Oct 5, 2023 · 1h 7m · in-depth
Contrarian takes on growth, hiring, and fundraising | Wade Foster (Co-founder & CEO at Zapier)
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of First Round Capital's In Depth podcast, Zapier co-founder and CEO Wade Foster shares tactical lessons on building a $5 billion automation platform through disciplined hiring, programmatic SEO distribution, incremental product iteration, and intellectual humility.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Brett holds 17.6% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Brett as informed peer 4.2 Guest teaching 5.1 Guest disagreement 2.4 Brett pushing back 1.8
speaking balance: gold is Brett, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 32:58 Wade rejecting the VC 'growth at all costs' hiring push
Wade firmly pushes back against conventional VC wisdom advocating hiring ahead of growth, arguing that rapid headcount scaling breaks organizations.
Hardest push from Brett ▶ 19:05 Brett challenging Wade on oversimplifying PMFBrett directly interrupts the narrative simplicity, challenging Wade on whether building Zapier was truly as intuitive and straightforward as he presented.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 10:30 Wade explaining programmatic SEO mechanics via Bingo Card CreatorWade delivers a granular breakdown of Patrick McKenzie's unit economics and explains how Zapier translated that mathematical SEO model into a zero-CAC integration directory.
Brett holds their own ▶ 44:31 Brett's thesis on executives jamming broken gears into unique startup machinesBrett demonstrates deep organizational pattern matching, eloquently describing why importing playbooks from Salesforce or Atlassian into specialized company engines causes operational failure.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Brett as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Brett pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contrarian Origins and the Influence of Veterans United | 4 | 5 | 4 | 1 | Brett lists out several contrarian choices Zapier made early on. Wade explains how their Midwest roots and watching Veterans United scale profitably without VC funding gave them skepticism toward standard Silicon Valley advice. | |
| The Plus One Philosophy and Daily Execution | 3 | 4 | 2 | 1 | Brett asks about specific principles drawn from Veterans United. Wade details the 'plus one' mindset, contrasting the unglamorous reality of daily startup execution with media depictions. | |
| Developing Zapier's Programmatic SEO Distribution Engine | 3 | 6 | 2 | 1 | Wade walks through the origin of Zapier's programmatic SEO strategy, referencing Patrick McKenzie's Bingo Card Creator economics and applying it to long-tail SaaS integration search queries. | |
| Integrating Go-to-Market with Product and SMB Focus | 4 | 5 | 3 | 2 | Brett asks whether distribution was conceived deliberately before product. Wade explains how product and go-to-market were treated as one inseparable system, resisting pushback to move upmarket prematurely. | |
| Product Iteration, Customer Validation, and the Hub-and-Spoke Model | 5 | 6 | 3 | 4 | Brett pushes back on whether Wade's narrative oversimplifies how easily things worked. Wade contrasts Zapier's immediate customer pull with past failed projects, walking through early Skype onboarding sessions. | |
| Balancing Timing, Luck, and Grinding Execution | 4 | 5 | 2 | 2 | Brett and Wade explore the balance between timing, luck, and skill. Wade highlights how human management problems proved significantly harder than deterministic code problems for technical founders. | |
| The Don't Hire Until It Hurts Philosophy | 4 | 6 | 4 | 2 | Wade explains the 'don't hire until it hurts' rule, arguing that performing every role firsthand creates clear baselines for management while critiquing the VC push for hyper-hiring. | |
| Sequencing Hiring and Early Management Mistakes | 3 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Wade breaks down the sequencing of early hires based on operational bottlenecks and openly reflects on waiting too long (until 30-40 employees) to hire experienced managers. | |
| Hiring Senior Leaders Who Roll Up Their Sleeves | 3 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Wade outlines strategies for identifying senior leaders who are willing to roll up their sleeves, sharing the example of Zapier's first CFO handling flight bookings alongside financial modeling. | |
| Avoiding Rigid Playbooks and Fostering Adaptive Problem-Solving | 6 | 4 | 2 | 2 | Brett articulates how executives often break unique company engines by importing rigid playbooks from past employers. Wade agrees and details why he values cross-disciplinary problem solvers over single-playbook operators. | |
| Twelve Years of Product Evolution: From Integrations to Ecosystem | 4 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Wade tracks Zapier's product evolution across 12 years from 1:1 point solutions to developer platforms, multi-step zaps, visual canvas workflows, and integrated AI bots. | |
| Customer-Centric Roadmaps and Network Effects vs. Competitors | 6 | 5 | 2 | 3 | Brett outlines a thesis on how SaaS categories often suffer from competitors mutual destruction, contrasting it with Zapier's dominance. Wade explains why their customer-first focus and integration network effects insulate them. | |
| Intellectual Honesty, Updating Priors, and Decision Frameworks | 5 | 5 | 2 | 2 | Brett brings up the hazard of founders calcifying their priors post-PMF. Wade cites Annie Duke's decision framework and discusses the continuous challenge of balancing intellectual honesty with executive conviction. |
Statements from this episode (22)
Foster: Veterans United is owned 50/50 by two brothers with zero outside funding
“It's owned by two brothers, 50, 50, and never raised any money.”
Foster: Startup building is mostly unglamorous, repetitive daily execution
“So much of company building is literally just like showing up day after day and doing that for a really long period of time and just putting in the work, like building companies, building startups. It's not a particularly glamorous thing in spite of what, like…”
Zapier's early customer acquisition costs rounded to zero via SEO distribution
“You know, we figured out how to, A really good distribution engine that meant our customer acquisition costs like rounded to zero.”
Foster: In 2012 only half a dozen notable tech companies hired remotely
“And the fact that there was maybe, you know, half a dozen tech companies of like name That were doing that at the time, you know, that were more than, say, 10 or 50 employees doing that. That really gave us an incredible advantage trying to attract top enginee…”
Replicating Zapier's programmatic SEO playbook today is impossible
“And if you tried to replicate it today, like, you couldn't do it because everyone has copied what Zapier has done now and It's just too competitive.”
Zapier built its search-optimized app directory before having any customers
“One of the first customers was doing that, but the app directory existed before we had a customer. It was just like, hey, we'll build this like little app directory, see if we can get people coming in through search. And if they are like, yeah, we can build a …”
Salesforce wins through its massive distribution engine, not product superiority
“The thing that actually helps Salesforce win. It's not necessarily that the product is amazing. It's that they have this incredible distribution engine that is really difficult to compete against.”
Foster: Product and go-to-market must be designed together from day one
“Product market fit is not just about the product. It's about the market too. You need these things to like coexist. And in many ways, that's what made Zapier hum is that the product and the go to market motion are inextricably linked. They work as one fluid mo…”
Foster: Zapier remains focused on SMBs, not enterprise customers
“We're still not an enterprise company. We still like SMB is our bread and butter. That's who we solve for.”
Foster: Product-market fit is obvious because customer demand makes growth easy
“How do you know if you have product market fit? And I'm always like, well, you know, because people want what you have. It's not actually that hard if people actually want what you're selling. They don't want it, then everything seems hard. Everything feels im…”
Zapier launched in a narrow window between API availability and high competition
“If you tried to build a company like ours before, I don't think you have like all these APIs that you can go connect and do this stuff. Like most companies aren't building and doing stuff in this way. If you try and build it, you know, a year later, there's al…”
Startup people problems are often just symptoms of underlying business model issues
“A good business makes a lot of this stuff a lot easier. Like, if you're making good money, if you're growing, if there's plenty of opportunity to go around, there's plenty of money to go around, salaries and bonuses and things like that, everything gets way ea…”
'Don't hire until it hurts' forces founders to learn every role firsthand
“We had this rule, don't hire till it hurts... One, it meant we did every single job. So we understood every piece of our business. So when we hired somebody in that meant we knew exactly how they were going to be effective, what was going to help them win. And…”
Foster: Scaling from 10 to 100 employees would have ruined early Zapier
“As a first time founder, like if I tried to go 10 to a hundred, I think we would have ruined a lot of stuff inside the business.”
Zapier only ever raised a $1.3 million seed round
“We raised the 1.3 million seed round. That's all we raised.”
Zapier reached 40 employees before hiring anyone with prior management experience
“I think it took us till we probably had 30 or 40 people before we hired someone who had been a manager before into the company, which in hindsight was just like far too long.”
Foster: Hiring senior executives willing to do tactical work is game-changing
“But if you can find somebody who has all the executive skill sets, who is willing to join your company and able to roll their sleeves up and do the job, that is a game changing hiring.”
Foster: Dynamic problem solvers are more valuable than single-playbook masters
“It's way more fun and way more valuable to work with folks who have a much more dynamic problem solving skill set, where they can borrow from a bunch of different areas, and then they can start to put those puzzle pieces together in novel ways.”
Zapier platform supports 6,000 apps, up from two at launch
“And of course, like a through line for all of this is just the explosion of number apps that are supported on the platform from two to now 6000 today.”
Foster: Zapier focused maniacally on one major product initiative at a time
“And that's like for most of Zapier's history, you know, it's a relatively small ish team. And so a lot of it is, you know, a maniacal focus focus on like the singular thing. ... Generally we were always trying to think through, like, what is the one thing that…”
Foster: Copying a competitor's product roadmap feature-by-feature leads companies astray
“I think you get into this really tricky thing where you're just literally like paying attention to somebody else's roadmap and just being like, Hey, we just got to keep up. You know, we just got to match it one to one because oftentimes you don't actually know…”
Smart leaders are more vulnerable to cognitive traps through better rationalization
“The more you're even aware of these phenomenon, like the more you, and the smarter you are, like the more it actually dangerous you are to these things because you actually get better at rationalizing your way through it.”