why aren't all 2,397 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 42 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Supported
NeXT Team Used Channel Stuffing to Inflate Sales Figures to Jobs
“The team reported sales figures by determining the number of units given to distributors, not sales to final customers. Distributors didn't have to pay right away. They got the machines on credit. Next then immediately counted these as sales, even though no mo…”
Insight
Steve Jobs: With Elite Talent, the CEO Works at the Bottom
“If you don't treat talented workers right, they can go get another job in 10 minutes. So a strange thing happens, which is the sort of the hierarchy of power inverts and the CEO is actually at the bottom. So I sort of feel like I work for most of these people …”
Assertion Supported
BeOS Founder Brought No Laptop or Presentation to Crucial Apple Pitch
“The founder of B walks in and he pursued a different approach. He hadn't brought anyone else from his team. He wasn't carrying a laptop. In fact, he had prepared no presentation whatsoever because the two teams had been kept separate.”
Insight
Phil Knight: People in their twenties should seek a calling, not a career
“I'd tell men and women in their mid-twenties not to settle for a job or a profession or even a career. Seek a calling. Even if you don't know what that means, seek it. If you're following your calling, the fatigue will be easier to bear. The disappointments wi…”
What-if
Schwarzenegger: Childhood Emotional Deprivation Created the Drive to Succeed
“If I had gotten everything I needed, meaning emotionally as a kid, and been well balanced, I wouldn't have had my drive.”
Insight
Demis Hassabis: Doing your best means pushing to the brink of collapse
“The only way I could know is if I basically push myself to the point just before death, because that is literally when you've done your best. If you die, and by die, I mean burnout or something, then you've slightly overdone it. It's like running a marathon. Y…”
Opinion
Hassabis: Elite chess wastes immense mental effort better spent on science
“Surely that immense collective mental effort should have been harnessed to some higher cause, say science or medicine. I thought we were wasting our minds.”
Insight
Founders Can Over-Inspire Teams Into Mutual Delusion
“Who would have thought that you can actually inspire people too much, he said. Well, you can, because you can get to the point where you're deluding your team, and then they are deluding you also. It's like I'm making this judgment that this is possible becaus…”
Insight
Thiel's Model: Consensus Voting in VC Dilutes Moonshot Returns into Mediocrity
“The way he saw things, if investments were chosen based on voting, the Founders Fund portfolio would consist of middle-of-the-road startups to which nobody objected. Given that all the profits in venture come from a few improbable moonshots, this sort of conse…”
Opinion
Academic Culture Is Cautious on Innovation but Ruthlessly Competitive in Publishing
“The culture of academia could be both boringly cautious and terrifyingly competitive. Boring because it pursued incremental advances. Terrifying because scientists cut each other's throats To be the first to publish.”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
A Single DeepMind Team Used More Compute Than Google's Entire Gmail Network
“In some weeks, a single research team at DeepMind Might gobble up more computational resources than Google's worldwide Gmail network, which had nine hundred million users.”
Insight
The Internet Is to AI What Fossil Fuels Were to Industry
“The analogy here is the internet has been for AI what coal and oil were for the industrial revolution. You could just literally drill a hole in the ground and get black gold. Today, we can just download all of the internet. Neither of these resources had to be…”
Assertion Supported
SpaceX designed Dragon's docking mechanism using off-the-shelf bike shocks
“The Dragon's capsule docking mechanism was reinvented from off-the-shelf bike shocks And catalog parts instead of adopting NASA's existing design.”
Assertion Supported
NASA found SpaceX developed Falcon 9 for a fraction of legacy costs
“A NASA study found SpaceX developed Falcon nine for roughly four hundred and forty million. They estimated the same work with traditional contractors would have cost three to 10 times that amount.”
Insight
Reusing a booster 20 times creates a steeper learning curve than manufacturing
“If making 40 rockets creates a manufacturing learning curve, flying the same rocket 20 times creates an operational learning curve that's even steeper.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
SpaceX runs separate risk profiles for Dragon, Falcon 9, and Starship
“The crucial distinction is between development and operations. SpaceX runs both, but with completely different risk profiles. So for the Dragon, it carries crew. It can never fail. So there's large margins of safety, there's exhaustive testing, there's conserv…”
Insight
Sales teams undermine engineering by promising customers bespoke features that add complexity
“In most other companies, the sales and business teams are natural enemies of engineering logic. They promise the customer whatever they want, which creates the very bespoke complexity that the first principles thinking is trying to delete.”
Assertion Supported
Gwynne Shotwell convinced NASA and the Pentagon to accept standardized rocket launches
“She made it so the world's most conservative buyers, NASA and the Pentagon would accept a radical new model of standardization.”
Insight
SpaceX's moat relies on vertical integration and first principles functioning as one
“The answer to what's hard to copy isn't any single tactic. It's that the tactics are a system. Copy one without the others, and it breaks down. First, principles designed without vertical integration gives you targets you can't reach. Vertical integration with…”
Assertion Supported
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang prefers to torture people into greatness
“There's a line from the founder of Nvidia, Jensen Wong. He said that he doesn't like to give up on people. He'd rather torture them into greatness.”
Insight
Senra: Asking for advice creates partners, but asking for feedback creates critics
“If you ask for someone's feedback, you'll get a critic, but instead, if you ask for advice, you'll get a partner.”
Insight
Follow personal intuition over rational advice when making major career decisions
“To the best of my ability, I followed my intuition to make career turns and have been recommended against doing so every time. It helps to realize that it's better to follow the universe or follow, in my case, I would change that sentence, follow your intuitio…”
Insight
Conventional rules direct creators toward average behaviors
“Rules direct us to average behaviors. If we're aiming to create works that are exceptional, most rules don't apply.”
Insight
Doing creative work without outsourcing compounds into uniquely valuable results
“I think the hard way is the right way. So many times people give me advice that I should be outsourcing X or I should be outsourcing Y. And when I try to explain to them is what makes this special is the compounding of this over 10 years. It's because I didn't…”
Insight
Creators of the greatest companies are obsessive at massive personal cost
“The people that are usually really great that create the greatest companies, the greatest inventions, the greatest technology. They're usually very obsessive and it causes them to discount other parts of their life.”
Insight
Wanting to change the world actively undermines the quest for greatness
“Fear of criticism, attachment to a commercial result, competing with past work, time and resource constraints, the aspiration of wanting to change the world, and any story beyond, I want to make the best thing I can make, whatever it is, are all undermining fo…”
Insight
Brad Jacobs demands unrestricted employee access immediately upon signing M&A deals
“I negotiate explicitly for unrestricted access to the company from the moment we sign an agreement. Immediate access to employees is an essential condition for us. This is not commonplace in M&A.”
Insight
Dell: You have to be full of yourself to do anything important
“Was I a little full of myself at 19? Sure I was. I think you have to be to do anything important.”
Opinion
Senra: Koenigsegg's communication rivals Steve Jobs, Elon Musk, and Charlie Munger
“And part of the reason I think he's able to do that is because of his incredible communication skills. He doesn't just express ideas. He makes them memorable. It reminds me a lot of Charlie Munger, reminds me of Elon Musk, reminds me of Steve Jobs.”
Insight
Dietrich Mateschitz: Small price premiums fail to establish distinct product categories
“If we only had a 15% price premium, we'd merely be a premium brand among soft drinks, and not a different category altogether.”
Insight
Dietrich Mateschitz: The most dangerous thing for a brand is low interest
“The most dangerous thing
For a brand, branded product is low interest.”
Insight
Dietrich Mateschitz: Red Bull marketing must center on product, not founder
“Since it's not me on the shelf for sale, but Red Bull, it's perfectly logical that Red Bull is at the center of our marketing activities and not the person.”
Assertion Partly supported
Dietrich Mateschitz bought an Austrian tabloid purely to keep himself out
“He's the richest man in Austria, right? And there's a society magazine. So like, you know, I don't, I guess we'd call it like kind of like a tabloid or like a gossip magazine in the States, but he actually buys it. He buys this magazine just so he will not app…”
Insight
Dietrich Mateschitz: Product bans serve as free advertising that multiplies demand
“If something's banned, it's all it is is free propaganda. It's free advertising. It's going to drastically increase the amount of demand.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Senra: Mateschitz rejected profit maximization as the primary corporate goal
“If someone says to him that the primary goal of a company is to maximize profit, he simply declares that to be incorrect. He thinks longer term and more broadly than his competitors.”
Insight
Elite performers win through intense information-gathering effort rather than raw talent
“Now, another trait that Rockefeller had is this maxim that says the good ones, no more. This is not an issue of talent or intelligence. This is an issue of effort. They just collect more information. They know more about what they're doing.”
Assertion Supported
Rockefeller's wealth grew more during his retirement than his active career
“What's crazy is Rockefeller's wealth wealth grows more in retirement than it did when he was active. And it did this because he never sold his stock.”
Assertion Supported
Standard Oil secretly funded patent litigation to financially bleed a rival
“Standard Oil had secretly approached Tweedle and told them that they will cover all the legal costs when Tweedle gets sued for patent infringement, which indeed happens. They then purposely drag the case through the court slowly to bleed the smaller company. E…”
Assertion Partly supported
Rockefeller routinely bribed politicians and paid off critical journalists
“So Rockefeller would buy politicians and he would make sure that they stayed bought. When the media wrote critical articles about standard oil, Rockefeller would buy off the reporters in the media too.”
Insight
Ellison: Software Buyers Are Forced to Assemble Systems Like Car Parts
“He says, if Detroit ran like Silicon Valley, nobody would sell cars. They would just sell parts. Customers would have to figure out which were the best parts. Maybe you'd grab a Honda engine, a Ford transmission, a BMW chassis, a GM electrical system, and buy …”
Insight
Ellison: The Human Brain's Primary Purpose Is Self-Deception
“One of Larry Ellison's favorite maxims is the brain's primary purpose is deception. And the primary person to be deceived is the owner.”
Insight
Programming Liberated Ellison by Rewarding Output Over Behavioral Conformity
“People, teacher, coaches, bosses, they want you to conform to some standard of behavior they deem correct. They measure and reward you on how well you conform, how you arrive on time, dress appropriately, exhibit a properly differential attitude, as opposed to…”
Insight
Ellison: Mistaking the Present for the Future Is Tech's Worst Mistake
“They were mistaking the present for the future. It is the worst mistake a tech company can make.”
Assertion Supported
Oracle Slashed Its Global Product Pricing Staff From 200 to Under 10
“We had about 200 people around the world involved in analyzing and reanalyzing, setting and resetting prices. It costs us a fortune in duplication of effort. We were competing against ourselves. It was embarrassing. Now we have less than 10 people working on p…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Ellison Avoids One-on-One Meetings to Ensure Shared Situational Awareness
“Ellison does not like doing one-on-ones with his direct reports. He prefers communicating as a group so everyone knows what's going on.”
Assertion Supported
Jensen Huang refused board recommendations to hire a COO
“Jensen had steadfastly refused to change his management philosophy, even when new board members joined and recommended that he hired a chief operating officer to reduce his administrative burden.”
Insight
Jensen Huang views pain endurance as a greater superpower than intelligence
“Of all the things that I value most about my abilities, intelligence is not top of that list. My ability to endure pain and suffering, my ability to work on something for a very, very long period of time, my ability to handle setbacks and see the opportunity j…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Huang: Nvidia avoids periodic five-year plans in favor of continuous planning
“We don't do a periodic planning system. The reason for that is because the world is a living, breathing thing. We just plan continuously. There's no five-year plan.”