why aren't all 15 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Humanoid robots will not displace labor near-term due to massive shortages
“I think in like the near and medium case, we're really not going to be displacing that much labor. I think what we're seeing every day we're walking into a warehouse or manufacturing a retail scenario, they have a tremendous amount of unemployment. The turnove…”
Opinion
Rabois: Meta, Google, and Apple cannot accurately assess undiscovered talent
“So you've got to go find people who haven't yet proven what they can do that these large organizations think meta, Think Google, think Apple, think Amazon, think Microsoft, or even these days open AI. They don't know how to assess these people.”
Insight
Lieberman: Founders should scare away wrong candidates rather than soften culture expectations
“A huge failure of entrepreneurs in general, especially in the early days of their business, is to set unrealistic expectations of what the work or the culture is like because they are afraid of scaring away employees. Bezos takes the complete opposite approach…”
Disclosure
Bezos identifies primarily as an inventor seeking atypical solutions
“I'm really an inventor, and I look at things, and I can come up with Atypical solutions, and, you know, and then I can create a hundred such atypical solutions for something. 99 of them may not survive, you know, scrutiny, but one of those 100 is like maybe th…”
Disclosure
Bezos: Amazon and Blue Origin meetings start with 30-minute silent memo reading
“Meetings at Amazon and Blue Origin are unusual. When we get new, when new people come in, like a new executive joins, they're a little taken aback sometimes, because a typical meeting, We'll start with a six-page narratively structured memo, and we do study ha…”
Opinion
Silicon Valley cultures split between lifestyle perks and mission-driven execution
“And I think there's like, there's, like, there's basically two bifurcated cultures out here in Silicon Valley. There's the culture of like, you know, Google, Facebook, Pinterest, that like, you know, we're here for you. We'll pay you as much money as possible,…”
Insight
Lieberman: Founders and investors must separate present facts from future narrative
“A really good force function for founders or investors or potential employees of startups is to be really good at separating what is story from what is fact. It is important to know both, but fact is what makes a business strong or weak today. Story is a possi…”
Insight
Lieberman: Written communication is one of best ways to solidify clear thinking
“And I think a written culture of communication is one of the best ways to solidify clear thinking across the organization.”
Insight
Lieberman: High-growth cultures require treating business like scientific experiments
“If you want a high growth entrepreneurial culture, you need to treat your business like a science experiment where your employees are like lab workers creating hypotheses and running constant tests, making decisions based on data and results versus having an e…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Bezos: A good six-page memo can take two weeks to write
“A good six-page memo might take two weeks to write. You have to write it. You have to rewrite it. You have to edit it. You have to talk to people about it. They have to poke holes in it for you. You write it again. It might take two weeks.”
Disclosure
Bezos: Early Amazon investors were told they had a 30% chance of break-even
“Told all of our early investors that I thought there was a 30% chance of success, by which I'd just been getting your money back, not, like, Not what actually happened.”
Insight
Rief: High-utility products succeed despite terrible visual design
“It was the classic thing where product sucks but people still use it. Like, oh, I mean, it's like Amazon. Amazon looks terrible. It's the worst design site that I use, yet people, people use it.”
Assertion Supported
Lieberman: Amazon Grew 1997 Revenue by 838% to $147 Million
“Revenue was up 838% to one hundred and forty-seven million dollars in revenue from just fifteen million a year earlier. The number of unique customers grew from 180,000 to 1.5 million, and the employee base three acts from 158 to 614.”
Assertion Supported
Lieberman: Costco ranks as sixth largest global retailer with $167B revenue
“In 1993, Costco ended up merging with Sol Price's Price Club, and it has gone on to boast one hundred and sixty seven billion dollars in revenue. It has more than 800 locations worldwide, and it is the sixth largest retailer in the world behind Walmart, Amazon…”
Assertion Supported
Alex Lieberman's tweet about Amazon shareholder letters got 4,800 likes
“A few months back, I posted on Twitter asking, anyone want to form a learning group to read, reflect, and discuss all of Amazon shareholder letters? That simple question and that simple tweet got 4800 likes and 1100 responses.”