we really redefine categories. And that's, I think a much easier way to get your traction in the market because we could go to companies a…”
Insight
Kracov: B2B startups skipping early marketing will stall past $10M ARR
“If you don't invest in marketing in the early days, you're going to stall out and it might not be at a million ARR. It might not be at two, but it's definitely going to happen as you get past 10 and 50 and so on and so forth.”
Insight
Founder CEOs possess unique moral authority over professional CEOs
“One of the things that's unique about founder CEOs relative to like a professional CEO is you do have this extra chip of moral authority that lets you shake things up and keep the startup feeling like a startup even when you are at scale, and one of the ways y…”
Prediction Open · timeframe Jun 2033
Seshan predicts every public company will require carbon accounting in 10 years
“In 10 years, every public company will need to do some level of carbon accounting and have a decarbonization plan to underscore that.”
Insight
Parikh: Infrastructure teams must share fate and accountability with product teams
“If our part worked, and the product piece didn't work, then, like, we still failed. So, those teams had to be fused together, and it was sort of a shared fate. I had no tolerance for this, like, hey, just because you're in infra, you don't need to care about, …”
Insight
Steep technology inflections demand IC-led cultures rather than managerial hierarchies
“If you want to be able to really, like, accelerate through one of those steep technology inflections, The people who generally know the best about the technology are actually the ICs. So you have to, like, elevate them, you have to, like, protect them, you hav…”
Insight
Hyper-scale technology companies fundamentally cannot rely on third-party infrastructure vendors
“When you take some layer of your kind of core stack, and it's like outsourced to this vendor, and vendor, you know, could be great, but when I was at these companies that were, you know, Kind of N of one in terms of what they were doing scale wise. They weren'…”
Disclosure
Parikh pushed Zuckerberg to prioritize engineering efficiency over pure product features
“You know, I remember talking to Mark and Mark was like, yeah, we can, you know, we have money, so we should just build features and we should put all the engineers working on product. And I said, cool, but I'm going to work on efficiency because I'm not going …”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Noronha: Presentations are the third most requested enterprise AI use case
“Well, everyone needs just a chat tool for sure. The engineers all need a tool like a cursor or cloud code or whatever. And it turns out the third use case that's bubbling up over and over is presentations. People are wasting all this time just like formatting …”
Disclosure
Noronha: Gamma rejected the standard vertical SaaS playbook despite investor pushback
“We bet early on and pretty consistently on building a horizontal product rather than a vertical one that was focused on a specific persona, and it was actually a source of constant tension in fundraising and a lot of our early debates because I think there's s…”
Insight
Noronha: Early LLM guardrails actively hold back modern AI models
“Now what we're finding, actually, is that all those guardrails we put in place are holding these much more intelligent AIs back. And so we're now in a mode not of even adding functionality, but trying to throw things out, loosen the requirements, and let AI do…”
Insight
Noronha: Founders must win user adoption before building moats
“This also, I think, came from perhaps trying to build for durability and moat before building for adoption. And I think you actually have to go in the opposite order. You have to first win adoption, which is a kind of a grueling fight with someone who is chang…”
Opinion
Noronha: AI is an anti-incumbent force questioning every software moat
“And AI is such a sea change that I do think it is just this anti-incumbent technology across the board. It is, I mean, this is why we have a SaaSpocalypse now, is it's kind of questioning every software company's moat.”
Insight
Noronha: Building smaller product surface areas lets AI fill white space
“Particularly in this world of rapidly advancing AI models, it's actually a really healthy instinct, because the less you build as product surface area, the more that the AI can actually fill in, in actually the white space.”
Insight
Noronha: Presentation AI is harder than spreadsheet AI due to subjective taste
“I think probably the biggest difference between the Excel workflow and the PowerPoint workflow is creativity and taste. There's less objective definition of what good looks like and there's much more room for the user and also the brand to express themselves. …”
Insight
Noronha: AI products should avoid granular UI controls that quickly become obsolete
“Err on the side of building fewer knobs and controls, because all of those become things that you need to maintain and honor over time, and they may end up becoming irrelevant as AI capabilities advance.”
Insight
Noronha: Presentation Prosumer Products Cannot Achieve Over 100% NRR
“Presentations are a naturally episodic use case, which means we can't expect on our prosumer base to have more than a hundred percent net revenue retention.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Noronha: AI Integration Unlocked Organic Virality and Free Distribution for Gamma
“The inflection point came when we truly solved virality in the product by introducing AI. And at that point, we started getting distribution for free because people would make something great. They would share it with someone else. Those people would try it ou…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gamma surpassed 100,000 daily signups in its first year without paid marketing
“And we were still doing no paid marketing at this time. So the only explanation for this was word of mouth growth, basically, you know, different kinds of word of mouth. But that 10,000 kept climbing upwards, 10,020 1030 thousand, to the point where in our fir…”
Insight
AI product craft requires rapid leaps rather than consensus and isolated tinkering
“Craft can no longer look like going into your little studio and tinkering for several weeks before coming out with something to show for it. And craft also doesn't mean that all of us can feel the same ownership of the product through consensus. We actually ha…”
What-if
Noronha: Gamma is 10x larger due to international expansion
“Going international has been huge for us. The AI app layer opportunity is so much broader than just a narrow segment of people, like, say, in the United States and the people right next to you. I think especially for a horizontal prosumer product like ours, it…”
Insight
Sager: Most toxic high performers reform when given direct, constructive feedback
“Once you say that to people, the vast majority of people I've ever worked with, Their reaction to this is, hey, Eric, thank you. I really appreciate you caring about me enough to give me that feedback. And then they do their best to course correct. And it migh…”
Insight
Sager: The idea that faster execution is always better is nonsense
“I don't think it's fair to say that, Hey, no matter what the decision is or what you're talking about in the context of the business, that faster is always better. I think that's nonsense, right? And there's plenty of examples where you don't want to do that.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Sager: Fintech competitors that sacrificed precision for speed failed completely
“I think we've had competitors that sacrificed, you know, everything at the altar of speed and it didn't work out and it didn't, and not at all.”
Disclosure
Sager: Plaid will accept account unprofitability to ensure customer success
“There's just, there's almost no amount of money, right, that I wouldn't reasonably spend to make sure that one of our customers gets to a good outcome. And even if that makes that account unprofitable, That experience will kind of resonate across the rest of t…”
Insight
Sager: The ultimate test of leadership is making yourself obsolete
“And in some ways, to me, that's like the ultimate asset test of, did you do a good job or not? And you know, my own lived experience is like, every time I've thought I've made myself useless and obsolete, like there's always been some new opportunity, right? T…”
Insight
Sager: Hiring solely for domain expertise fails as domain advantages erode in 18 months
“But I think if that's the main reason you hire someone. I think that oftentimes doesn't work out because you end up overlooking like all these other things that are far more important in terms of like what that person's ceiling is. You know, I was a consultant…”